HSC Study

Individual Contracts and High Income Earners

What common law individual contracts are, how they differ from enterprise agreements, why awards do not apply to high income earners with a guarantee of annual earnings above the high income threshold, why Australian Workplace Agreements were abolished, and the benefits and risks of individual wage determination.

20 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management

Assumes you have read Enterprise Agreements.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • A common law contract is an individual agreement between an employer and one employee. It is enforced in the ordinary courts, not the Fair Work Commission.
  • For most employees, a contract cannot go below the NES or the relevant award. It can only add to them, for example with bonuses or above-award pay.
  • High income earners are the exception. If an employee earns above the high income threshold ($190,100 from 1 July 2026) and the employer gives a written guarantee of annual earnings, the award does not apply. Only the NES and the contract apply.
  • High income earners not covered by an award or agreement also cannot claim unfair dismissal.
  • Individual arrangements are the most common way pay is set: 38.5 per cent of employees in May 2025, including managers, professionals and many small business employees.
  • Australian Workplace Agreements, individual statutory agreements that could undercut awards, were abolished by the Fair Work Act because employers used their stronger bargaining power to remove entitlements.

Common law individual contracts

AnswersWhat are individual contracts and how do they differ from enterprise agreements?

Common law contract

An individual employment agreement between an employer and a single employee setting out pay and conditions. It sits outside the formal industrial relations system, is enforced through the courts, and must meet the NES and, for employees covered by an award, the award.

As your notes explain, individual contracts are often only a page or two, and give employers and employees flexibility to tailor pay, including bonuses, profit sharing, shares and salary packaging. They are used most for executives, managers and professionals, and by small businesses that pay above the award.

Enterprise agreementCommon law contract
PartiesEmployer and a group of employees, usually through a unionEmployer and one employee
ApprovalApproved by the Fair Work CommissionNo approval
Relation to awardCan vary award terms if employees are better off overallCannot reduce award entitlements, except for high income earners
EnforcementFair Work Commission and Fair Work OmbudsmanCourts; award and NES breaches can still be pursued by the Ombudsman
Industrial actionProtected action during bargainingNo protected action

Australian Workplace Agreements. Individual statutory agreements were introduced in 1996, and Work Choices removed the test that they be no worse than the award. Your notes explain that they were often imposed without genuine negotiation, because an individual worker has much less bargaining power than an employer, and some were used to remove penalty rates and overtime. The Fair Work Act abolished them.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

For an employee earning below the high income threshold, what is true of a common law individual contract?

Select one answer

Hint 1Floor.

Hint 2Award still applies.

Hint 3Can add, not subtract.

Employment contracts for high income earners

AnswersHow are high income earners treated differently in the national system?

High income threshold

An annually indexed earnings level set under the Fair Work Act. An award does not apply to an employee who earns more than the threshold and has a written guarantee of annual earnings, and employees above it who are not covered by an award or agreement cannot make an unfair dismissal claim.

YearHigh income threshold
From 1 July 2025$183,100
From 1 July 2026$190,100

Source: Fair Work Commission.

The guarantee of annual earnings. An award-covered employee who earns above the threshold can be taken out of the award if the employer gives a written guarantee to pay at least the threshold over the year. The employee is then covered only by the NES and their contract.

Why the exception exists. Your notes explain that the award system is a safety net for workers with little bargaining power. High income earners usually have scarce skills and strong bargaining power, so they can negotiate their own pay and conditions. Applying award rules on overtime, rosters and penalty rates to a senior engineer or lawyer would add complexity without protecting anyone who needs it.

Unfair dismissal. Employees above the threshold who are not covered by an award or agreement cannot claim unfair dismissal. For those who can, compensation is capped at the lower of six months' pay or half the threshold ($95,050 from July 2026).

Exam question

Standard · about 7 min

4 marks

Explain how employment contracts for high income earners are treated in the national wage determination system, and why. (4 marks)

Hint 1Threshold.

Hint 2Guarantee of annual earnings.

Hint 3Bargaining power.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying high income earners have no protections.

    Why it happens: Awards do not apply.

    The NES still apply.

Written for this site.

Individual wage determination: benefits and risks

AnswersWhat are the economic effects of individual contracts?

Benefits

  • Flexibility and efficiency. Pay can reflect each worker's skills and performance, rewarding productivity and helping firms attract scarce skills. This improves allocative efficiency.
  • Responsiveness. Individual pay adjusts quickly to labour market conditions. Your notes explain that individual arrangements drove much of the pick-up in wages growth after the pandemic, as employers raised pay to attract workers in a tight market.
  • Lower costs. Small businesses avoid the cost of bargaining.

Risks

  • Bargaining power. Low-skilled workers negotiating alone have little power. Without strong enforcement of the NES and awards, they risk being underpaid. Your notes cite the underpayment of workers at 7-Eleven and Domino's franchises between 2015 and 2017.
  • Inequality. Individual bargaining rewards those with scarce skills, widening wage dispersion between high and low earners.
  • Pay secrecy. Individual pay can hide discrimination; since 2022, pay secrecy clauses have been banned so employees can discuss their pay, which helps reveal gender pay gaps.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Evaluate the use of individual contracts in determining pay and conditions in Australia. (5 marks)

Hint 1Flexibility.

Hint 2Bargaining power.

Hint 3Inequality and enforcement.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • One-sided answer.

    Why it happens: Evaluate requires a judgement.

    Weigh flexibility against equity.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

High income earners have no legal protections because they are outside the award system.

Why it happens: Awards do not apply to them.

High income earners with a guarantee of annual earnings are outside the award, but they are still covered by the National Employment Standards, such as annual leave, personal leave and notice of termination, and by their contract, which is enforceable in the courts.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'High income earners have no legal protection at work because awards do not apply to them.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1NES.

Hint 2Contract.

Hint 3Courts.

Why individual arrangements are the largest category

It may seem surprising that individual arrangements cover more employees than awards or enterprise agreements. The category is broad: it includes chief executives on complex contracts, but also many small business employees who are paid a little above the award by a simple letter of offer. For most of these workers, the award is still the floor, so individual arrangements are better seen as award plus than as a separate system.

This matters for policy. Changes to award rates flow through to many individual arrangements, because employers who pay a margin above the award often maintain it when the award rises. And the growth of individual arrangements means that the pay of a large share of workers responds to market conditions rather than to tribunal decisions, which makes wages more flexible over the business cycle, but also more dependent on each worker's bargaining power.