Dispute Resolution
What industrial disputes are and why they matter for the economy, the forms of industrial action, conciliation and arbitration, when the Fair Work Commission can intervene, the long decline in working days lost, and recent cases such as the 2025 Sydney rail dispute.
25 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management
Assumes you have read Enterprise Agreements.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- An industrial dispute is a disagreement between employers and employees that leads to action disrupting production.
- Forms of industrial action: strikes, work bans and go-slows by employees; lockouts by employers.
- Industrial action is lawful (protected) only during enterprise bargaining, after a secret ballot and notice.
- Why dispute resolution matters: disputes cost firms output and profits, cost workers income, disrupt supply to other industries, and can damage Australia's reputation as a reliable supplier.
- The Fair Work Commission resolves disputes through:
- conciliation: helping the parties reach their own agreement;
- arbitration: making a binding decision, now used only in limited cases.
- The FWC can intervene when bargaining is not in good faith, when bargaining is intractable, or when industrial action threatens significant harm to the economy or public. In 2025 it ordered a cooling-off period in the Sydney rail dispute.
- Trend: working days lost fell from about 4 million in 1981 to about 167,000 in 2025.
Industrial disputes and why they matter
AnswersWhat are industrial disputes and why is dispute resolution needed?
- Industrial dispute
A disagreement between employers and employees over pay or conditions that leads to industrial action disrupting the production process.
As your notes explain, disputes can lead to:
| Action | By whom | What it involves |
|---|---|---|
| Strike | Employees | Withdrawing labour and refusing to work |
| Work ban | Employees | Refusing to perform particular duties, such as overtime |
| Lockout | Employers | Refusing employees access to the workplace |
- Protected industrial action
Industrial action taken during bargaining for an enterprise agreement that meets the requirements of the Fair Work Act, including approval in a secret ballot and at least three working days' notice. Employees and employers taking protected action are immune from most legal claims.
Action outside bargaining, or without a ballot and notice, is unprotected and can lead to penalties.
Why effective dispute resolution matters. Your notes explain it is needed to:
- resolve intractable disputes quickly, limiting the length of strikes;
- limit damage to firms, through lost production, profits and customers, and to workers, through lost income;
- balance bargaining power, so neither side can impose outcomes;
- avoid disruption to other industries that rely on the affected supply, and to Australia's reputation as a reliable exporter, as when disputes at ports delay shipments.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
When is industrial action protected under the Fair Work Act?
Hint 1Bargaining period.
Hint 2Ballot.
Hint 3Notice.
Conciliation, arbitration and the Fair Work Commission
AnswersHow does the Fair Work Commission resolve disputes?
- Conciliation
A dispute resolution process in which a third party, such as the Fair Work Commission, meets with the employer and employees and helps them reach their own agreement.
- Arbitration
A dispute resolution process in which a tribunal hears both sides and hands down a legally binding decision.
As your notes explain, Australia has moved from compulsory arbitration, where tribunals routinely decided outcomes, to a system where parties are expected to resolve disputes at the workplace, with arbitration used only in limited circumstances. Every award and enterprise agreement must include a dispute settlement procedure, which usually requires the parties to try to resolve a dispute themselves before referring it to the Commission for conciliation.
When the Commission can intervene
| Situation | What the FWC can do |
|---|---|
| A party is not bargaining in good faith, such as refusing to meet or disclose information | Make bargaining orders requiring the party to comply |
| Bargaining is intractable, with no reasonable prospect of agreement | Make an intractable bargaining declaration and then a workplace determination that settles the terms (strengthened in 2022) |
| Industrial action threatens significant harm to the economy, to the population's safety or welfare, or to third parties | Suspend or terminate the action, including a cooling-off period |
| The agreement's dispute term refers a dispute to the FWC | Conciliate and, if the term allows, arbitrate |
The 2025 Sydney rail dispute. Rail unions took industrial action over pay in early 2025, causing widespread delays and cancellations. The NSW government applied to the Fair Work Commission, and in February a full bench ordered a cooling-off period until 1 July, finding that pausing the action was in the public interest. The case shows the Commission balancing the right to take protected action against harm to third parties, here millions of commuters and businesses.
Exam question
Harder · about 9 min
5 marks
Distinguish between conciliation and arbitration, and explain the circumstances in which the Fair Work Commission can intervene in an industrial dispute. Refer to a recent example. (5 marks)
Hint 1Helps agree versus decides.
Hint 2Good faith, intractable, harm.
Hint 3Sydney rail 2025.
Where students lose marks on this one
Treating conciliation and arbitration as the same.
Why it happens: Both involve a third party.
Only arbitration is binding.
Written for this site.
The decline in industrial disputes
AnswersWhy have industrial disputes declined?
| Year | Working days lost |
|---|---|
| 1981 | about 4 million |
| 2025 | about 167,000 |
Sources: ABS, Industrial Disputes, Australia, December 2025; historical ABS series.
In 2025 there were 213 disputes involving about 112,500 employees. Of the disputes that ended in the June quarter 2025, about three in four arose from enterprise bargaining.
Your notes explain the decline reflects:
- enterprise bargaining, which restricts protected action to the bargaining period and focuses negotiation at the workplace;
- legal limits on industrial action, including ballots, notice and penalties for unprotected action;
- lower union membership, now about one in eight employees;
- structural change towards services, where strikes are less common than in manufacturing and mining;
- greater competition, which makes firms and workers more aware that disputes can cost jobs.
Is fewer disputes always better? Fewer disputes mean less lost output. But your notes point out that the Productivity Commission has recognised disputes can play a positive role by correcting power imbalances and can improve outcomes in the long run. Some economists argue the very low level of disputes in the 2010s reflected weak worker bargaining power, which contributed to slow wages growth.
Chain of reasoning
Restrictions on industrial action rises
Ballots, notice, bargaining period onlyWorking days lost falls
Less disruption to productionWorker bargaining power falls
Less power in negotiationsWages growth falls
Part of the explanation for weak 2010s wages
Exam question
Harder · about 7 min
4 marks
Explain why the number of working days lost to industrial disputes has fallen, and discuss whether this is beneficial for the economy. (4 marks)
Hint 1Legal limits and bargaining.
Hint 2Unions and structure.
Hint 3Bargaining power.
Where students lose marks on this one
Assuming fewer disputes are always better.
Why it happens: Disputes cost output.
Consider bargaining power and wages.
Written for this site.
Common mistake
The Fair Work Commission decides the outcome of most workplace disputes through arbitration.
Why it happens: Australia had compulsory arbitration for most of the twentieth century.
Today the Commission mainly conciliates. Arbitration is limited to specific cases, such as intractable bargaining or where an agreement's dispute term allows it. Parties are expected to resolve disputes themselves at the workplace first.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'The Fair Work Commission settles most workplace disputes by arbitration.' Which response is best?
Hint 1Compulsory arbitration ended.
Hint 2Conciliation.
Hint 3Limited arbitration.
Public sector disputes
Many recent disputes have been in the public sector: nurses, doctors, psychiatrists, teachers and transport workers. These are different from private sector disputes in two ways. First, the employer is a government that must weigh pay claims against its budget, so wage decisions are partly fiscal decisions. Second, the harm from action falls mostly on the public, not on the employer's profits, so governments are more likely to seek orders suspending action.
After years of public sector wage caps, including a 2.5 per cent cap in NSW that was removed in 2023, many public sector workers sought large increases to make up for real wage losses when inflation rose. This explains why so many recent disputes have involved state governments as employers, and why governments are central to dispute resolution today.