Enterprise Agreements
How enterprise agreements are negotiated and approved, good faith bargaining and the better off overall test, the types of agreement including multi-employer bargaining, the decline in enterprise bargaining over the 2010s and the 2022 reforms to revive it, and the link between bargaining and productivity.
25 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management
Assumes you have read Awards.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- An enterprise agreement is a collective agreement on pay and conditions between an employer and a group of employees, usually negotiated through a union, and approved by the Fair Work Commission.
- Rules for bargaining:
- both sides must bargain in good faith: attend meetings, share relevant information and genuinely consider proposals;
- protected industrial action is allowed only during bargaining, after a secret ballot and notice;
- the agreement must meet the NES and pass the better off overall test (BOOT): each employee must be better off than under the award.
- Types: single-enterprise, multi-enterprise (several employers) and greenfields (a new enterprise with no employees yet).
- Coverage: about 35 per cent of employees were paid under collective agreements in May 2025. Bargaining declined over the 2010s as employers let agreements lapse and fell back on awards.
- Reforms since 2022: easier multi-employer bargaining in low-paid sectors such as childcare, arbitration of intractable disputes, and termination of old "zombie" agreements.
- Why it matters: enterprise bargaining links pay to productivity at the workplace. It drove productivity gains in the 1990s, but recent agreements have focused on pay more than productivity.
How enterprise agreements are made
AnswersHow is an enterprise agreement negotiated and approved?
- Enterprise agreement
A collective agreement setting wages and conditions for a group of employees at one or more workplaces, negotiated between an employer (or employers) and employees or their union, and approved by the Fair Work Commission.
- Better off overall test (BOOT)
A test applied by the Fair Work Commission before approving an enterprise agreement, which requires that each employee would be better off overall under the agreement than under the relevant modern award.
As your notes explain, the Fair Work Act gave employees a right to bargain. If a majority of employees want an agreement, the employer must bargain.
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| Bargaining | Employer and bargaining representatives, usually a union, negotiate. Both must bargain in good faith |
| Industrial action | Protected action, such as strikes or work bans, is lawful only during bargaining, after a secret ballot and three days' notice |
| Vote | A majority of employees who vote must approve the agreement |
| Approval | The Fair Work Commission checks the agreement meets the NES and passes the BOOT |
| Operation | Usually runs for three to four years. It continues after its nominal expiry until replaced or terminated |
Agreements usually cover wage increases over their life, rosters and hours, allowances, and changes to work practices that are meant to raise productivity. Each must include a flexibility term and a dispute resolution term.
Types of agreement
| Type | Parties |
|---|---|
| Single-enterprise | One employer and its employees |
| Multi-enterprise | Two or more employers and their employees, such as several childcare centres |
| Greenfields | A genuinely new enterprise with no employees yet, made between the employer and a union |
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Before approving an enterprise agreement, what must the Fair Work Commission be satisfied of?
Hint 1Compared with the award.
Hint 2Overall.
Hint 3NES.
Trends and recent reform
AnswersWhy did enterprise bargaining decline and what has been done about it?
The decline. Your notes explain that coverage fell over the 2010s. Collective agreements covered about 35 per cent of employees in May 2025, and many employers let agreements expire and moved staff back onto awards. Explanations include:
- the BOOT was applied strictly, making agreements harder to approve;
- bargaining is costly and slow, especially for small businesses;
- lower union membership, now about one in eight employees;
- growth in industries, such as hospitality and care, where bargaining has never been common.
Because agreements run for several years, wages under them adjust slowly. Together with public sector wage caps, this contributed to weak wages growth in the late 2010s.
The 2022 reforms. The Secure Jobs, Better Pay Act aimed to revive bargaining:
- Multi-employer bargaining. A new supported bargaining stream lets the Commission bring low-paid sectors into a single agreement. The first was early childhood education and care, where a multi-employer agreement and Commonwealth funding delivered a 15 per cent pay rise over two years from December 2024.
- Intractable bargaining. Where negotiations have no prospect of agreement, the Commission can make a workplace determination that settles the outstanding terms.
- A simpler BOOT, applied to the agreement as a whole rather than to every hypothetical roster.
- Zombie agreements, made before 2010, were automatically terminated from December 2023.
Employer groups argue multi-employer bargaining raises the risk of industry-wide strikes and pattern bargaining. Unions argue it gives low-paid workers, mostly women, bargaining power they never had at a single workplace.
Exam question
Harder · about 7 min
4 marks
Explain why enterprise bargaining declined over the 2010s and how the Secure Jobs, Better Pay reforms aimed to revive it. (4 marks)
Hint 1BOOT and cost.
Hint 2Unions and industries.
Hint 3Multi-employer and intractable.
Where students lose marks on this one
Blaming only unions.
Why it happens: Union membership fell.
Rules, costs and industry structure also mattered.
Written for this site.
Enterprise bargaining and productivity
AnswersHow does enterprise bargaining affect productivity and wages?
The case for enterprise bargaining. It lets pay and conditions reflect the circumstances of each workplace, so that:
- wage increases can be traded for productivity improvements, such as more flexible rosters or new technology;
- efficient, growing firms can pay more to attract workers, improving allocative efficiency;
- wage rises funded by productivity do not need to be passed on as higher prices, so they are less inflationary.
Your notes explain that labour productivity growth averaged about 2.2 per cent a year from 1991 to 2004, when enterprise bargaining removed outdated work practices.
The limits. Recent agreements have focused more on wages and avoiding industrial action than on productivity. The Productivity Commission has argued the BOOT could be more flexible so that agreements can trade some award conditions for productivity. Bargaining power also matters: workers with scarce skills, such as in mining, gain large increases, while those in low-paid sectors gain little, widening wage dispersion.
Chain of reasoning
Enterprise bargaining rises
Pay negotiated at the workplaceWork practices rises
Wage rises traded for flexibility and technologyLabour productivity rises
More output per hourUnit labour costs falls
Wages rise without raising cost per unitInflation falls
Less cost-push pressure
Exam question
Harder · about 9 min
5 marks
Assess the effect of enterprise bargaining on labour productivity and inflation in Australia. (5 marks)
Hint 1Trading wages for practices.
Hint 21990s evidence.
Hint 3Recent limits.
Where students lose marks on this one
Assuming bargaining always raises productivity.
Why it happens: It did in the 1990s.
Recent agreements focus on pay.
Written for this site.
Common mistake
The BOOT means an enterprise agreement must give every employee higher pay than the award.
Why it happens: The test is called better off overall.
The BOOT compares the whole package with the award. An agreement might remove a penalty rate but pay a higher base rate, as long as employees are better off overall. It cannot go below the NES.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'Under the BOOT, every condition in an enterprise agreement must be better than the award.' Which response is best?
Hint 1Whole package.
Hint 2Trade-offs.
Hint 3NES floor.
Single-employer or multi-employer?
Australia moved from centralised, industry-wide wage setting to single-enterprise bargaining in the 1990s so that pay would reflect productivity at each workplace. Multi-employer bargaining partly reverses that move.
Supporters argue single-enterprise bargaining never worked in sectors of many small employers, such as childcare, aged care and cleaning. Each centre is too small to bargain, and the main source of funding is often the government. Bargaining across the sector is the only way these workers can bargain at all.
Critics argue multi-employer agreements weaken the link between pay and the productivity of each business, and that pay rises in government-funded sectors depend on budget decisions rather than bargaining. The experience of the early childhood agreement, where the pay rise depended on Commonwealth funding, supports both views: it raised pay quickly, but through a funding decision rather than productivity gains.