HSC Study

Quantum Mechanical Nature of the Atom

Why Rutherford's atom should collapse, how Bohr's quantised energy levels explain the hydrogen spectrum, how de Broglie's matter waves explain Bohr's orbits, and how Schrödinger turned the waves into the current model of the atom.

70 min · Module 8: From the Universe to the Atom

Assumes you have read Structure of the Atom and Light: Quantum Model.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

Rutherford's problem. An orbiting electron is accelerating, and an accelerating charge radiates. The electron should lose energy and spiral into the nucleus in about s, giving out a continuous spectrum on the way. Instead, atoms are stable and hydrogen emits only a few sharp lines.

Bohr, 1913. Electrons can only occupy certain orbits, with angular momentum , and in them they do not radiate. Jumping between levels emits or absorbs one photon carrying the energy difference: . For hydrogen the levels are eV.

The spectrum. Every line is one jump. Falls to form the Balmer series, whose first four lines are visible (656, 486, 434 and 410 nm). Falls to are the ultraviolet Lyman series; falls to are the infrared Paschen series. Rydberg's equation gives any line: .

Bohr's limitations. It only works for one electron, gives no reason why the orbits are quantised, and cannot explain line intensities, fine structure or the splitting of lines in magnetic and electric fields.

de Broglie, 1924. Every moving particle has a wavelength . A stable orbit is a standing wave with a whole number of wavelengths round it, , which gives exactly Bohr's condition. Davisson and Germer, and G. P. Thomson, confirmed it by diffracting electrons from crystals in 1927.

Schrödinger, 1926. A wave equation for the electron in three dimensions. Quantised energies come out of the mathematics, and the wave function squared gives the probability of finding the electron. Orbits are replaced by orbitals, regions of probability. This is the basis of the current model.

Why Rutherford's atom should collapse

Rutherford pictured electrons orbiting a tiny nucleus like planets round the Sun. The trouble is that an electron in a circular orbit is always changing direction, so it is always accelerating, and Maxwell's theory says an accelerating charge gives out electromagnetic waves. The electron should lose energy, spiral inwards and hit the nucleus in about a hundred-billionth of a second. Its orbital frequency would rise smoothly as it fell, so the light it gave out would form a continuous spectrum.

Neither happens. Atoms last indefinitely, and hot hydrogen gas gives out light at only a few sharp wavelengths.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

According to classical electromagnetism, why should the electrons in Rutherford's model of the atom spiral into the nucleus?

Select one answer

Hint 1An electron in a circular orbit is always changing direction. What does that make it?

Hint 2What does Maxwell's theory say an accelerating charge does?

Hint 3If the electron gives out energy, what happens to its orbit?

Bohr's model

In 1913 Niels Bohr kept Rutherford's nucleus and orbiting electrons but added three new rules. He did not derive them. He chose them because they worked.

  1. Stationary states. The electron can only occupy certain orbits, each with a fixed energy. While in one of them it does not radiate, whatever classical physics says.
  2. Transitions. The electron moves between allowed orbits by emitting or absorbing one photon whose energy is exactly the difference between the two levels: . This is conservation of energy applied to a single jump.
  3. Quantised angular momentum. The allowed orbits are those in which the electron's angular momentum is a whole number multiple of : , where is the principal quantum number.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Outline Bohr's three postulates for the hydrogen atom.

Hint 1The first is about which orbits the electron may occupy, and what it does not do there.

Hint 2The second is about what happens when the electron moves from one orbit to another.

Hint 3The third picks out the allowed orbits using angular momentum.

3D model

Bohr kept the nucleus and the orbits and added one rule: only orbits whose angular momentum is a whole multiple of h/2π are allowed, and an electron in one of them does not radiate. Light is emitted only when the electron drops to a lower orbit, carrying away exactly the difference in energy, which fixes the wavelength. Choose which level it falls from and which series it falls to.

4

The rings are the allowed orbits, with nothing in between them. The electron circles without radiating, then drops to a lower orbit and a single photon carries off the difference in energy, drawn in the colour of its own wavelength. Change the series and watch the colour change with it: falling to n = 2 gives the visible Balmer lines, falling to n = 1 gives ultraviolet photons that leave no visible flash at all.

The photon is drawn in the colour of its own wavelength, so a Balmer jump comes out red, blue or violet and a Lyman jump is ultraviolet and invisible. The energies follow E = −13.6/n² eV, which is where the Rydberg equation comes from. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

The third rule, combined with the Coulomb force providing the centripetal force, fixes the size and energy of every orbit.

Worked example4 marks

Bohr's ground state of hydrogen

Use Bohr's condition for , with the electrostatic attraction of the proton providing the centripetal force, to find the radius of hydrogen's smallest orbit and the electron's speed in it. Then comment on what this shows about Bohr's model.

Force equation

In a circular orbit the Coulomb attraction is the centripetal force.

Bohr's condition

Rearrange mvr = h/2π for the speed and substitute it into the force equation.

Substitute

Use the data sheet values for h, the electron mass and e, with k = 8.99 × 10⁹ N m² C⁻².

Answer

The smallest orbit has radius m, and the electron moves at m s⁻¹. That radius matches the measured size of the hydrogen atom, a real success. But the result depends entirely on the quantisation rule, which Bohr assumed and could not justify, and the force equation includes only one electron and one proton. For any other atom, the repulsion between electrons has to be included, and the model has no way to do that.

Is that answer sensible?

The kinetic energy is J eV, which is hydrogen's measured ionisation energy.

The limitations of both models

Assesstypically 5 to 8 marks

Demands
Make a judgement of value, size or significance, and support it.
Shape
Criteria, evidence against them, then a stated judgement. The judgement must be visible.
Loses marks
Presenting balanced evidence and never committing to a verdict.

An assess answer needs a judgement, so say how successful each model was, not just what it got wrong.

ModelWhat it explainedWhat it could not explain
Rutherford (1911)Alpha scattering: a tiny, dense, positive nucleus with electrons outsideWhy orbiting electrons do not radiate and spiral in; why spectra are lines, not continuous; how the electrons are arranged
Bohr (1913)Stable atoms; the wavelengths of every hydrogen line; the Rydberg constant; the size of the atomAny atom with more than one electron; why angular momentum is quantised; why some lines are brighter than others; fine and hyperfine structure (lines that turn out to be several close lines); the splitting of lines in a magnetic field (Zeeman effect) or an electric field (Stark effect)

The deepest problem with Bohr's model is that it is a patchwork. It uses classical orbits and Newton's laws to find the orbit sizes, then switches classical electromagnetism off inside those orbits by decree. That is why it works for hydrogen but cannot be extended.

Common mistake

Bohr showed why electrons can only have certain orbits.

Why it happens: His model is remembered for quantised orbits, so it is easy to credit him with the reason too.

Bohr assumed the orbits were quantised because that gave the right spectrum. The reason came from de Broglie in 1924, later in this lesson.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student says: "Bohr's model predicted the hydrogen spectrum exactly, so applying the same rules to helium should predict the helium spectrum just as well." Which statement best explains why this is wrong?

Select one answer

Hint 1How many electrons does helium have?

Hint 2Which forces did Bohr include in his calculation for hydrogen?

Hint 3What extra force acts in helium that his model has no way to handle?

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Assess the limitations of the Rutherford and Bohr models of the atom.

Hint 1Start with Rutherford: what does classical physics predict for an orbiting electron, and what does his model not explain about spectra?

Hint 2Then show how Bohr fixed those problems, and list what his model still could not explain.

Hint 3"Assess" needs a judgement. How successful was each model, and what did its limitations lead to?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing limitations without any judgement.

    Why it happens: The limitations are the part students memorise.

    Assess means make a judgement. Say how well each model did and what its limitations led to.

  • Saying Bohr explained why the orbits were quantised.

    Why it happens: His model is remembered for quantised orbits.

    He assumed the quantisation to make the numbers fit. The reason came a decade later from de Broglie.

Written for this site.

The hydrogen spectrum

Investigating the Balmer series

In a hydrogen discharge tube, a high voltage across low pressure hydrogen excites the atoms, and as their electrons fall back down the gas glows pink. Viewed through a spectroscope or a diffraction grating, the glow splits into separate coloured lines: a red line, a blue green line and two violet lines, with nothing in between.

To measure them, find the angle of each line from the straight through position and use , where is the grating's line spacing. The four visible lines are at 656, 486, 434 and 410 nm. In 1885 Johann Balmer found that they fitted a simple wavelength formula, with nm and , although he had no idea why. The lines are now called the Balmer series.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Describe how the Balmer series of hydrogen can be observed and measured in a school laboratory, and how the results could be checked against theory.

Hint 1What makes hydrogen gas glow?

Hint 2Which instrument splits the light into separate lines and lets you measure angles?

Hint 3Which equation turns the angles into wavelengths, and which gives the theoretical values?

Energy levels explain the lines

Bohr's model gives hydrogen's energy levels as

The energies are negative because zero is chosen as the electron just free of the atom (). A bound electron has less energy than a free one, and eV is needed to free it from the ground state.

When an electron falls from level to a lower level , conservation of energy says the photon carries off exactly the energy the atom loses:

Photon energyon the NESA formulae sheet

Symbols
  • energy of one photonJ
  • Planck's constant, 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴ J sJ s
  • frequency of the lightHz
Valid when
Any electromagnetic radiation, one photon at a time. Combine it with c = fλ when the wavelength is given.
Not valid when
It is applied to a whole beam, whose energy is the photon energy times the number of photons, or the energy is wanted in electronvolts and the conversion is skipped.
Rearranged
for f: for E:
Where it turns up
  • The energy carried by one photon of a given colour
  • The number of photons per second in a beam of known power
  • Planck's quantised oscillators in black body radiation
Where marks go missing
  • Substituting a wavelength for f
  • Mixing joules and electronvolts in one line
  • Thinking a brighter beam has more energetic photons

Where this comes from

Because there are only certain levels, there are only certain differences, and so only certain wavelengths. Each allowed jump is one line. Absorption works the same way in reverse: a photon is absorbed only if its energy exactly matches a gap, which is why cool hydrogen in front of a hot source removes the same wavelengths as dark lines.

Choose a starting and a finishing level below and watch the photon's energy and wavelength change. Set the finishing level to 2 and step the starting level up from 3: that is the Balmer series. Then try finishing on 1 and on 3.

Energy levels of hydrogenA hydrogen electron moving from n = 3 to n = 2 emits a photon of 1.89 eV, wavelength 656.3 nm, in the Balmer series.n = 1n = 2n = 3n = 4n = ∞-14-12-10-8-6-4-20Energy (eV)
  • Emission
Levels crowd together towards zero, the energy of an electron just free of the atom. A downward arrow emits a photon carrying exactly the energy difference; an upward one absorbs a photon of that energy and no other. Every line in a series ends on the same level, so the series is named by where it ends: Lyman on n = 1, Balmer on n = 2.
The numbers behind this graph
nEnergy (eV)Energy (J)
1-13.61-2.181 × 10⁻¹⁸
2-3.40-5.452 × 10⁻¹⁹
3-1.51-2.423 × 10⁻¹⁹
4-0.85-1.363 × 10⁻¹⁹
5-0.54-8.722 × 10⁻²⁰
6-0.38-6.057 × 10⁻²⁰
7-0.28-4.450 × 10⁻²⁰
3
2
Transition
n = 3 to n = 2, emits a photon
Series
Balmer series
Photon energy E_i − E_f
1.891 eV = 3.029 × 10⁻¹⁹ J
Wavelength from Rydberg
656.3 nm, visible, red
Frequency E / h
4.571 × 10¹⁴ Hz

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

The levels crowd together as increases, so the higher lines of each series crowd together too, towards a series limit where . Each series is named by the level the electron ends on:

SeriesEnds onRegionWavelengths
LymanUltraviolet122 nm down to 91 nm
BalmerVisible and near ultraviolet656 nm down to 365 nm
PaschenInfrared1875 nm down to 820 nm

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which statement about the Balmer series of hydrogen is correct?

Select one answer

Hint 1Each series is named by the level the electron ends on.

Hint 2Balmer found his formula for lines he could see.

Hint 3Do all the lines of a series have to be in the same part of the spectrum?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Why do the lines of the Balmer series get closer together towards shorter wavelengths?

Select one answer

Hint 1Sketch the levels for to 6.

Hint 2How big is the gap between and compared with and ?

Hint 3If the upper levels crowd together, what happens to the photon energies of falls from them to ?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain how quantised energy levels and the law of conservation of energy account for hydrogen emitting a line spectrum rather than a continuous spectrum.

Hint 1What energies can the electron in hydrogen have?

Hint 2When the electron falls, where does the energy it loses go?

Hint 3Link the photon's energy to its frequency.

Rydberg's equation

Combining with the levels gives one equation for every hydrogen line. Johannes Rydberg had found it by fitting data in 1888, and Bohr's model explained it:

Rydberg's equationon the NESA formulae sheet

Symbols
  • wavelength of the photon emitted or absorbedm
  • Rydberg constant, 1.097 × 10⁷m⁻¹
  • principal quantum number of the lower level, where an emitted photon leaves the electron1
  • principal quantum number of the upper level1
Valid when
Transitions between energy levels of hydrogen, emission or absorption. For emission n_i > n_f; for absorption swap the roles so the bracket stays positive.
Not valid when
Atoms with more than one electron, including helium, or an ion that is not hydrogen-like.
Rearranged
for \lambda: for E:
Where it turns up
  • The wavelength of a Balmer line, with n_f = 2
  • Identifying which transition produced a measured spectral line
  • The ionisation energy of hydrogen, with n_i → ∞
Where marks go missing
  • Forgetting to take the reciprocal at the end and giving 1/λ as the wavelength
  • Swapping n_i and n_f and getting a negative wavelength
  • Using it for helium or other multi-electron atoms

Where this comes from

Here m⁻¹. For emission, is the lower level the electron ends on and the higher level it starts from, which keeps the bracket positive. For Balmer lines, . Balmer's constant is just .

Worked example4 marks

A Balmer line three ways

An electron in a hydrogen atom falls from to . Calculate the wavelength, energy and frequency of the photon emitted, and check the energy against the levels eV.

Wavelength

Rydberg's equation, with the electron ending on n_f = 2.

Energy

Photon energy from its wavelength.

Frequency

E = hf, so f = E/h. Using f = c/λ gives the same answer.

Check with the levels

Conservation of energy: the photon carries off the difference between the levels.

Answer

nm (violet, the third Balmer line), J eV, Hz. The two routes to the energy agree.

Is that answer sensible?

A Balmer line must lie between 365 nm and 656 nm, and a fall from higher up must give a shorter wavelength than the 656 nm line from . 434 nm passes both tests.

Common mistake

Giving the answer to 1/λ as the wavelength.

Why it happens: The unknown is on the left as a reciprocal, and it is easy to stop once the arithmetic is done.

Rydberg's equation gives in m⁻¹, a number around . A wavelength of light is around m. Always take the reciprocal and check the size.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Use Rydberg's equation to calculate the wavelength, in metres, of the photon emitted when the electron in a hydrogen atom falls from to .

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1Which level is and which is ?

Hint 2Work out the bracket first: .

Hint 3The equation gives . Take the reciprocal at the end.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

The blue green line in the hydrogen spectrum has a wavelength of nm. Calculate the energy of one of its photons in joules.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1Which formula links energy and wavelength?

Hint 2Convert 486 nm to metres.

Hint 3.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

The energy levels of hydrogen are eV. Calculate the frequency of the photon emitted when an electron falls from to .

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1Find and in eV.

Hint 2By conservation of energy, the photon carries off the difference. Convert it to joules with J.

Hint 3Then .

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A line in the hydrogen spectrum has a wavelength of nm. Identify the transition that produced it and the series it belongs to.

Hint 1A wavelength this short is ultraviolet. Which series is in the ultraviolet?

Hint 2Try and solve Rydberg's equation for .

Hint 3.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An electron in the ground state of hydrogen absorbs just enough energy to escape the atom. Treating this as a transition from to , use Rydberg's equation to calculate the ionisation energy of hydrogen in joules.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1What is ?

Hint 2The bracket becomes .

Hint 3Combine with , so .

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Hydrogen's levels are : eV, : eV, : eV. A photon of energy eV passes a hydrogen atom in its ground state. What happens?

Select one answer

Hint 1Which gaps above the ground state could the photon match?

Hint 2 eV and eV.

Hint 3A photon is absorbed whole or not at all.

de Broglie's matter waves

In 1924 Louis de Broglie turned a known fact round. Light, a wave, carries momentum like a particle: . So perhaps particles have wavelengths:

de Broglie wavelengthon the NESA formulae sheet

Symbols
  • wavelength of the matter wavem
  • Planck's constant, 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴J s
  • mass of the particlekg
  • speed of the particlem s⁻¹
Valid when
Any particle with mass, at speeds well below c. More generally λ = h/p, which also holds for photons.
Not valid when
Speeds close to c, where the momentum is γmv, not mv. Massless particles, where p = E/c.
Rearranged
for v: for \lambda:
Where it turns up
  • The wavelength of electrons accelerated through a potential difference
  • Showing why everyday objects show no wave behaviour
  • The allowed orbits of hydrogen, 2πr = nλ
Where marks go missing
  • Using the accelerating voltage as the speed
  • Forgetting to convert the kinetic energy qV into a speed before substituting
  • Using the proton mass for an electron or the reverse

Where this comes from

For everyday objects the wavelength is absurdly small. A cricket ball at m s⁻¹ has m, far smaller than any gap it could diffract through, so its wave nature can never show. But an electron's small mass gives it a wavelength comparable with the spacing of atoms in a crystal.

Common mistake

Only electrons have de Broglie wavelengths.

Why it happens: Electrons are the example in every textbook.

Every moving particle has one: protons, neutrons, whole atoms and molecules have all been diffracted. Heavier particles at the same speed just have shorter wavelengths.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A kg cricket ball is bowled at m s⁻¹. Calculate its de Broglie wavelength.

Give it to 2 significant figures.

Hint 1The ball's momentum is .

Hint 2.

Hint 3Compare your answer with the size of a proton, about m.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An electron and a proton move at the same speed. Which statement about their de Broglie wavelengths is correct?

Select one answer

Hint 1 with the same for both.

Hint 2Which particle has more mass?

Hint 3The proton is about 1840 times heavier.

Why Bohr's orbits are quantised

de Broglie's idea explains Bohr's third postulate. If the electron in an orbit is a wave, then as it goes round, each lap must join smoothly onto the last. If it does, the wave reinforces itself and forms a standing wave, which is stable. If it does not, successive laps are out of step and the wave cancels itself out. So a whole number of wavelengths must fit round the orbit:

That is exactly Bohr's condition, which he had had to assume.

3D model

An electron wave wrapped round a circular orbit about a hydrogen nucleus, with the allowed orbits for n = 1 to 6 drawn as faint rings. Each lap of the wave is drawn faintly and the lap average in bold. When a whole number of wavelengths fits round the orbit, every lap lies on top of the last and a standing wave forms, with fixed nodes. Otherwise the laps drift apart and cancel.

3.00

An electron wave wrapped round circular orbits about a nucleus, with its displacement drawn upwards from the plane of the orbit. Faint rings mark the allowed orbits. Eight successive laps of the wave are drawn faintly and their average in bold. When a whole number of wavelengths fits round the orbit the laps coincide and nodes appear; otherwise the laps drift apart and the average shrinks.

Radii are drawn growing in step with n, not n² as they really do, so all six orbits fit on screen. Slide between whole numbers and watch the standing wave fall apart. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

Drag the number of wavelengths from 3 towards 3.5. The laps stop lining up and the bold wave, their sum, shrinks away: the orbit is not allowed. Only whole numbers survive, and for each one the readout gives the real radius, speed and energy of that Bohr orbit.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain how de Broglie's matter waves account for Bohr's condition .

Hint 1Treat the electron in orbit as a wave running round a circle.

Hint 2For the wave to join up with itself, how many wavelengths must fit round the circumference?

Hint 3Substitute into .

The evidence: electron diffraction

A wavelength is only real if it produces interference. In 1927 two experiments showed it did.

Davisson and Germer fired a beam of electrons at a nickel crystal and measured how many bounced off at each angle. Instead of scattering smoothly in all directions, the electrons came off strongly at one particular angle. The rows of atoms on the crystal surface were acting as a reflection grating: electrons scattered from neighbouring rows arrive in phase only in certain directions.

G. P. Thomson (J. J. Thomson's son) fired electrons through thin gold foil. The foil contains many tiny crystals at random angles, and the electrons formed a pattern of concentric rings on a screen, just like the pattern X rays of similar wavelength give.

Worked example4 marks

Davisson and Germer's electrons

Davisson and Germer accelerated electrons through V and found a maximum at . The rows of surface atoms in nickel are m apart. Compare the wavelength from the diffraction pattern with de Broglie's prediction.

Measured wavelength

For a reflection grating with the beam at right angles to the surface, the first maximum is at d sin θ = λ.

Speed of the electrons

The work done by the field, qV, becomes kinetic energy.

de Broglie's prediction

λ = h/mv.

Answer

The measured wavelength is m and the prediction is m. They agree within about 1%, so the electrons diffracted with exactly the wavelength predicts.

Is that answer sensible?

The speed is about 1.5% of , so using for the momentum is fine. The wavelength is close to the atom spacing, which is the condition for strong diffraction.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An electron starting from rest is accelerated through a potential difference of V. Calculate its de Broglie wavelength.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1The electron's kinetic energy equals .

Hint 2Solve for .

Hint 3Then with kg.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In 1927 Davisson and Germer fired eV electrons at a nickel crystal and found a strong maximum in the scattered electrons at from the incident beam. The spacing of the surface atoms was m. Explain how this result supported de Broglie's hypothesis, using calculations.

Hint 1A maximum at one particular angle is the signature of a diffraction grating. What formula locates it?

Hint 2Calculate the wavelength from .

Hint 3Then calculate de Broglie's prediction: find from eV, then .

Schrödinger's wave mechanics

de Broglie's waves explained Bohr's rule but only for a flat, circular orbit, and they still could not handle more than one electron. In 1926 Erwin Schrödinger wrote a wave equation for the electron: an equation, like the equations for sound or water waves, whose solutions describe how the electron's wave varies through three dimensional space.

  • Quantisation comes out of the mathematics. For an electron bound to a nucleus, the equation only has sensible solutions for certain energies, just as a guitar string only has certain standing waves. For hydrogen these are Bohr's eV, now derived instead of assumed.
  • The wave function gives probability. Max Born showed that the square of the solution, , gives the probability of finding the electron at each point. The model does not say where the electron is, or give it a path, until it is measured.
  • Orbits become orbitals. An orbital is a three dimensional region where the electron is likely to be found. Each is labelled by three quantum numbers, for energy, shape and orientation, which is why orbitals have the s, p and d shapes met in chemistry.
  • It reaches beyond hydrogen. The same equation applies to atoms with many electrons. With Pauli's exclusion principle, it explains electron shells and the periodic table, and it predicts the relative brightness of spectral lines, which Bohr's model could not.

Its original form still had limits. It ignores relativity and says nothing about the electron's spin, which Pauli added in 1927 and Dirac's relativistic equation explained in 1928. And for any atom with more than one electron it cannot be solved exactly, only approximated.

Common mistake

In Schrödinger's model the electron moves round the nucleus along a wavy path.

Why it happens: Standing wave diagrams wrapped round a circle look like a wiggly orbit.

The wave is not a path. It describes the electron itself, and its square gives the probability of finding the electron at each point. The model gives no trajectory at all.

3D model

Treating the electron as a standing wave around the nucleus replaces the orbit with a probability cloud. Each dot is one possible result of looking for the electron, not a point on a path it follows. Switch between the 1s, 2s, 2p and 3d orbitals to see the shapes, including the surfaces where the electron is never found.

2500

Every dot is one possible result of looking for the electron, so the cloud is a map of probability rather than a picture of a path. The 2s orbital has a spherical surface through which the electron is never found, and the 2p orbital has a whole plane of them through the nucleus. Nothing in Bohr's model can produce a shape like that.

The cloud is sampled from the square of the wavefunction, so where the dots are dense the electron is more likely to be found. This model handles atoms with many electrons, the brightness of each spectral line and the shapes that set how atoms bond, none of which the Bohr model could do. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A textbook shows the 1s orbital of hydrogen as a fuzzy sphere. A student says: "The electron is moving round inside that sphere very fast along a path we just can't see." Which statement best describes the orbital in Schrödinger's model?

Select one answer

Hint 1What does the square of the wave function tell you?

Hint 2Does Schrödinger's model give the electron a path at all?

Hint 3Why is the edge of the picture fuzzy rather than sharp?

Analysetypically 4 to 7 marks

Demands
Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
Shape
Identify the components, then the relationships, then what follows from them.
Loses marks
Summarising the stimulus rather than taking it apart.

Worked example5 marks

Planning an analyse answer on Schrödinger

Analyse the contribution of Schrödinger to the current model of the atom. (5 marks)

What came before

Analyse means showing how the parts relate, so start with the problem Schrödinger solved.

Bohr's model only worked for hydrogen and assumed its quantisation. de Broglie explained the quantisation with standing waves, but only for circular orbits.

What he did

Name the contribution precisely.

In 1926 he wrote a wave equation for the electron in three dimensions. Its solutions, wave functions, exist only for certain energies, so quantised levels are derived, not assumed.

What it changed

Link the contribution to the model we use now.

With Born's interpretation, gives the probability of finding the electron, so definite orbits are replaced by orbitals described by quantum numbers.

What it explained

Show the gain over the previous model.

It applies to many electron atoms, explains shells and the periodic table with Pauli's principle, and predicts line intensities.

Limits and judgement

A complete analysis says what it did not do.

It left out spin and relativity (added by Pauli and Dirac) and cannot be solved exactly for more than one electron. Even so, it is the foundation of the current quantum mechanical model.

Answer

A top answer covers each of these five parts in its own short paragraph, linking each to the next with words like "this meant" and "so". The full model answer is in the question below.

Is that answer sensible?

Count the parts against the marks: five marks, five distinct points, each connected to Schrödinger's work rather than to a general history of the atom.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Analyse the contribution of Schrödinger to the current model of the atom.

Hint 1What problem was left by Bohr's model and de Broglie's matter waves?

Hint 2What did Schrödinger's equation describe, and what did the square of its solutions come to mean?

Hint 3What did his model explain that Bohr's could not, and what did it still leave out?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Writing only about Schrödinger's cat.

    Why it happens: It is the best known thing about Schrödinger.

    The cat is a thought experiment about measurement. The syllabus asks about his contribution to the model of the atom: the wave equation and orbitals.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

3 marks

Explain how de Broglie's hypothesis accounts for the stability of electron orbits in Bohr's model. (3 marks)

The attempt

1 out of 3

de Broglie said electrons are waves with . This means the electrons do not radiate, so the orbits are stable.

What the marker sees

The formula earns a mark. But the answer jumps straight to the conclusion: it never says what it is about a wave that makes only some orbits stable, which is the whole point of the question.

The same answer, fixed

3 out of 3

de Broglie proposed that an electron has a wavelength . In an orbit the wave must join up with itself after each lap. If a whole number of wavelengths fits round the circumference, , the wave forms a standing wave and reinforces itself, so the orbit is stable. For any other radius the laps are out of step and the wave cancels itself out, so that orbit cannot exist.

Substituting gives , which is Bohr's condition for the allowed orbits.

The uncertainty principle

Schrödinger's model gives probabilities because nature does. Heisenberg showed in 1927 that the position and momentum of a particle cannot both be known exactly at once:

Confining an electron to an atom, m, forces a spread in momentum of at least about kg m s⁻¹, a spread in speed of about m s⁻¹. That is why an electron cannot simply sit on the nucleus: squeezing it smaller would make its momentum, and its energy, larger. The uncertainty principle, not a rule about non-radiating orbits, is what stops the atom collapsing.

Schrödinger's cat

In 1935, after corresponding with Einstein about the strangeness of quantum measurement, Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment. A cat in a sealed box will be killed if a single radioactive atom decays. Until the box is opened, quantum mechanics describes the atom as a combination of decayed and not decayed, and so, it seems, the cat as a combination of alive and dead. Schrödinger meant it to show how absurd it is to apply quantum descriptions naively to everyday objects. It is not part of the syllabus, and it is not his contribution to the model of the atom.

Where the 1/n² comes from

With the Coulomb force as the centripetal force and , the worked example above generalises to and a total energy of . That gives , and substituting the constants gives eV for . The same combination of constants is the Rydberg constant: , which Bohr calculated to within the accuracy of the measured value. That agreement, from nothing but known constants, is what convinced physicists his model was on to something.