HSC Study

Deep Inside the Atom

The evidence that protons and neutrons are made of quarks and that other particles exist, the Standard Model of quarks, leptons and force carriers, and how particle accelerators test it.

75 min · Module 8: From the Universe to the Atom

Assumes you have read Quantum Mechanical Nature of the Atom and Charged Particles in Electric and Magnetic Fields.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

Nucleons are not fundamental. The neutral neutron has a magnetic moment, so it must contain moving charges. Accelerators produced hundreds of new hadrons, whose pattern was explained by quarks. Deep inelastic scattering fired very high energy electrons at protons, and far more bounced through large angles than a smooth proton allows, revealing point-like parts inside.

Other particles exist. The positron (Anderson, 1932) was predicted by Dirac and found in cosmic rays. The muon (1936) was found in cosmic ray showers with a mass between the electron's and the proton's. The neutrino was proposed by Pauli in 1930 to explain the spread of beta particle energies and detected in 1956.

The Standard Model.

  • Six quarks (up, down, charm, strange, top, bottom) with charges or . Quarks combine into hadrons: baryons have three quarks (proton uud, neutron udd), mesons have a quark and an antiquark.
  • Six leptons: the electron, muon and tau with charge , and three neutrinos. Leptons do not feel the strong force.
  • Matter comes in three generations. Only the first is stable.
  • Forces are carried by gauge bosons: the gluon (strong), photon (electromagnetic), and W and Z (weak). The Higgs boson belongs to the field that gives particles mass. Gravity is not included.

Accelerators. A linac accelerates particles across gaps between drift tubes. A cyclotron uses two dees and a magnetic field: the time per turn, , does not depend on speed, so a fixed frequency supply works, until relativity puts the ions out of step. A synchrotron raises its magnetic field with the particles' momentum to keep them in a fixed ring. Accelerators found quark structure, the W and Z bosons, the top quark and the Higgs boson.

Evidence that protons and neutrons have parts

A fundamental particle has no smaller parts. Four independent lines of evidence showed that protons and neutrons do.

Magnetic moments

Moving charges produce magnetic fields, and every charged particle with spin behaves like a tiny bar magnet. Dirac's theory predicts exactly how strong that magnet should be for a point particle. The electron matches it almost perfectly. In 1933 Otto Stern measured the proton's magnetic moment and found it about times Dirac's value.

The neutron is more striking still. It has no charge at all, so as a point particle it should have no magnetic moment. Yet it has one, about two thirds the size of the proton's and pointing the opposite way. The only way a neutral particle can act as a magnet is if it contains charged parts whose charges add to zero but whose motion does not cancel.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

The neutron has no overall charge, yet it has a magnetic moment and behaves like a tiny bar magnet. Why is this evidence that the neutron is not a fundamental particle?

Select one answer

Hint 1What produces a magnetic field?

Hint 2Could a single point with zero charge produce one?

Hint 3What if the neutron contains charges that add to zero?

The particle zoo

From the late 1940s, cosmic ray experiments and then accelerators found hadrons faster than anyone could name them: pions, kaons, lambdas, sigmas and hundreds more. It is hard to believe that hundreds of particles are all fundamental. In 1964 Gell-Mann and Zweig showed they fell into neat patterns if every one was built from just three smaller particles, which Gell-Mann called quarks. The pattern had a gap, which predicted a particle, the , with a particular mass and charge. It was found the same year.

Deep inelastic scattering

The quark model explained patterns, but many physicists thought quarks were only a bookkeeping device. Direct evidence came from an experiment much like Geiger and Marsden's.

At SLAC in California in 1968, electrons were accelerated to about GeV and fired at protons. At that energy their de Broglie wavelength is far smaller than a proton, so they can probe inside it. If the proton's charge were spread smoothly through it, like Thomson's plum pudding, the electrons would only be deflected slightly. Instead, far more electrons than expected were scattered through large angles, losing a large share of their energy, and the pattern matched collisions with small, point-like charged particles. Later experiments showed these had charges of and : quarks. Deep means the electrons probed deep inside the proton; inelastic means the collision did not conserve kinetic energy, because the proton broke up into a shower of new hadrons.

Common mistake

Deep inelastic scattering knocked quarks out of protons.

Why it happens: The collisions break the proton up, so it sounds as though the quarks come out.

No free quark has ever been seen. When a quark is struck hard, the energy creates new quark and antiquark pairs and the fragments emerge as ordinary hadrons. The evidence for quarks is the pattern of scattered electrons, not detected quarks.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Describe how deep inelastic scattering experiments showed that protons have internal structure.

Hint 1What was fired at the protons, and why did it need a very high energy?

Hint 2What would happen to the electrons if the proton's charge were spread smoothly through it?

Hint 3What did the large angle scattering show, and which earlier experiment does this resemble?

Beta decay

In beta minus decay a neutron in a nucleus turns into a proton. Something that can change into something else is unlikely to be fundamental. In the quark model it is simple: one down quark becomes an up quark, turning udd into uud. You will see the full process in the Standard Model section.

Evidence for other particles

The positron

In 1928 Dirac combined quantum mechanics and special relativity into an equation for the electron. It had solutions that seemed to describe an electron with positive charge. In 1932 Carl Anderson photographed cosmic ray tracks in a cloud chamber in a strong magnetic field, with a lead plate across the middle, and found one.

Radius of a charged particle's path in a magnetic fieldnot on the formulae sheet, learn it

Symbols
  • radius of the circular pathm
  • mass of the particlekg
  • speed of the particle, perpendicular to the fieldm s⁻¹
  • chargeC
  • magnetic field strengthT
Valid when
The field is uniform and the velocity is perpendicular to it, so the magnetic force supplies the whole centripetal force. The period is T = 2πm/qB, independent of speed.
Not valid when
The velocity has a component along the field, where only the perpendicular component goes in, or the speed is close to the speed of light.
Rearranged
for v: for T:
Where it turns up
  • Finding the radius of an electron or proton's path
  • Separating isotopes by mass in a mass spectrometer
Where marks go missing
  • Inverting the formula as qB/mv
  • Forgetting to convert mT to T

Where this comes from

Worked example4 marks

Anderson's positron track

A track crosses a mm lead plate in a cloud chamber with a magnetic field of T. On one side of the plate its radius is m and on the other side m. Its curvature is the way a positive charge would bend if it travelled from the m side to the m side. Show that it is a positively charged particle, and that it cannot be a proton.

Direction of travel

A particle loses energy passing through lead, so its momentum and radius are smaller after the plate.

, so the smaller radius is after the plate. The particle travelled from the m side to the m side.

Sign of the charge

With the direction fixed, the sense of curvature decides the sign.

Travelling that way, it curves as a positive charge would. An electron going the other way would curve the same way, but that is ruled out by the plate.

Momentum on each side

For charge e, p = qBr.

Could it be a proton?

A proton with this momentum would be slow, and slow protons stop quickly.

A proton with only MeV travels about mm through the chamber's gas, but the track after the plate was over mm long, with the thin trail of a fast, light particle.

Answer

It is positive and has about the electron's mass: a positron, the electron's antiparticle, exactly as Dirac predicted.

Is that answer sensible?

For a particle this light, the energy is about : J, or MeV before the plate, and MeV after. Anderson reported MeV and MeV.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In a cloud chamber photograph, a track crosses a lead plate. Its radius of curvature is larger on one side of the plate than the other, and it curves the way a positive charge would. A student says: "We can't tell which way it went, so it could just be an electron moving backwards." What settles it?

Select one answer

Hint 1What happens to a particle's momentum when it passes through lead?

Hint 2How does the radius depend on momentum?

Hint 3Once the direction of travel is known, what does the curvature tell you?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A particle with charge leaves a circular track of radius m in a cloud chamber with a magnetic field of T perpendicular to its motion. Calculate its momentum.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1The magnetic force provides the centripetal force: .

Hint 2Rearrange for .

Hint 3 C.

The muon

Primary cosmic rays, mostly high energy protons from space, strike nuclei in the upper atmosphere and set off showers of particles. Among them are pions, which quickly decay into muons, and most of the charged particles reaching the ground are muons.

In 1936 Anderson and Neddermeyer found tracks with the charge of an electron that behaved like neither an electron nor a proton. The curvature gave each particle's momentum. Electrons of that momentum lose a lot of energy in metal plates, but these particles passed through losing little. Protons of that momentum would be slow and stop quickly, but these went on. The only consistent answer was a new particle about times the electron's mass. Nobody had predicted it; the physicist Isidor Rabi asked, "Who ordered that?"

Common mistake

The muon's larger radius showed it had a larger mass.

Why it happens: The mass appears in r = mv/qB.

The radius gives the momentum, , not the mass. The mass came from combining the momentum with how much energy the particles lost in the plates.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Outline how the muon was discovered and why it was accepted as a new particle rather than an electron or a proton.

Hint 1Where do the muons at ground level come from?

Hint 2What two things did Anderson and Neddermeyer compare for each track?

Hint 3How did the muons behave differently from both electrons and protons of the same momentum?

The neutrino

If a nucleus at rest split into only two particles, conservation of energy and momentum would give the beta particle the same energy every time. Measurements showed a continuous spread of energies up to a maximum. Some energy seemed to vanish.

In 1930 Pauli proposed a third particle: neutral, very light, and hardly interacting, which carried away the missing energy and momentum. Neutrinos pass through the whole Earth almost unaffected, so detecting one took until 1956, when Cowan and Reines set up detectors beside a nuclear reactor, which gives out an enormous flux of antineutrinos, and saw the reactions a few of them caused.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain why Pauli proposed the existence of the neutrino, and how its existence was confirmed.

Hint 1If a nucleus at rest decays into two particles, what does conservation of energy and momentum say about the electron's energy?

Hint 2What did measurements of beta particle energies actually show?

Hint 3Where would you find a huge number of neutrinos to detect?

Analysetypically 4 to 7 marks

Demands
Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
Shape
Identify the components, then the relationships, then what follows from them.
Loses marks
Summarising the stimulus rather than taking it apart.

For "analyse the evidence", each piece needs three things: what was observed, why the old picture could not explain it, and what it implies. The strongest answers also point out that independent methods agree.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 11 min

6 marks

Analyse the evidence that protons and neutrons are not fundamental particles, and that other subatomic particles exist.

Hint 1For nucleons: magnetic moments, the flood of new hadrons, and scattering experiments.

Hint 2For new particles: the positron, the muon and the neutrino. Say what was measured each time.

Hint 3"Analyse" means showing how each piece of evidence leads to the conclusion, not only listing it.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing particles and dates without saying what was observed.

    Why it happens: History is easier to memorise than evidence.

    For each discovery, give the measurement and why it could not be explained otherwise.

Written for this site.

The Standard Model of matter

The Standard Model, developed in the 1960s and 70s, describes all known matter with twelve fundamental fermions, the matter particles, and a set of bosons that carry the forces between them. Explore the chart.

The Standard Model

IIIIIIforce carriersuup+2/3ccharm+2/3ttop+2/3ddown−1/3sstrange−1/3bbottom−1/3eelectron−1μmuon−1τtau−1νₑe neutrino0νμ neutrino0ντ neutrino0ggluonstrongγphotonelectromagneticZZ bosonweakWW± bosonsweakHHiggsmassquarksleptons
  1. 1Three generations

    Each column is a generation. The second and third are heavier copies of the first, with the same charges. The heavier particles are unstable and decay within a tiny fraction of a second, so everything around you is built from the first column: up and down quarks make protons and neutrons, and electrons complete the atoms.

  2. 2Quarks

    Six flavours of quark. The top row has charge and the bottom row . Quarks feel all four forces, including the strong force, and are never found alone: they are always bound into hadrons.

  3. 3Leptons

    Six leptons. The electron, muon and tau have charge ; the three neutrinos are neutral and almost massless. Leptons do not feel the strong force, which is what makes them leptons. Mass has nothing to do with it: the tau is almost twice as heavy as a proton.

  4. 4Gauge bosons

    Gauge bosons carry the forces. Two particles interact by exchanging them. The gluon carries the strong force, the photon the electromagnetic force, and the W⁺, W⁻ and Z the weak force. The graviton, proposed for gravity, is not part of the model and has never been detected.

  5. 5The Higgs boson

    The Higgs boson is a ripple in the Higgs field, which fills space. Particles that interact with the field gain mass; the W and Z bosons gain large masses, the photon none. It was predicted in 1964 and found in 2012 by the ATLAS and CMS experiments at the Large Hadron Collider.

Twelve matter particles in three generations, with the gauge bosons that carry three of the four forces and the Higgs boson. Each matter particle also has an antiparticle with the opposite charge.

Quarks and hadrons

Particles made of quarks are called hadrons. There are two kinds.

HadronMade ofExamples
BaryonThree quarksProton uud, neutron udd
MesonA quark and an antiquarkPositive pion , negative pion

An antiquark has the opposite charge to its quark. The charge of a hadron is the sum of its quarks' charges:

Quark charges are fractions, but every hadron has a whole number charge. That is part of why free quarks are never seen.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

What is the charge of a baryon made of three down quarks (ddd)?

Select one answer

Hint 1What is the charge of a down quark?

Hint 2Add the three charges.

Hint 3Give the answer in units of .

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Distinguish between baryons and mesons, and show that a negative pion, , made of a down quark and an anti-up quark, has charge .

Hint 1How many quarks in each kind of hadron?

Hint 2What is the charge of an antiquark compared with its quark?

Hint 3Add and the anti-up charge.

Leptons

There are three charged leptons, the electron, muon and tau, each with its own neutrino. Every lepton has an antiparticle: the positron is the anti-electron. Leptons are fundamental and do not feel the strong force. The charged leptons feel the electromagnetic and weak forces; neutrinos feel only the weak force (and gravity), which is why they pass through the Earth.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which of these particles is a lepton?

Select one answer

Hint 1Leptons do not feel the strong force.

Hint 2Which particles here are made of quarks?

Hint 3Which one is a force carrier?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student says: "Leptons are the light particles. The tau has almost twice the mass of a proton, so it can't really be a lepton." What is wrong with this?

Select one answer

Hint 1What property actually defines a lepton?

Hint 2Does the tau feel the strong force?

Hint 3Is the tau made of anything smaller?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Why is all ordinary matter around us made only of first generation particles (up and down quarks and electrons)?

Select one answer

Hint 1How do the generations differ from each other?

Hint 2What happens to heavier unstable particles?

Hint 3Where are the heavier ones made?

Fundamental forces

ForceRelative strengthRangeCarrierActs on
StrongAbout mGluonQuarks (and so hadrons)
ElectromagneticInfinitePhotonCharged particles
WeakAbout mW⁺, W⁻, ZAll quarks and leptons
GravityInfiniteGraviton (proposed)Everything with mass or energy

The strong force binds quarks into hadrons; the force holding protons and neutrons together in a nucleus is a leftover of it. The weak force is the only one that can change one flavour of quark or lepton into another, which is how beta decay happens.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Identify the four fundamental forces, and for each state the boson that carries it in the Standard Model (or that is proposed) and one particle it acts on.

Hint 1Two have infinite range, two act only inside the nucleus.

Hint 2The strong and electromagnetic bosons are both massless.

Hint 3One of the four is not part of the Standard Model.

Worked example4 marks

Beta minus decay in the Standard Model

In beta minus decay a neutron changes into a proton, an electron and an electron antineutrino. Describe the decay in terms of quarks, leptons and bosons, and show that charge and lepton number are conserved.

Quark content

Write both baryons as quarks and see what changes.

The neutron is udd and the proton is uud. One down quark has become an up quark:

Which force

Only one force changes quark flavour.

The weak force. The quark's charge rises by , so it must emit a boson with charge : a .

The W decays

The W is very heavy and lives about 10⁻²⁵ s.

The electron and antineutrino are both leptons.

Check the conservation laws

Every Standard Model interaction must conserve charge, baryon number and lepton number.

Charge: .

Lepton number: , since the electron counts and the antineutrino .

Baryon number: .

Answer

A down quark turns into an up quark by the weak interaction, emitting a that decays into an electron and an electron antineutrino.

Is that answer sensible?

The antineutrino is Pauli's missing particle: it shares the decay energy with the electron, which is why beta electrons have a spread of energies.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In beta minus decay a down quark changes into an up quark. Which boson carries this interaction?

Select one answer

Hint 1Which force can change one flavour of quark into another?

Hint 2The quark's charge rises by . What charge must the boson carry away?

Hint 3It then decays into an electron and an antineutrino.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In beta plus decay, a proton in a nucleus changes into a neutron, emitting a positron and an electron neutrino. Describe this change in terms of quarks and bosons, and show that charge is conserved.

Hint 1Write the quark content of the proton and the neutron. Which quark changes?

Hint 2What charge must the emitted W boson have?

Hint 3Check the total charge before and after.

What the Standard Model cannot explain

The Standard Model is the most precisely tested theory in science, and it predicted the gluon, the W and Z bosons, the charm and top quarks and the Higgs boson before any was seen. But it is not complete, which is the answer to the inquiry question.

  • Gravity is not included, and no one has found a quantum theory of gravity that works with the rest of the model.
  • Dark matter, about five times as abundant as ordinary matter, is not any particle in the model.
  • Dark energy, which drives the accelerating expansion of the universe, is not explained.
  • Matter and antimatter. The Big Bang should have made equal amounts, yet the universe is almost all matter.
  • Neutrino mass. The original model had massless neutrinos, but they have been shown to change type as they travel, which requires mass.
  • The model has around numbers, such as the particle masses, that must be measured rather than predicted, and gives no reason why there are three generations.

Common mistake

The Standard Model cannot explain why a proton is heavier than its three quarks.

Why it happens: Some study guides list it as a limitation.

Most of the proton's mass is the energy of the gluon field and of the quarks' motion, through . The Standard Model's theory of the strong force accounts for it, and computer calculations reproduce the proton's mass. It is surprising, but it is not a limitation.

Evaluatetypically 6 to 8 marks

Demands
Judge worth against criteria, weighing strengths against weaknesses, and conclude.
Shape
A position stated early, defended with evidence, with the counter-case acknowledged and answered.
Loses marks
Listing advantages and disadvantages with no weighting, so nothing is actually evaluated.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Evaluate the Standard Model of matter as a description of the universe.

Hint 1What does it describe, and what successful predictions has it made?

Hint 2Which observations can it not account for?

Hint 3"Evaluate" needs a judgement based on both.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying the model cannot explain why the proton is heavier than its three quarks.

    Why it happens: It appears in some study guides.

    Most of the proton's mass is the energy of the gluon field and the quarks' motion (), which the Standard Model's theory of the strong force accounts for.

Written for this site.

Particle accelerators

To make a particle of mass , a collision must supply at least . To see detail of size , the probe needs a de Broglie wavelength smaller than , so a large momentum. Accelerators give charged particles these energies in controlled, repeatable collisions. Electric fields do the accelerating; magnetic fields steer.

Mass–energy equivalenceon the NESA formulae sheet

Symbols
  • energy equivalent to the mass, or released when that mass is convertedJ
  • mass, or the mass lost by a systemkg
  • speed of light in a vacuumm s⁻¹
Valid when
Any process. The energy a system releases equals its loss of rest mass times c², whether the process is nuclear, chemical or an annihilation.
Not valid when
m is taken as the total mass of the reactants rather than the mass that disappears, or masses in atomic mass units are used without converting to kilograms.
Rearranged
for m:
Where it turns up
  • The rate at which the Sun loses mass
  • The photon energy from electron–positron annihilation
  • The mass change in burning a fuel
Where marks go missing
  • Using the whole mass of a fuel rather than the tiny mass lost
  • Forgetting to square c
  • Believing mass is converted only in nuclear reactions

Where this comes from

Linear accelerators

A linac is a straight line of hollow metal drift tubes connected alternately to the two terminals of a high frequency alternating supply. Inside a tube there is no electric field, so the particle coasts. In each gap between tubes the field accelerates it.

While the particle is inside a tube, the supply reverses, so every gap has the right polarity when the particle arrives. The particle spends half a cycle in each tube, a fixed time, and it is faster each time, so each tube is longer than the last. The Stanford linac, used for deep inelastic scattering, is km long. Linacs are also used to inject particles into larger machines, and in hospitals to make X-rays for radiotherapy.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain how a linear accelerator speeds up charged particles, and why its drift tubes get longer along its length.

Hint 1Where is the particle accelerated: inside a tube or in the gaps?

Hint 2What must the alternating voltage do while the particle is inside a tube?

Hint 3The supply frequency is fixed. What happens to the distance travelled in half a cycle as the particle speeds up?

Cyclotrons

A linac for very high energies must be very long. Lawrence's cyclotron (1932) reuses one gap over and over by bending the particles round in a magnetic field.

Two hollow D shaped electrodes, the dees, sit in a vacuum between the poles of a large magnet. An alternating voltage across the gap between them accelerates the ions each time they cross it. Inside a dee there is no electric field, and the magnetic force bends the ion into a semicircle. With more speed each time, the radius grows and the ion spirals outwards.

The key is the time for each semicircle:

The speed cancels. A fast ion goes round a larger circle, but in the same time. So a supply of fixed frequency reverses exactly when the ion reaches the gap, every time. At the edge a deflector plate steers the ions out to a target.

3D model

Two hollow D shaped electrodes, the dees, sit between the poles of a magnet with a narrow gap between them. An alternating voltage across the gap accelerates an ion each time it crosses. Inside a dee there is no electric field, and the magnetic field bends the ion into a semicircle of radius mv/qB. Each crossing adds energy qV, so each semicircle is larger, and the ion spirals out until a deflector sends it to a target.

Gap voltage and the ion’s energy (each scaled to its own peak)Gap voltageIon energy
1.20 T
250 kV
0.50 m

A cyclotron with its magnetic field vertical and an ion spiralling outwards between two dees. The gap's electric field arrows reverse with the supply, and the trace shows the supply voltage with the ion's energy stepping up at each crossing.

Every semicircle takes the same time, however fast the ion is going, so a supply of one fixed frequency stays in step. Watch the gap field: it has flipped by the time the ion arrives back at the gap. Radii are drawn to scale with the dees. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

Watch the trace: every step in energy happens at a peak of the supply, positive or negative, because the ion crosses the gap in opposite directions on alternate half turns. Now raise the peak voltage: the ion takes fewer turns, but leaves with the same energy, set only by , and the ion. Switch to the alpha particle: double the charge and four times the mass halve the frequency.

Worked example5 marks

A cyclotron's frequency and output

A cyclotron accelerates protons in a magnetic field of T. Its dees have radius m and the peak voltage across the gap is kV. Find the supply frequency, the protons' final speed and kinetic energy, and the number of turns they make.

Supply frequency

One full cycle of the supply per turn.

Final speed

The ions leave when their radius reaches the edge of the dees.

Kinetic energy

The speed is under a fifth of c, so the classical formula is a fair approximation.

Number of turns

Each crossing gives qV, and there are two crossings per turn.

Energy per turn MeV, so the number of turns is .

Answer

MHz, and the protons leave at m s⁻¹ with J ( MeV) after about turns.

Is that answer sensible?

At , , so by the last turns each one takes about longer than the supply's cycle. Over dozens of turns that lag builds up and the protons start meeting the gap at the wrong moment. This is the limit of a simple cyclotron.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A cyclotron accelerates deuterons (charge C, mass kg) in a magnetic field of T. Calculate the frequency of the alternating voltage across the dees, in hertz.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1The time for one circle is with .

Hint 2The speed cancels: .

Hint 3The supply must complete one cycle per turn, so .

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A cyclotron has dees of radius m and a magnetic field of T. Calculate the maximum kinetic energy, in joules, of the protons it produces.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1At the edge of the dees the radius is . Find the speed from .

Hint 2Then .

Hint 3Or combine them: .

Synchrotrons

As particles approach the speed of light, their momentum keeps rising while their speed barely does. The period becomes , which grows, and a fixed frequency cyclotron falls out of step. A cyclotron for higher energies would also need an impossibly large magnet.

Relativistic momentumon the NESA formulae sheet

Symbols
  • momentum of the particlekg m s⁻¹
  • rest mass of the particlekg
  • speed of the particlem s⁻¹
  • speed of light in a vacuumm s⁻¹
Valid when
Any particle with rest mass at any speed below c. At everyday speeds it reduces to p = m₀v.
Not valid when
Applied to a particle with no rest mass such as a photon, or used to find a speed at or above c, where the square root is zero or undefined.
Rearranged
for v:
Where it turns up
  • The momentum of electrons or protons in an accelerator
  • Explaining why no finite force can bring a massive particle to c
Where marks go missing
  • Using p = m₀v for a particle moving at a large fraction of c
  • Concluding that the particle's rest mass itself increases

Where this comes from

A synchrotron keeps the particles in a ring of fixed radius. The particles are made and given a first boost by a linac, then injected into the ring. Around the ring:

  • Radio frequency cavities give the particles energy on every lap, with their frequency adjusted to stay in step.
  • Bending magnets keep them on the ring. Since is fixed, is raised in step with the momentum, which is where the name comes from.
  • Focusing magnets keep the beam narrow.

Only a thin ring needs magnets, so a synchrotron can be kilometres across. The Large Hadron Collider at CERN is km around and collides protons at TeV, with two beams travelling in opposite directions so that all their energy is available to make new particles. Electrons in a ring radiate energy as synchrotron radiation, intense X-rays that the Australian Synchrotron in Melbourne uses for research.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain why a cyclotron cannot accelerate protons to very high energies, and how a synchrotron overcomes this.

Hint 1What happens to the period as the proton approaches the speed of light?

Hint 2What does that do to the timing with the fixed frequency supply?

Hint 3In a synchrotron the radius is fixed. What must happen to as the momentum rises?

What accelerators have shown

DiscoveryWhere and whenWhat it tested
Quarks inside the protonSLAC linac, 1968The quark model
The J/ψ, containing charm quarksSLAC and Brookhaven, 1974The predicted fourth quark
The W and Z bosonsCERN, 1983The theory of the weak force, including the bosons' masses
The top quarkFermilab, 1995The sixth quark, completing the third generation
The Higgs bosonLHC (ATLAS and CMS), 2012The mechanism that gives particles mass

Accelerators also test the model by searching for what it lacks. So far no dark matter particle, and none of the extra particles some theories predict, has appeared.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

The Higgs boson has a mass of kg. Calculate the minimum energy, in joules, that a collision must supply to create one.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1Which equation links mass and energy?

Hint 2 m s⁻¹.

Hint 3The rest energy is the minimum; in practice collisions need far more.

Common mistake

In a synchrotron the linac accelerates the particles as they go round the ring.

Why it happens: The linac is the first part of the machine.

The linac only injects the particles. Once in the ring, the radio frequency cavities accelerate them on each lap, and the magnets are ramped up to keep them on the ring.

Through a marker’s eyes

3 marks

Explain why the alternating voltage in a cyclotron can have a fixed frequency. (3 marks)

The attempt

1 out of 3

The protons go faster each time they cross the gap, so they go in bigger circles. The voltage changes direction so that they are always accelerated.

What the marker sees

Both statements are true, and the second earns a mark. But the question is why a fixed frequency works, and the answer never shows that the time per turn stays the same. The key step is the cancellation of speed.

The same answer, fixed

3 out of 3

Inside a dee the magnetic force provides the centripetal force, so and .

The time for one turn is , which does not depend on speed: a faster ion travels a larger circle in the same time.

So the ions reach the gap at equal time intervals, and a supply of fixed frequency reverses in time to accelerate them at every crossing, as long as their speed stays well below .

Discusstypically 5 to 8 marks

Demands
Present issues from more than one side.
Shape
Each position stated with its strongest supporting case, then a synthesis.
Loses marks
Arguing one side well and giving the other a token sentence.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Discuss the role of particle accelerators in obtaining evidence that tests the Standard Model of matter.

Hint 1Why do we need high energies? Think of and of de Broglie wavelength.

Hint 2Give specific discoveries made with accelerators.

Hint 3What can accelerators not yet do?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing how accelerators work in detail but not what they discovered.

    Why it happens: The operation is easier to recall.

    A question about their role wants evidence: which predictions were tested, and with what results.

Written for this site.

Why quarks are never alone

Quarks carry a property called colour charge, with three types named red, green and blue, and the strong force acts between colours. Every hadron is colourless: a baryon has one quark of each colour, and a meson a colour and its anticolour. Unlike the electric force, the force between quarks does not weaken as they are pulled apart; it stays roughly constant, like a stretched elastic band. Pulling two quarks apart stores more and more energy, until there is enough to create a new quark and antiquark pair (), and the band snaps into two hadrons instead of freeing a quark. This is confinement.

Where the proton's mass comes from

An up quark has a mass of about MeV/ and a down quark about MeV/, so the three quarks in a proton add to about MeV/. The proton is MeV/. The other is energy: the quarks move at close to the speed of light, and the gluon field binding them stores an enormous amount of energy. By , that energy is mass. So most of your mass is not the mass of the particles you are made of, but the energy of the strong force holding them together.

Antimatter

Every fermion has an antiparticle with the same mass and opposite charge. When a particle meets its antiparticle they annihilate, turning into photons or other particles. The positron is used in PET scanners: a tracer emits positrons, each annihilates with an electron to give two gamma photons travelling in opposite directions, and detectors find where they came from. Why the early universe ended up with slightly more matter than antimatter, about one extra particle per billion pairs, is one of the model's open questions.