HSC Study

Pollution and Climate Change

Pollution and climate change as externalities and global public good problems, their economic and social costs for Australia and the world, Australia's emissions by sector since 2005, an economic analysis of the electricity transition, and an evaluation of Australian environmental policy for essay priority 6.

45 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues

Assumes you have read Externalities and Market Failure and Public Goods and Free Riders.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Pollution is the degradation of the environment by harmful substances, waste or noise. It is a negative externality: producers and consumers do not pay its cost, so the market overproduces polluting goods.
  • Climate change is the rise in global average temperatures caused by greenhouse gas emissions. A stable climate is a global public good, so every country has an incentive to free ride.
  • Costs for Australia: the 2025 National Climate Risk Assessment found 1.5 million people at risk from sea level rise by 2050 and disaster recovery costs above $40 billion a year by 2050.
  • Australia's emissions in the year to March 2026 were 455.6 Mt, 25 per cent below 2005. Electricity and land use have fallen; transport is up 23 per cent.
  • Policy mix: the Safeguard Mechanism (a baseline and credit scheme), subsidies for renewables and home batteries, vehicle efficiency standards, and targets of 43 per cent by 2030 and 62 to 70 per cent by 2035.
  • Judgement: policy has been effective in electricity, but progress elsewhere is too slow to meet the targets.

Pollution

AnswersWhy is pollution an economic issue, and how is it addressed?

Pollution

The degradation of the natural environment by harmful chemical substances, waste, noise or other by-products of production and consumption.

As your notes explain, pollution is both a social and an economic issue.

  • Social issue. Pollution in cities affects many people at once, through air, water and noise pollution, reducing health and quality of life.
  • Economic issue. Toxic waste and pollution degrade natural resources, such as soils, rivers and fisheries, inhibiting long-run growth.
  • A global issue. Pollution can be felt far from its source, such as ocean plastic, so it concerns international institutions as well as national governments.

Economically, pollution is the classic negative externality: marginal social cost exceeds marginal private cost, so polluting goods are overproduced and underpriced. Your notes list four measures, each of which moves the market towards the social optimum:

MeasureHow it worksAustralian example
Bans on damaging techniques or productsRemoves the sourceState bans on single-use plastics
Quotas restricting emissionsCaps the quantityLicence limits on pollutants from industrial sites
Subsidies for cleaner practicesMakes the alternative cheaperGrants for recycling infrastructure
Taxes and chargesMakes the polluter payWaste levies on landfill; container deposit schemes such as NSW Return and Earn

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A state government introduces a refundable deposit on drink containers. Which type of environmental policy is this?

Select one answer

Hint 1Does it change a price?

Hint 2Who bears the cost?

Hint 3Polluter pays.

Climate change

AnswersWhy is climate change an economic issue?

Climate change

The ongoing rise in global average temperatures caused mainly by greenhouse gas emissions from burning fossil fuels and land clearing, and its effects on weather, oceans and ecosystems.

As your notes explain, the IPCC found that limiting warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels requires net zero emissions by about 2050. Even at 1.5°C, heatwaves become more frequent; at 2°C, heat extremes reach critical thresholds for agriculture and health. The world passed 1.5°C for a single year for the first time in 2024.

Why markets fail. Climate change combines two market failures:

  1. A negative externality. Emitters do not pay for the damage their greenhouse gases cause, so emissions are overproduced.
  2. A global public good. A stable climate is non-excludable and non-rival. Every country benefits from global emissions cuts whether or not it contributes, so each has an incentive to free ride.

Economic and social issues. As your notes point out, rising living standards increase demand for energy and food, and while economies rely on fossil fuels, growth raises emissions. The poorest communities are the most vulnerable, even though they have contributed least.

The costs for Australia. Australia's first National Climate Risk Assessment (September 2025) found:

  • 1.5 million people at risk from sea level rise by 2050, and 597,000 by 2030.
  • Disaster recovery costs of over $40 billion a year by 2050, and a $611 billion fall in property values.
  • Heat-related deaths in Sydney rising by over 400 per cent under 3°C of warming.
  • Lower agricultural output from drought, and permanent damage to ecosystems such as the Great Barrier Reef, which recorded its largest annual falls in coral cover in 2025.

Chain of reasoning

How climate change reduces economic growth

  1. Global temperatures rises

    from accumulated greenhouse gas emissions
  2. Droughts, floods, fires and heatwaves rises

    in frequency and severity
  3. Capital stock, farm output and labour productivity falls

    through destruction, lost yields and heat stress
  4. Aggregate supply and long-run growth falls

    while spending shifts to recovery and adaptation

Exam question

Standard · about 7 min

4 marks

Explain why climate change is an example of market failure, and outline ONE economic cost of climate change for Australia. (4 marks)

Hint 1Externality.

Hint 2Public good and free riders.

Hint 3Use the National Climate Risk Assessment.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing climate effects without the market failure.

    Why it happens: The science is familiar.

    Use MSC, MPC and free riding.

Written for this site.

Australia's emissions

AnswersHow have Australia's emissions changed, and which sectors drive them?

Australia's emissions by sector, year to March 2026

SectorMt CO2-eChange since 2005
Electricity144.0−26.8%
Transport100.6+23.0%
Stationary energy (excluding electricity)97.4+19.9%
Agriculture75.1−9.2%
Fugitive emissions (mining and gas)45.5+6.9%
Industrial processes31.5
Waste13.5
Land use, land use change and forestry−52.0a net sink, from a large source in 2005
Total455.6−25.0%

Source: DCCEEW, National Greenhouse Gas Inventory Quarterly Update, March 2026.

Reading the data.

  • Most of the fall since 2005 comes from land use (less land clearing and more regrowth) and electricity, where renewables reached 44.2 per cent of generation in the main grid, with coal at 51.6 per cent.
  • Transport and stationary energy, which includes LNG production for export, have risen. These are the harder sectors to decarbonise.
  • Emissions per person are 45.7 per cent below 2005 and emissions per dollar of GDP 55.3 per cent below, so growth has decoupled from emissions.
  • Australia has used about 60 per cent of its 2021 to 2030 emissions budget with 58 per cent of the period gone: roughly on track for 2030, but projections show a gap for 2035.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

Australia's electricity emissions are 26.8 per cent below 2005 and transport emissions 23.0 per cent above 2005 (year to March 2026). Account for the difference between these two trends. (3 marks)

Hint 1What has changed in electricity?

Hint 2What policies target transport?

Hint 3Timing and cost of alternatives.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing the numbers without causes.

    Why it happens: The data are given.

    Account for means give reasons.

Written for this site.

Analysing a contemporary issue: the electricity transition

AnswersHow can economic concepts be used to analyse a contemporary environmental issue?

The syllabus asks you to use economic concepts to analyse an issue. A strong analysis names the market failure, uses the relevant diagram, evaluates the policy response and weighs its costs. Here is the method applied to the transition away from coal-fired electricity.

Worked example6 marks

Applying economic concepts to the electricity transition

Use economic concepts to analyse the transition of Australia's electricity system from coal to renewable energy.

Identify the market failure

Coal generation has a negative externality: marginal social cost, including greenhouse emissions and air pollution, exceeds marginal private cost. Without policy, the market overproduces coal-fired electricity at too low a price. A stable climate is a global public good, so there is also a free rider problem.

Explain the policy response with theory

Australia has mostly used subsidies for the positive alternative rather than a tax on the negative one. The Capacity Investment Scheme underwrites new renewable generation and storage, and Cheaper Home Batteries gives households about a 30 per cent discount. Subsidies lower the marginal private cost of clean supply, shifting its supply curve right.

Use evidence of the outcome

Renewables' share of generation in the main grid reached 44.2 per cent, with renewable output up 13 per cent in a year, and electricity emissions are 26.8 per cent below 2005.

Weigh the costs

Subsidies have a budget cost and an opportunity cost: the expected cost of Cheaper Home Batteries rose from $2.3 billion to $7.2 billion. Coal closures create structural unemployment in regions such as the Hunter and Latrobe valleys, and the cost of new transmission lines is passed on to consumers. A carbon tax would raise revenue rather than cost it, but the 2012 carbon price was repealed in 2014 after electricity prices rose, showing the political constraint.

Answer

The transition corrects a negative externality mainly through subsidies. It has cut electricity emissions substantially, but at a growing budget cost and with regional adjustment costs, and it has not addressed transport and industry.

Is that answer sensible?

The same four steps (market failure, policy theory, evidence, costs and judgement) work for any contemporary environmental issue: Reef decline, water in the Murray-Darling, or plastic waste.

Evaluating Australian environmental policy

AnswersHow effective are government policies in managing environmental issues and market failure?

PolicyTypeEvidenceAssessment
Safeguard Mechanism (strengthened 2023)Baseline and credit, like cap and tradeAbout 215 facilities, about 28 per cent of emissions, baselines falling 4.9 per cent a yearLeast-cost abatement for heavy industry; depends on the integrity of offsets and stays under review in 2026-27
Capacity Investment Scheme and Cheaper Home BatteriesSubsidyRenewables 44.2 per cent of NEM generation; electricity emissions −26.8 per cent since 2005Effective, but with a large and rising budget cost
New Vehicle Efficiency Standard (from 2025)RegulationTransport emissions +23 per cent since 2005Too new to judge; transport is the largest source of emissions growth
EPBC reform (2025) and protected areasRegulation and provision2,175 threatened species; protected land over 22 per centBiodiversity is still declining; the new agency starts in July 2026
2030 and 2035 targetsTargets25 per cent below 2005; projections 20 to 34 per cent above the 2031-35 budgetRoughly on track for 2030; well off track for 2035

Essay planpriority 6 of 16 · 20 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of government policies in managing environmental issues and market failure.

Evaluate
Judge worth against criteria, weighing strengths against weaknesses, and conclude.
Thesis
Australian governments have used a mix of market-based policies, subsidies and regulation to correct environmental market failure. Since 2020 this mix has been effective in electricity, where emissions have fallen by over a quarter since 2005, but much less effective in transport, industry and biodiversity, so current policy will not meet the 2035 target or halt species decline without further action.
  1. Environmental problems are market failures that justify government intervention.

    Open with the theory that justifies every policy that follows, and set the scale with current data.

    Theory
    Negative externalities (MSC above MPC), public goods and free riders, the tragedy of the commons.
    Diagram
    Negative externality diagram with MPC, MSC, demand and the deadweight loss.
    Evidence
    Emissions of 455.6 Mt in the year to March 2026; National Climate Risk Assessment (2025) costs of \$40 billion a year in disaster recovery by 2050.
    Against
    Coase: with clear property rights and low bargaining costs, markets could resolve some externalities without government.
  2. Market-based policy, through the Safeguard Mechanism, gives heavy industry an incentive to cut emissions at least cost.

    Explain the mechanism before the evidence, then judge it against the criteria.

    Theory
    Tradable permits create a property right to emit, cap the quantity and let trading set the price.
    Diagram
    Negative externality diagram showing supply shifting to MSC.
    Evidence
    About 215 facilities, about 28 per cent of emissions, baselines falling 4.9 per cent a year to 2030; stationary energy emissions still 19.9 per cent above 2005.
    Against
    Heavy reliance on offsets and generous baselines may limit real reductions; a review is due in 2026-27.
  3. Subsidies have driven the fall in electricity emissions.

    This is the strongest evidence of effectiveness in the essay, so give it the most data.

    Theory
    Subsidising the clean alternative lowers its marginal private cost and corrects an under-supplied positive externality.
    Diagram
    Positive externality diagram with a subsidy shifting supply to reach the social optimum.
    Evidence
    Renewables 44.2 per cent of NEM generation, up 13 per cent in a year; electricity emissions 26.8 per cent below 2005.
    Against
    Budget cost: Cheaper Home Batteries rose from \$2.3 billion to \$7.2 billion; the 2026-27 Budget saved \$1.3 billion by cutting other clean energy programs.
  4. Regulation is addressing transport and biodiversity, but outcomes remain poor.

    Contrast the certainty of regulation with its weak results so far.

    Theory
    Standards and approvals set rules directly; certain but less cost-effective than market-based policy.
    Diagram
    None needed; use the data table.
    Evidence
    New Vehicle Efficiency Standard from 2025, yet transport emissions 23 per cent above 2005; 2,175 threatened species; EPBC reform passed November 2025 with a new agency from July 2026.
    Against
    These policies are recent, so it is too early to judge them.
  5. Targets and international agreements address the free rider problem, but credibility is tested.

    Link back to the public good theory from the first paragraph.

    Theory
    Climate as a global public good; collective commitment reduces free riding.
    Diagram
    None needed.
    Evidence
    Targets of 43 per cent by 2030 and 62 to 70 per cent by 2035; emissions 25 per cent below 2005; 2025 projections 20 to 34 per cent above the 2031-35 budget; the United States left the Paris Agreement.
    Against
    Australia is about 1 per cent of global emissions, so its own action has limited direct effect; its influence comes through example and trade.
  6. Environmental policy has economic costs that governments must weigh.

    Use this paragraph to reach the overall judgement.

    Theory
    Short-run trade-off between growth and environmental protection; ESD and intergenerational equity.
    Diagram
    Production possibility frontier shifting inward with degradation.
    Evidence
    Structural unemployment in coal regions; electricity prices; carbon price repealed in 2014 after price rises; EU carbon border adjustment threatening high-emission exports.
    Against
    The long-run costs of inaction, \$611 billion in property values and rising disaster costs, exceed the short-run costs of action.

Judgement

Evaluate means make a judgement based on criteria. Use three criteria: whether the policy corrects the market failure in theory, whether evidence shows environmental outcomes improving, and its economic cost. Judge each policy, then conclude that effectiveness is uneven: strong in electricity, weak in transport and biodiversity.

The full response also needs: The microeconomic policy lessons in Topic 4 for environmental policy as microeconomic reform, and the fiscal policy lesson for the budget cost of subsidies.

Common mistake

Listing every environmental policy with a sentence of description each.

Why it happens: There are many policies, and covering them all seems thorough.

Evaluate questions reward judgement, not breadth. Choose four or five policies, explain the theory of each, give evidence of its outcome, and judge its effectiveness against clear criteria.

Exam question

Harder · about 14 min

8 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of TWO Australian government policies in addressing climate change. (8 marks)

Hint 1Choose one market-based policy and one subsidy or regulation.

Hint 2Theory, evidence, cost.

Hint 3Judgement.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing policies without a judgement.

    Why it happens: Description is easier than evaluation.

    State how effective each is and why.

Written for this site.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'Australia produces only about 1 per cent of global emissions, so its climate policy has no economic rationale.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1Free riding.

Hint 2Who bears the costs?

Hint 3Trade and new industries.

Discounting the future

Economists disagree about how much climate action is worth today largely because of the discount rate: how much less a dollar of damage in 2100 counts than a dollar today. Nicholas Stern's 2006 review used a very low rate, arguing that future generations' welfare should count almost equally, and recommended strong, immediate action. William Nordhaus used a higher, market-based rate and recommended a gradual increase in carbon prices.

The choice is partly ethical. A high discount rate places little weight on future generations, which conflicts with the intergenerational equity principle of ESD. A low rate places great weight on distant damage, supporting large costs today. The precautionary principle adds a further argument for acting early: the damage may be irreversible, and the risk of catastrophic outcomes is uncertain.