Public Goods and Free Riders
How public goods differ from private goods through non-excludability and non-rivalry, why free riding means markets underprovide them, how common resources suffer the tragedy of the commons, and how governments respond through provision, taxation, property rights and international agreements.
30 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues
Assumes you have read Externalities and Market Failure.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- Private goods are excludable (people who do not pay can be stopped from using them) and rival (one person's use leaves less for others). Markets supply them well.
- Public goods are non-excludable and non-rival: national defence, street lighting, flood levees, a stable climate, clean air.
- Because people can benefit without paying, they have an incentive to free ride. Private firms cannot charge enough to cover costs, so the market underprovides public goods, or provides none: market failure.
- Common resources such as fisheries, groundwater and the atmosphere are non-excludable but rival, so open access leads to overuse: the tragedy of the commons.
- Governments respond by providing public goods from taxation, and by creating and enforcing property rights, quotas and international agreements for common resources.
Private goods, public goods and common resources
AnswersWhat distinguishes public goods from private goods?
- Public good
A good that is non-excludable (people cannot be prevented from using it once it is provided) and non-rival (one person's use does not reduce the amount available to others).
- Free rider
A person who benefits from a good or service without paying for it, relying on others to cover the cost.
As your notes explain, the price mechanism works when a good is excludable: sellers can refuse to supply anyone who does not pay, so price reflects demand and supply. Economists classify goods using two questions.
| Rival | Non-rival | |
|---|---|---|
| Excludable | Private goods: food, clothing, cars, a house | Club goods: toll roads, streaming services, a private golf course |
| Non-excludable | Common resources: ocean fish, groundwater, grazing land, the atmosphere as a waste sink | Public goods: defence, street lighting, flood defences, weather forecasts, a stable climate |
Many environmental goods fall in the bottom row. Nobody can be excluded from breathing clean air or benefiting from a stable climate, and no single person owns a river or the atmosphere. This is why the environment is so prone to market failure.
Common mistake
A public good is any good provided by the government.
Why it happens: Governments provide many goods, so the terms seem interchangeable.
The definition depends on the good's characteristics, not who supplies it. Public hospitals and schools are provided by government, but they are excludable and rival (a hospital bed used by one patient cannot be used by another), so they are private goods with large positive externalities. Street lighting is a public good whoever pays for it.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which of the following is the best example of a public good?
Hint 1Can non-payers be excluded?
Hint 2Does one person's use reduce another's?
Hint 3Both must be true.
Why markets underprovide public goods
AnswersHow does the free rider problem cause market failure?
A firm that builds a flood levee cannot charge households behind it, because they are protected whether or not they pay. Each household reasons that if others pay, it gets the benefit free; and if others do not pay, its own contribution will not be enough. So each has an incentive to understate how much it values the good and wait for others to pay. As your notes explain, private markets are therefore unwilling to provide public goods, or underprovide them, even when their total benefit to society is far greater than their cost.
Worked example3 marks
The free rider problem in numbers
A levee would protect 50 households in a river town. Each values the protection at $4,000. The levee costs $120,000. Show that the levee is worth building, explain why it may not be built by the market, and explain how government can solve the problem.
Total benefit against cost
Total benefit dollars, which exceeds the cost of $120,000. The levee adds $80,000 to society's welfare.
Why the market fails
No household values the levee at anything near $120,000, so none will build it alone. If a firm asked for voluntary payments, each household would be protected whether or not it paid, so many would pay little or nothing. The firm cannot raise $120,000, and the levee is not built.
The government's solution
Government can build the levee and fund it through taxes or council rates of $2,400 per household. Every household is better off by dollars, and compulsory payment removes the incentive to free ride.
Answer
The levee's benefit ($200,000) exceeds its cost ($120,000), but free riding prevents private provision. Public provision financed by compulsory taxation delivers the efficient outcome.
Is that answer sensible?
The same logic applies to climate change at a global scale: every country benefits from lower global emissions whether or not it cuts its own, so each has an incentive to free ride on the efforts of others.
Chain of reasoning
How free riding leads to underprovision
Ability to exclude non-payers falls
the good is non-excludableWillingness to pay revealed falls
people free ride on othersRevenue to private suppliers falls
below the cost of provisionQuantity provided falls
below the social optimum, or none at all: market failure
Exam question
Standard · about 5 min
3 marks
Explain why the free rider problem causes the market to underprovide public goods. (3 marks)
Hint 1Non-excludability.
Hint 2Incentive to pay nothing.
Hint 3Revenue and supply.
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing public goods without the incentive.
Why it happens: Definitions are easy to recall.
Explain why individuals will not pay.
Written for this site.
Common resources and the tragedy of the commons
AnswersWhy are common resources overused?
Common resources are non-excludable but rival. Each fish caught is one fewer for others, but no one can be stopped from fishing. As your notes explain, property rights make the price mechanism efficient when they are excludable, transferable and enforceable. Environmental goods usually lack them, so each user takes as much as they can before others do. The result is overexploitation and depletion: the tragedy of the commons.
Australian examples
- Water in the Murray-Darling Basin. Before caps, irrigators extracted water faster than rivers could sustain, degrading wetlands and water quality. The Basin Plan created sustainable diversion limits and tradable water entitlements: a cap on the total, with property rights that can be bought and sold.
- Fisheries. Commonwealth fisheries use individual transferable quotas, giving each operator a right to a share of a total allowable catch set to let stocks regenerate.
- The atmosphere. Until emissions are priced or capped, firms use the atmosphere as a free waste sink. The Safeguard Mechanism gives large emitters a baseline, in effect a limited right to emit.
Common mistake
Creating property rights over a resource guarantees it will be used sustainably.
Why it happens: Ownership creates incentives to conserve.
Property rights only help if the total is capped at a sustainable level and the rights are enforced. As your notes point out, mining leases are property rights over environmental goods, yet they do not prevent exploitation, because the owner's incentive is to extract, not conserve.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain the tragedy of the commons and assess ONE policy used in Australia to address it. (4 marks)
Hint 1Rival but non-excludable.
Hint 2Missing property rights.
Hint 3Water or fisheries.
How governments respond
AnswersHow do governments respond to public goods and common resources?
| Problem | Government response | Australian example |
|---|---|---|
| Public goods underprovided | Direct provision, funded by compulsory taxation | Defence, national parks, the Bureau of Meteorology, flood levees, CSIRO research |
| Environmental public goods | Funding conservation and restoration | Protected area estate over 22 per cent of land (CAPAD 2024), Reef protection funding |
| Common resources overused | Property rights and caps | Water entitlements, fishing quotas, Safeguard baselines |
| Global public goods | International agreements | The Paris Agreement; Australia's 2035 target of 62 to 70 per cent below 2005 |
As your notes observe, the free rider incentive undermines private provision, so government provides public goods itself. The difficulty is deciding how much to provide: without prices, government must estimate the value people place on goods like biodiversity, and the opportunity cost is spending on other programs.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'Public schools are public goods because the government provides them.' Which response is best?
Hint 1What defines a public good?
Hint 2Is a school place rival?
Hint 3Can students be excluded?
Climate change as a global public good
A stable climate is the largest public good of all. Every country benefits from lower global emissions, whether or not it cuts its own, and the costs of cutting fall on the country that acts. Each country therefore has an incentive to free ride. Australia produces about 1 per cent of global emissions, which is why some argue its own action makes little difference.
The economic answer is that free riding is only defeated by collective commitment. The Paris Agreement relies on each country setting its own target and reporting progress, with peer pressure rather than penalties. Its weakness is enforcement: the United States withdrew for the second time from January 2026. Trade policy may add enforcement: the European Union's carbon border adjustment mechanism puts a price on the emissions in imports of steel, aluminium, cement and fertiliser, reducing the gain from free riding for exporters.