Effects of Microeconomic Policies
How microeconomic reform has changed individual product and factor markets and industries (finance, agriculture, aviation, telecommunications and energy), the structural change it produced, and its effects on growth, inflation, employment, external stability and income distribution, with an essay plan evaluating microeconomic policy.
45 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management
Assumes you have read Rationale for Microeconomic Policies.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- Product markets are markets for goods and services; factor markets are markets for inputs (labour, capital, land, finance, energy). Reform in factor markets lowers costs for every industry that uses them.
- Industry cases:
- Finance (deregulated in the 1980s): more competition and innovation, but the GFC and the 2019 Royal Commission showed the need for regulation.
- Agriculture (statutory marketing monopolies ended): consolidation and higher productivity.
- Aviation (deregulated 1990): lower fares, though the market is now highly concentrated after the collapse of Bonza and Rex's administration in 2024.
- Telecommunications (competition from 1991, Telstra privatised): lower prices and new services; NBN built as a wholesale-only network.
- Structural change: employment shifted from manufacturing and agriculture to services; car manufacturing closed in 2017; the care economy is now the largest employing sector.
- Effects on the economy: higher productivity and growth in the 1990s, lower inflation, better competitiveness. Costs: structural unemployment, regional decline and uneven distribution of gains.
- Judgement: effective in the long run, when it has been done, but reform slowed after the early 2000s, and productivity growth slowed with it.
Effects on individual markets and industries
AnswersHow has microeconomic policy affected particular markets and industries in Australia?
As your notes explain, deregulation (removing or simplifying rules that constrain market forces) has been a major form of reform, and it drives structural change.
Financial sector (factor market).
- Reform: in the 1980s, interest rate controls were removed, the dollar was floated in 1983, and foreign banks were allowed to enter.
- Effects: more competition and innovation (internet and mobile banking, new loan products); lower interest margins and operating costs; greater access to overseas capital, which lowered the cost of finance for all industries.
- Limits: the GFC showed the risk of too little regulation. The 2014 Murray Inquiry raised banks' capital requirements, which left them strong enough to keep lending during COVID. The 2019 Banking Royal Commission exposed misconduct and led to tougher enforcement. Buy now, pay later products have been regulated as credit since June 2025.
Agriculture (product and factor market).
- Reform: in the 1990s and 2000s, statutory marketing monopolies for wheat, dairy and wool and minimum price schemes were removed under the National Competition Policy.
- Effects: farmers faced competition and incentives to innovate. Farms consolidated to gain economies of scale, so there are fewer farms but higher output. Labour and capital were released to other industries.
- Limits: broadacre productivity growth has slowed since 2000, which ABARES attributes mainly to drought, a hotter and drier climate and slower growth in agricultural research.
Aviation (product market).
- Reform: the Two Airline Policy ended in 1990.
- Effects: low-cost carriers such as Virgin Blue and Jetstar entered the market, fares fell and passenger numbers grew several times over.
- Limits: Bonza collapsed and Rex entered administration in 2024, leaving the Qantas Group and Virgin Australia with the great majority of domestic passengers. The 2024 Aviation White Paper aims to strengthen competition, including through reforms to Sydney Airport slot rules.
Telecommunications (product and factor market).
- Reform: competition was introduced from 1991, Telstra was privatised in stages from 1997, and access rules required owners of networks to share them with competitors.
- Effects: prices fell and services such as mobile and broadband spread quickly.
- Limits: Telstra's ownership of the copper network limited competition, so the government built the NBN as a wholesale-only network. It is to remain in public ownership for the foreseeable future.
Energy (factor market).
- Reform: the National Electricity Market created a competitive wholesale market, and state generators and retailers were privatised.
- Effects: early NCP reforms lowered electricity prices.
- Recent: the transition to renewables, network costs and the 2022 gas price shock raised prices. Governments have re-regulated through default market offers and gas price caps, and underwrite new renewable supply through the Capacity Investment Scheme.
Exam question
Harder · about 9 min
5 marks
With reference to ONE industry, explain the effects of microeconomic reform on efficiency, prices and the structure of the industry. (5 marks)
Hint 1Choose finance, agriculture, aviation, telecommunications or energy.
Hint 2Reform, then efficiency.
Hint 3Limits.
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing the industry without linking to efficiency.
Why it happens: Case studies are descriptive.
Name the type of efficiency each change improves.
Written for this site.
Structural change from microeconomic policy
AnswersWhat structural changes in the Australian economy have resulted from microeconomic policies?
- Structural change
A change in the pattern of production and employment across industries, regions and occupations over time. Some industries decline (sunset industries) and others expand (sunrise industries).
Microeconomic reform drives structural change by exposing industries to competition, domestic and international. Resources move from less efficient to more efficient uses, which improves allocative efficiency.
| Reform | Structural change |
|---|---|
| Tariff cuts from the 1980s (to 5 per cent or less on most goods) | Manufacturing declined as a share of output and employment; textiles, clothing and footwear shrank; car manufacturing ended in 2017 when Ford, Holden and Toyota closed their plants |
| Agricultural deregulation | Consolidation into larger farms; labour released to towns and cities |
| Financial deregulation and the float | Growth of financial and professional services; integration with global capital markets |
| Competition policy and privatisation | Government monopolies became competitive businesses; growth of new entrants in telecommunications, aviation and energy |
| Trade liberalisation and agreements | Growth of industries with comparative advantage: mining, education, tourism, professional services |
The overall shift. Services now account for about four-fifths of employment. Health care and social assistance has become the largest employing industry, reflecting ageing, the NDIS and the care economy, while manufacturing's share of employment has fallen to under 7 per cent.
Not all structural change comes from policy. Technology, the rise of China and the mining boom, and population ageing also drive it; reform determines how quickly and smoothly the economy adjusts.
Chain of reasoning
From tariff cuts to structural change
Tariff protection falls
imports become cheaperOutput of protected manufacturing falls
inefficient firms closeStructural unemployment in affected regions rises
workers' skills do not match new jobsResources in industries of comparative advantage rises
allocative efficiency improves over time
Exam question
Standard · about 7 min
4 marks
Investigate how tariff reductions since the 1980s have caused structural change in the Australian economy. (4 marks)
Hint 1Protected industries.
Hint 2Resource movement.
Hint 3Evidence.
Where students lose marks on this one
Attributing all structural change to tariffs.
Why it happens: Tariffs were the most visible reform.
Technology, China and ageing also drive structural change.
Written for this site.
Effects on the whole economy
AnswersWhat have been the overall effects of microeconomic policy on the Australian economy?
As your notes explain, reform brings long-run benefits and short-run costs.
| Benefits | Costs |
|---|---|
| Higher efficiency and productivity growth | Higher unemployment in the short run, especially structural unemployment |
| Higher sustainable growth and living standards | Closure of inefficient businesses and regional decline |
| Lower inflation, through competition and lower costs | Greater work intensity and job insecurity |
| Better international competitiveness, supporting exports | Gains can be unevenly shared, widening inequality |
- Growth and living standards. The Productivity Commission estimated that the National Competition Policy reforms raised GDP by about 2.5 per cent by 2005-06. Labour productivity growth averaged about 2.3 per cent a year in the 1990s.
- Inflation. Competition lowered prices in reformed industries, including telecommunications and freight, and allowed the economy to grow faster without inflation, helping to keep inflation in the target band for most of the period after 1993.
- External stability. Lower input costs improved competitiveness in the tradable sector.
- Employment. Short-run job losses, such as the tens of thousands of jobs lost in car making and its suppliers, were offset over time by jobs in expanding industries. Unemployment fell from about 11 per cent in 1993 to around 4 per cent before the GFC.
- Distribution. Your notes point out that the costs have often fallen on lower-skilled workers and particular regions, while gains have gone to owners of capital and skilled workers.
The slowdown. As reform slowed after the early 2000s, productivity growth slowed, to about 1.1 per cent a year in the 2010s and 0.3 per cent in the decade to 2024-25. Many economists see this as evidence that reform works, and that its absence has a cost.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which is a short-run cost of microeconomic reform?
Hint 1Structural change.
Hint 2Skills mismatch.
Hint 3Short run.
Essay plan: evaluating microeconomic policy
AnswersHow should an essay evaluating microeconomic policy be structured?
Essay planpriority 2 of 16 · 20 marks
Evaluate the effectiveness of microeconomic policies in achieving the economic objectives of the Australian government.
- Evaluate
- Judge worth against criteria, weighing strengths against weaknesses, and conclude.
- Thesis
- Microeconomic policy has been effective in the long run in achieving sustainable growth and price stability by shifting aggregate supply, as the productivity surge of the 1990s showed. Its effectiveness since the mid-2000s has been limited by the slow pace of reform, and its costs have fallen on particular workers and regions, so it achieves growth and efficiency objectives more reliably than equity objectives.
Microeconomic policy raises sustainable growth by increasing productivity and shifting aggregate supply.
This paragraph sets the main criterion. The recent slowdown supports the argument by showing the cost of too little reform.
- Theory
- AD-AS with AS shifting right; allocative, technical and dynamic efficiency; productivity as the source of long-run growth in income per person.
- Diagram
- AD-AS diagram with AS shifting right, showing higher output and a lower price level.
- Evidence
- Labour productivity growth of about 2.3 per cent a year in the 1990s after the reforms of the 1980s and 1990s; NCP estimated to have raised GDP by about 2.5 per cent by 2005-06; productivity growth fell to about 0.3 per cent a year in the decade to 2024-25 as reform slowed.
- Against
- Part of the 1990s surge reflected the global technology boom, and part of the recent slowdown is global, so not all changes in productivity can be attributed to domestic policy.
Competition policy has lowered prices and supported price stability, but concentration remains high in several markets.
Use the recent concentration as a qualification, not a contradiction.
- Theory
- Competition improves technical efficiency and lowers prices; market power allows firms to raise prices above costs.
- Diagram
- None needed.
- Evidence
- Lower prices after NCP in electricity, gas, telecommunications and aviation; ACCC supermarkets inquiry in 2025 and a mandatory Food and Grocery Code from April 2025; mandatory merger notification from 1 January 2026; a revitalised National Competition Policy agreed in 2024.
- Against
- Aviation became highly concentrated after 2024, and energy prices rose with the transition to renewables and the 2022 gas shock, which shows competition policy alone cannot guarantee lower prices.
Labour market reform has increased flexibility and helped lower the NAIRU, but its effect on productivity is debated.
Link to priority 7 for more depth.
- Theory
- Decentralised bargaining links pay to productivity; a lower NAIRU permits lower unemployment without accelerating inflation.
- Diagram
- Long-run Phillips curve shifting left.
- Evidence
- Enterprise bargaining since the 1990s; unemployment fell from about 11 per cent in 1993 to 3.4 per cent in October 2022; the 2022 Secure Jobs, Better Pay reforms introduced multi-employer bargaining for low-paid sectors; Treasury's long-run NAIRU assumption is 4.25 per cent.
- Against
- Enterprise agreement coverage has fallen and wages growth was weak in the late 2010s, so the productivity gains from bargaining have faded.
Tax, infrastructure and skills policies improve the supply side, although with long lags.
Judge these as promising but unproven.
- Theory
- Investment in human and physical capital raises productivity; tax incentives change the allocation of investment.
- Diagram
- None needed.
- Evidence
- The \$20,000 instant asset write-off made permanent in the 2026-27 Budget; fee-free TAFE, to be made permanent from 2027; 2026-27 changes to negative gearing and capital gains concessions to favour new housing supply; the productivity package cutting business compliance costs by about \$10.2 billion a year.
- Against
- The gains take many years, are hard to measure, and depend on complementary reforms in planning and state regulation, which are slow.
Microeconomic policy has been less effective in achieving equity, because its costs fall on particular workers and regions.
This is the paragraph that justifies the qualified judgement.
- Theory
- Structural change causes structural unemployment; gains go to owners of capital and skilled workers.
- Diagram
- None needed.
- Evidence
- The closure of car manufacturing in 2017 affected tens of thousands of workers, including in component suppliers; regional communities dependent on coal face the same adjustment in the energy transition; relative poverty rose to 14.2 per cent in 2022-23.
- Against
- Labour market programs, retraining and the tax and transfer system can compensate those who lose, and higher growth provides the revenue to do so.
Judgement
Evaluate means make a judgement based on criteria. Use productivity growth as the main criterion, then assess the effect on each objective. Judge microeconomic policy as highly effective when implemented, but weakened by slow reform since the 2000s, with the recent revival too early to judge.
The full response also needs: The rationale for microeconomic policies lesson for the AS model and efficiency, the competition policy lesson, and the labour market and environmental management lessons for further evidence.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'Deregulation always increases competition.' Which response is best?
Hint 1Aviation after 2024.
Hint 2Barriers to entry.
Hint 3Better regulation.
Did deregulation go too far?
Three industries show that reform is a question of balance rather than direction.
In finance, deregulation brought competition and innovation, but the GFC abroad and the misconduct uncovered by the Royal Commission at home led to more regulation, not less. Australia's banks came through both episodes well partly because of the regulation that followed.
In electricity, privatisation and competition initially lowered prices, but a market designed around coal generators struggled with the transition to renewables. Governments now intervene heavily through price caps, underwriting schemes and public investment in transmission and storage.
In aviation, deregulation lowered fares, but the market has returned to near duopoly. The lesson is that removing regulation does not by itself create competition: new entrants need access to airport slots, networks and finance.
The modern consensus is better regulation, not simply less: remove rules that protect incumbents, and keep or strengthen rules that correct market failures and protect consumers.