HSC Study

Regulation, Deregulation and Competition Policy

How governments balance regulation and deregulation, why public trading enterprises were corporatised and privatised, what the National Competition Policy and the ACCC do, the conduct the Competition and Consumer Act bans, and recent reforms including the mandatory merger regime, the supermarkets inquiry and the revitalised National Competition Policy.

35 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management

Assumes you have read Rationale for Microeconomic Policies.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Regulation is a set of rules that governs how firms behave. Deregulation removes rules that restrict competition. Good policy is a balance: too much regulation raises costs and deters entry, too little allows market failure and instability.
  • Public trading enterprises (PTEs) have been reformed in two ways:
    • corporatisation, where they run at arm's length from government and aim for commercial returns (Australia Post, Sydney Water);
    • privatisation, where they are sold (Qantas, the Commonwealth Bank, Telstra, Medibank, NSW electricity networks).
  • National Competition Policy (NCP) from 1995 extended competition to natural monopoly sectors such as electricity, gas and water, introduced competitive neutrality and access regimes, and set up the ACCC. The Productivity Commission estimated it raised GDP by about 2.5 per cent.
  • Banned conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act includes misuse of market power, cartels (price fixing and market sharing), exclusive dealing and mergers that substantially lessen competition.
  • Recent reforms:
    • higher maximum penalties from 2022;
    • the ACCC supermarkets inquiry, reported in 2025;
    • a mandatory Food and Grocery Code from April 2025;
    • a mandatory merger notification regime from 1 January 2026;
    • a revitalised NCP agreed in 2024.

Regulation and deregulation: striking a balance

AnswersWhy is effective regulation a balance between too much and too little?

Regulation

Rules imposed by government that govern the behaviour of firms and individuals, such as rules on prices, entry into an industry, safety, the environment and consumer protection.

Deregulation

The removal of government rules that restrict competition or the operation of markets, such as limits on the number of firms, controls on prices or restrictions on ownership.

As your notes explain, effective regulation involves striking a balance between competing policy goals:

  • Excessive regulation raises business costs, reduces investment, discourages new firms from entering markets and lowers growth. Compliance costs ("red tape") also absorb resources that could be used productively.
  • Inadequate regulation allows market failure, such as a lack of competition, pollution or exploitation of consumers, and can cause economic instability. The tension is clearest in the financial sector, where a crisis spreads across the whole economy.

Australia removed many regulations that restricted competition from the 1980s, including the Two Airline Policy, controls on interest rates and bank lending, and the statutory marketing boards in agriculture. It is now less regulated than most advanced economies, but regulation remains important where:

  • large firms dominate and could charge high prices: prices and investment in electricity networks, gas pipelines, water, postal services and telecommunications are overseen by regulators, and the Default Market Offer caps standing electricity prices;
  • safety and the environment are at risk, as in construction, transport, mining and agriculture;
  • new markets emerge: governments responded to ridesharing, homesharing and buy now pay later with new transport, planning, tax and consumer credit laws, and are now considering rules for digital platforms and artificial intelligence.

Deregulation is therefore often accompanied by re-regulation: removing rules that restrict entry, and adding rules that make competition work, such as access to infrastructure and consumer protection.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which statement best describes effective regulation?

Select one answer

Hint 1Costs of too much.

Hint 2Costs of too little.

Hint 3Balance.

Reforming public trading enterprises

AnswersHow have governments tried to make public trading enterprises more efficient?

Public trading enterprise (PTE)

A business owned and run by a Commonwealth or state government that sells goods or services, such as a water utility or a postal service.

As your notes explain, governments have used two main approaches.

CorporatisationPrivatisation
What it isThe PTE runs independently of day-to-day political direction, with managers accountable for commercial performanceThe PTE is sold to private owners, in whole or in part, or its assets are leased long term
AimA rate of return comparable to private firms; competitive neutrality with private rivalsCompetitive and profit pressure to improve efficiency; one-off revenue for government
ExamplesAustralia Post, Sydney Water, Hunter WaterCommonwealth Bank, Qantas, Telstra, Medibank Private (2014), NSW electricity networks (leased 2015 to 2017)

Benefits. Profit pressure encourages PTEs to cut costs (technical efficiency) and to price closer to cost (allocative efficiency). State governments have used sale proceeds to fund infrastructure: NSW used its electricity network leases to fund transport projects under its asset recycling strategy.

Limits. Your notes explain that selling a monopoly asset such as a port or electricity grid transfers monopoly power to a private owner, which can raise prices unless the asset is regulated. A sale also gives up the future stream of profits, so it does not improve the government's long-run financial position unless the price exceeds the value of those profits.

A shift away from privatisation. Governments have become more cautious:

  • the NBN, set up in 2009, remains in public ownership, and the government has said it will stay that way;
  • NSW legislated in 2023 to prevent the privatisation of Sydney Water and Hunter Water;
  • governments have taken back a larger role in energy through public investment in transmission and storage, such as Snowy Hydro 2.0.

Exam question

Standard · about 7 min

4 marks

Distinguish between corporatisation and privatisation, and explain ONE limitation of privatising a monopoly asset. (4 marks)

Hint 1Ownership.

Hint 2Commercial targets.

Hint 3Monopoly power.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating corporatisation as a sale.

    Why it happens: Both make PTEs commercial.

    Corporatised enterprises stay in public ownership.

Written for this site.

National Competition Policy and the ACCC

AnswersWhat is competition policy and what does the ACCC do?

Competition policy

Government policy that promotes competition in markets, so that firms have an incentive to improve efficiency and lower prices, by removing barriers to entry and prohibiting anti-competitive conduct.

The National Competition Policy was agreed by the Commonwealth and the states in 1995, following the Hilmer Review. Your notes list its key features:

  • Competition in natural monopoly sectors. Electricity, gas, water, rail and road transport were restructured, separating the monopoly network from parts of the industry where firms can compete, such as generation and retailing.
  • Competitive neutrality. Government businesses lost special advantages, such as tax exemptions, over private firms.
  • Access regime. Owners of monopoly infrastructure such as ports, pipelines and telecommunications networks must give competitors access at a reasonable price.
  • Workable competition. The aim is enough competition to keep firms efficient, while allowing firms to grow large enough to reach the lowest long-run average cost.
  • The ACCC. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission enforces the Competition and Consumer Act 2010, monitors prices, reviews mergers and protects consumers.

Conduct banned under the Competition and Consumer Act

ConductWhat it is
Misuse of market powerA firm with substantial market power engages in conduct that has the purpose or effect of substantially lessening competition, such as below-cost pricing to drive out a rival
Cartel conductCompetitors agree to fix prices, share markets, rig bids or restrict output. Serious cartel conduct is a criminal offence
Exclusive dealingA supplier imposes conditions that stop a customer dealing with rivals, where this substantially lessens competition
Anti-competitive mergersAcquisitions that would substantially lessen competition in a market
Misleading conductFalse or misleading claims to consumers, including about prices and discounts

Your notes also mention price discrimination, charging different customers different prices for reasons unrelated to cost. It is not banned as such, but it shows market power: the more power a firm has, the more it can charge each customer what they are willing to pay.

Effects of NCP. The Productivity Commission estimated NCP and related reforms raised GDP by about 2.5 per cent by 2005-06, well short of the original estimate of 5.5 per cent. Prices of electricity and gas for business fell sharply in the years after reform, and productivity in utilities improved.

The Harper Review (2015) recommended extending competition principles to government services such as health and aged care, and strengthening the misuse of market power test. In 2017 the test was changed to catch conduct with the effect of substantially lessening competition, not only the purpose.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Explain how the National Competition Policy and the ACCC promote competition in the Australian economy. (5 marks)

Hint 1Natural monopolies.

Hint 2Competitive neutrality and access.

Hint 3Banned conduct.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing banned conduct without explaining its effect.

    Why it happens: Lists are easy to remember.

    Link each rule to competition and efficiency.

Written for this site.

Recent competition reform

AnswersWhat has competition policy done since 2022?

Concern about concentrated markets has put competition policy back at the centre of microeconomic reform. Many Australian markets, including supermarkets, domestic aviation, banking and fuel, are dominated by a few firms, and the Productivity Commission links weak competition to slow productivity growth.

Tougher enforcement

  • Higher penalties. From November 2022, maximum penalties for competition and consumer law breaches rose to the greatest of $50 million, three times the benefit gained, or 30 per cent of turnover during the breach.
  • Qantas. In 2024 the Federal Court ordered Qantas to pay a $100 million penalty for selling tickets on flights it had already cancelled, plus about $20 million in remediation to customers.
  • Supermarkets. The ACCC took Coles and Woolworths to court in 2024 over allegedly misleading discount claims.

Supermarkets

  • The ACCC supermarkets inquiry (final report 2025) found that Coles and Woolworths form an oligopoly with little price competition between them, and that they are among the most profitable supermarket businesses in the world. It recommended measures to make price comparison easier and encourage entry.
  • The Food and Grocery Code of Conduct became mandatory from 1 April 2025, with significant penalties for large supermarkets that mistreat suppliers.

Merger reform. From 1 January 2026, acquisitions above set thresholds must be notified to the ACCC and cannot proceed until it approves them. Previously notification was voluntary, and the ACCC had to prove in court that a merger would lessen competition. The change aims to stop "creeping acquisitions" that concentrate markets.

A revitalised NCP. In 2024 the Commonwealth and states agreed to revitalise the National Competition Policy, with a National Productivity Fund that pays states for pro-competitive reforms, such as mutual recognition of occupational licences and planning reform.

Chain of reasoning

  1. Competition policy rises

    Tougher enforcement, merger control, easier entry
  2. Market power falls

    Firms face rivals and cannot raise margins
  3. Efficiency rises

    Pressure to cut costs and innovate
  4. Prices falls

    Lower margins and costs pass to consumers
  5. Aggregate supply rises

    Higher productivity lifts capacity

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 11 min

6 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of recent competition policy in addressing concentrated markets in Australia. (6 marks)

Hint 1Enforcement and penalties.

Hint 2Supermarkets and mergers.

Hint 3Limits.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing reforms without judging their effect.

    Why it happens: Evaluate asks for a judgement.

    State how effective, and why.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

Deregulation and competition policy are the same thing.

Why it happens: Both aim to increase competition.

Deregulation removes rules. Competition policy often adds rules: it bans cartels, controls mergers and forces access to infrastructure. Markets with few firms do not become competitive just because rules are removed; they often need active competition law.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'Competition policy is a form of deregulation because it removes government rules.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1What competition law does.

Hint 2Adding rules.

Hint 3Merger control.

Is bigger always worse?

Competition policy does not aim for the largest possible number of firms. Your notes describe workable competition: enough rivalry to keep firms efficient, while letting them grow large enough to reach the lowest long-run average cost. In a small economy such as Australia, some industries can only support a few firms at efficient scale, and firms competing in world markets may need scale to match overseas rivals.

This is why the ACCC and the Competition Tribunal sometimes allow mergers that reduce the number of firms. In 2024 the Tribunal authorised ANZ's acquisition of Suncorp Bank after the ACCC had opposed it, accepting that the merger would not substantially lessen competition. Critics argued it further concentrated banking.

The question is always whether the market remains contestable: whether the threat of entry keeps existing firms efficient. Where barriers to entry are high, such as supermarkets needing sites, supply chains and scale, a concentrated market can earn high margins for a long time, and competition policy has to work harder, through access rules, merger control and making it easier for consumers to compare and switch.