Types and Causes of Unemployment
The four main types of unemployment (cyclical, structural, frictional and seasonal), how to tell them apart, and the causes of unemployment in Australia, from weak aggregate demand and policy settings to structural and technological change, productivity and labour costs.
40 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues
Assumes you have read Measuring Unemployment.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
| Type | Cause | Example | Does stimulating demand help? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cyclical | A downturn in aggregate demand | The rise to 7.4 per cent in July 2020 | Yes |
| Structural | A mismatch between workers' skills or locations and the jobs available, from technological and structural change | Car workers after the plants closed in 2016 and 2017 | Little: needs retraining and mobility |
| Frictional | Time taken to move between jobs | A graduate searching for a first job | No, and some is healthy |
| Seasonal | Regular, predictable patterns in the year | Fruit pickers after harvest, school leavers each summer | No |
Causes of unemployment:
- weak aggregate demand and slow growth
- tight macroeconomic policy
- constraints on growth, such as inflation and the external balance
- rising participation
- structural and technological change
- productivity growth
- inadequate training
- high labour costs.
Cyclical unemployment
AnswersWhat is cyclical unemployment?
- Cyclical unemployment
Unemployment caused by a downturn in economic activity. It rises in contractions, when aggregate demand is too low to employ the whole labour force, and falls in expansions.
The demand for labour is a derived demand: firms hire workers to produce goods and services that people want to buy. When aggregate demand, C + I + G + (X − M), falls, firms cut production. They retrench workers, which raises unemployment, or cut hours, which raises underemployment. In the Keynesian model this is equilibrium below full employment: a deflationary gap.
Chain of reasoning
How a fall in demand causes cyclical unemployment
- Aggregate demand falls, for example as higher interest rates cut consumption and investment.
- Firms sell less, build up stock and cut production.
- Because the demand for labour is derived from the demand for output, firms cut hours and jobs.
- Unemployed workers spend less, and the multiplier spreads the fall in demand, adding to unemployment.
Australian example. The rise in unemployment from 5.1 per cent in February 2020 to 7.4 per cent in July 2020 was mostly cyclical. Spending collapsed as restrictions closed businesses. Most of it disappeared as demand recovered: unemployment was back to 5.1 per cent by May 2021.
Cyclical unemployment is the type that macroeconomic policy can reduce. Lower interest rates or more government spending raise demand. In the COVID recession this was done with JobKeeper and a cash rate of 0.10 per cent.
Structural unemployment
AnswersWhat is structural unemployment?
- Structural unemployment
Unemployment caused by a mismatch between the skills or locations of the unemployed and the jobs available. It results from structural change in the economy: changes in technology, in the pattern of demand, and from microeconomic reform.
Structural change creates sunset industries, which are shrinking, and sunrise industries, which are growing. Workers who lose jobs in sunset industries often lack the skills, or do not live in the right places, for jobs in sunrise industries.
- Tariff cuts from the late 1980s reduced employment in textiles, clothing and footwear, and in car manufacturing. The last car plants, run by Ford, Holden and Toyota, closed in 2016 and 2017. Many workers were in their 40s and 50s, with skills specific to car assembly.
- Services have grown to account for the great majority of jobs, especially health care, professional services and education. Many of these require qualifications that displaced manufacturing workers did not have.
- Privatisation and corporatisation of government businesses in the 1990s reduced their workforces.
Structural unemployment does not fall much when demand is stimulated, because the jobs created need different skills or are in different places. It is reduced by microeconomic and labour market policies: retraining, education, help to relocate, and better job matching.
Common mistake
Workers in a factory that closes during a recession are cyclically unemployed.
Why it happens: The job loss happens during a downturn.
Ask whether the job will come back when demand recovers. If the factory closed because demand fell temporarily and it will reopen, the unemployment is cyclical. If it closed for good because of cheaper imports or new technology, the jobs will not return, and the unemployment is structural. Recessions often speed up structural change, so many job losses in downturns become structural.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A printing works closes permanently because newspapers and magazines have moved online. Its press operators cannot find work because local job vacancies are mainly in health care and software. What type of unemployment is this?
Hint 1Will the jobs come back when demand recovers?
Hint 2Do the workers have the skills for the vacancies?
Hint 3Sunset and sunrise industries.
Frictional and seasonal unemployment
AnswersWhat are frictional and seasonal unemployment?
- Frictional unemployment
Short-term unemployment of people moving between jobs or entering the labour force, reflecting the time taken for workers to find suitable jobs and for employers to find suitable workers.
Frictional unemployment is always present, and some of it is a healthy sign. It means workers are free to move to jobs where they are more productive and better paid. It rises when job matching is slow and can be reduced by better information: online job boards, skills databases and employment services. Job switching slowed to record lows in the pandemic and then picked up as the labour market tightened.
- Seasonal unemployment
Unemployment that occurs at regular, predictable times of the year because some work is seasonal.
Examples:
- Fruit picking and other agricultural work outside harvest.
- Ski resort staff in summer.
- Retail staff after Christmas.
- Students leaving school, TAFE and university who enter the labour market between December and March each year.
The ABS removes these regular patterns in its seasonally adjusted series. That is why news reports and exam data usually quote seasonally adjusted rates.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which of the following is an example of SEASONAL unemployment?
Hint 1Seasonal unemployment is regular and predictable.
Hint 2Which one happens at the same time every year?
Hint 3Harvests and holidays.
- Natural rate of unemployment
The unemployment that remains when there is no cyclical unemployment: frictional, seasonal and structural unemployment. It is closely related to the NAIRU.
Exam question
Standard · about 6 min
4 marks
Distinguish between cyclical and structural unemployment, and explain why they require different policy responses. (4 marks)
Hint 1What causes each type?
Hint 2What happens to each when demand recovers?
Hint 3Macroeconomic versus microeconomic policies.
Where students lose marks on this one
Defining the types without the policy link.
Why it happens: The question has two parts.
Explain why demand stimulus works for one and not the other.
Written for this site.
Common mistake
Frictional unemployment is a problem the government should try to eliminate.
Why it happens: All unemployment sounds bad.
Some frictional unemployment is a sign of a dynamic labour market, in which people leave jobs to find better ones. Policy aims to make job matching faster, not to stop people changing jobs. Zero frictional unemployment would mean no one ever moved between jobs.
Exam question
Standard · about 2 min
1 mark
A student writes: 'The government should aim to eliminate frictional unemployment completely.' What is wrong with this?
Hint 1What is frictional unemployment?
Hint 2Why do people change jobs?
Hint 3What could policy sensibly do?
Where students lose marks on this one
Treating all unemployment as equally bad.
Why it happens: Unemployment sounds bad.
Some frictional unemployment reflects mobility.
Written for this site.
The causes of unemployment
AnswersWhat are the causes of unemployment in Australia?
Your notes list nine causes. The first three work mainly through demand, and cause cyclical unemployment. The rest work through the structure and costs of the labour market, and cause structural unemployment.
1. The level of economic growth. Weak aggregate demand means weak demand for labour.
- Growth above about 3 per cent a year has tended to reduce unemployment.
- Growth of 2 to 3 per cent has kept it roughly stable.
- Growth below 2 per cent has tended to raise it.
With lower productivity and labour force growth, the threshold is now lower. Unemployment is a lagging indicator: firms wait until they are confident a change in demand will last before hiring or firing. Reserve Bank research finds that the peak effect of a change in activity on unemployment comes after about two years.
2. The stance of macroeconomic policy.
- Expansionary monetary and fiscal policy raise demand and reduce cyclical unemployment.
- Contractionary policy, used to reduce inflation, raises it. The rise in the cash rate from 0.10 to 4.35 per cent between 2022 and 2023 slowed growth and contributed to the rise in unemployment from 3.4 to 4.6 per cent.
3. Constraints on growth. If growth exceeds the economy's capacity, inflation rises and the current account deficit widens as imports grow. Policy must then slow the economy, which limits how far unemployment can fall.
4. Rising participation. When the economy recovers, discouraged jobseekers start looking again and join the unemployed until they find work. So unemployment can fall only slowly even when employment grows strongly.
5. Structural change. Tariff cuts, privatisation and globalisation shrank manufacturing and expanded services, leaving workers whose skills no longer match the jobs available.
6. Technological change.
- In the short run, technology substitutes capital for labour and changes the skills employers want: automated mines, self-service checkouts and warehouse robots.
- Artificial intelligence may transform many office and professional jobs in the 2020s.
- Over time, technology also creates new industries and jobs, and raises incomes that are spent on other goods and services.
7. Productivity. As Okun's law shows, faster productivity growth means fewer workers per unit of output. That can raise unemployment in the short run, although it raises growth and jobs in the long run.
8. Inadequate training. Where the education and training system does not produce the skills employers need, skill shortages coexist with unemployment. Persistent shortages in trades, health care and construction have made Australia rely on skilled migration.
9. Labour costs. Wages that grow faster than productivity raise unit labour costs, and firms may cut jobs or substitute capital. Higher on-costs, such as payroll tax and superannuation, add to the cost of employing labour; the superannuation guarantee rose to 12 per cent in July 2025. Large rises in minimum and award wages may reduce jobs for lower skilled workers, though economists disagree about how large this effect is.
Exam question
Standard · about 7 min
4 marks
Explain TWO causes of the rise in Australia's unemployment rate between 2023 and 2026. (4 marks)
Hint 1What did the Reserve Bank do?
Hint 2What happened to the labour force?
Hint 3Use figures.
Where students lose marks on this one
Blaming a recession.
Why it happens: Unemployment rises in recessions.
There was no recession; growth slowed.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Harder · about 5 min
3 marks
Explain how technological change such as artificial intelligence can affect unemployment in both the short run and the long run. (3 marks)
Hint 1Short run: substitution and skills.
Hint 2Long run: productivity and new industries.
Hint 3Who is affected?
Where students lose marks on this one
Assuming technology permanently reduces total employment.
Why it happens: Automation replaces jobs visibly.
Consider the income and new industry effects too.
Written for this site.
Cyclical becomes structural: hysteresis
The line between cyclical and structural unemployment is not fixed. When a downturn lasts, people who lose their jobs for cyclical reasons stay unemployed long enough to lose skills, contacts and confidence. Employers then see them as risky hires, so they stay unemployed even after demand recovers. Economists call this hysteresis: past unemployment raising future unemployment. The recession of the early 1990s showed it. More than a third of the unemployed had been out of work for over a year by 1993, and unemployment did not return to its 1989 level until 2003. It is a strong argument for acting quickly in a downturn, as governments did with JobKeeper in 2020. It also explains why the Reserve Bank tried in 2023 and 2024 to lower inflation without giving up the employment gains of the recovery.