HSC Study

The OECD

Thirty-eight mostly advanced economies, no money to lend and no power to compel, and the one organisation in this dot point that changed how multinational firms are taxed.

35 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read The United Nations.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Formed in 1961, with 38 member economies, mostly advanced, committed to democracy and open markets. In 2023 the membership was 22 economies from the EU and 16 from outside it.
  • Its stated aims: sustainable growth and rising living standards in member economies, financial stability, and a contribution to world economic development.
  • Its instrument is research, comparison and peer review. It publishes a regular assessment of every member's economic performance and policy, including Australia's, and those assessments are argued over in national politics.
  • Its agenda is set by the problems of advanced economies: competition, education, employment, health, innovation, migration, regulation and tax. That is a limitation to name, not a criticism to dodge.
  • Its largest achievement is the global minimum corporate tax: 15 per cent on large multinational groups, agreed through its Inclusive Framework in 2021 and endorsed by the G20 at Rome that year.

The judgement the exam wants: the OECD shows that influence and enforcement are different things, and the minimum tax is the case study that proves both the power and its limits.

The role of the OECD

AnswersWhat is the role of the OECD?

  • Brings together mostly advanced market economies. Formed in 1961, the OECD has 38 member economies committed to democracy and open markets. Its objectives are sustainable growth and rising living standards in members, financial stability, and a contribution to world economic development and the expansion of world trade.
  • Researches and publishes comparable data. The OECD collects statistics on the same basis for every member and publishes the Economic Outlook twice a year, regular Economic Surveys of each member, including Australia, and PISA results comparing school students' performance. Comparable data lets governments see which policies work elsewhere.
  • Runs peer review. Each member's policies are examined by the secretariat and discussed by the other members. No penalty follows a poor review, but the published comparison creates domestic pressure to reform and lowers the risk of moving first. Policy converges without anyone being compelled.
  • Coordinates policy on issues facing advanced economies. Its agenda covers competition, education, employment, health, innovation, migration, regulation and tax. During the pandemic it acted as a forum for members to share research and coordinate responses.
  • Sets standards through agreement rather than enforcement. The OECD develops guidelines for multinational enterprises, an anti-bribery convention and model tax treaties that members adopt into national law. It is also where international tax cooperation is negotiated.
  • Led the reform of international corporate tax. Through its Inclusive Framework of more than 140 economies, the OECD brokered the 2021 agreement for a 15 per cent global minimum tax on large multinational groups, so profit shifted to tax havens can be taxed elsewhere. The G20 endorsed it in Rome in 2021 and more than 60 jurisdictions have legislated it, though a January 2026 side-by-side package exempts United States groups.
  • Measures and monitors foreign aid. The OECD's Development Assistance Committee defines what counts as official development assistance and reports each donor's aid, which is the basis of the 0.7 per cent of national income target and of the figures showing aid's record fall in 2025.
  • Shapes the policy debate. It supported fiscal and monetary stimulus in the 2008 to 2009 financial crisis and monetary tightening against inflation in 2023, and its inclusive growth work challenged the assumption that reducing inequality must cost growth.
  • Is limited by membership and power. Its focus is on advanced economy problems rather than those of developing economies, which have no vote, and it can only recommend: every decision is left to national governments.

Research, comparison and peer review

Every member submits to a regular survey of its economy, written by the secretariat, discussed by the other members and published. Nothing follows from a bad survey. No money is withheld, no rule is breached, no penalty applies.

It still changes policy, and the mechanism is worth stating precisely rather than waving at.

Chain of reasoning

How a published comparison moves a government

  1. The organisation publishes the same measure for every member on a consistent basis, so the numbers are actually comparable rather than merely adjacent.
  2. A government that ranks badly is asked about it domestically, by its own opposition and its own press, using a source it cannot dismiss as partisan.
  3. Defending the ranking requires either changing the policy or arguing that the measure is wrong, and the second is harder than it sounds when 37 other governments accept it.
  4. Meanwhile the comparison tells each government what the others are doing, which lowers the political cost of moving first on a reform others have already survived.
  5. Policy converges without anyone being compelled, which is the only kind of power the organisation has.

This is the same mechanism as the UN's 0.7 per cent aid target and the same mechanism behind a non-binding G20 communiqué. Recognising that the three organisations share one instrument is a genuinely high-value observation in an essay, because it lets you evaluate all of them against the same standard.

Common mistake

The OECD is unimportant because it has no money and cannot enforce anything.

Why it happens: The other four organisations in this dot point all have something concrete: rules, loans, or a treaty. The OECD's instrument is invisible by comparison.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: "The OECD has no real influence, because it cannot lend money, cannot make rules and cannot enforce anything."

What is wrong with this?

Select one answer

Hint 1Judge the body by what changed after it acted, not by the powers in its charter.

Hint 2One international agreement negotiated through it changed how large multinational groups are taxed.

Hint 3Its surveys are published and compared. Ask what a government does when it ranks badly on a measure it has accepted.

The global minimum tax: the case study to use

The problem. A multinational group can book its profit wherever it likes by charging its own subsidiaries for the use of brands, patents and internal loans. The profit lands in whichever jurisdiction taxes it least, while the production, the workers and the customers stay where they always were. No individual government can fix this, because any government that raises its rate alone simply loses the booked profit to the next jurisdiction. It is a coordination problem, and coordination problems are the only kind the OECD is built for.

The response. Negotiations through the Inclusive Framework, which now takes in more than 140 economies and so reaches well past the 38 members, produced a two-part agreement in 2021. The part worth knowing is Pillar Two: a minimum effective rate of 15 per cent on large multinational groups. If a group pays less than 15 per cent in one jurisdiction, another jurisdiction may collect the difference.

Why that design defeats the problem. The tax that a haven does not levy is collected somewhere else, so shifting the profit to the haven stops being worth the accounting. The incentive is removed rather than the behaviour being policed, which is the only approach available to a body that cannot police anything.

The OECD in numbersFigure
Member economies38
Economies in the Inclusive Framework on taxMore than 140
Agreed global minimum rate15 per cent on large multinational groups
Jurisdictions that have legislated itMore than 60
The concession made in January 2026A side-by-side package exempting United States groups

The limit, and the reason to use this example rather than a simpler one. An agreement negotiated at the OECD becomes real only when a national parliament legislates it, and one large economy declining to do so can force the rest to bend. In January 2026 a side-by-side package was released that exempts United States groups from the main charging rules, in exchange for keeping the framework intact everywhere else. Whether that is a sensible compromise or the hollowing out of the whole agreement is a live argument, and it is the kind of argument a Band 6 response is built from.

What lifts this to a Band 6

This is the single best example in the dot point for a question about whether international economic organisations are effective, because the evidence cuts both ways in one case study. More than 140 economies agreed and more than 60 legislated, which no other body in this topic achieved on a question of domestic tax. And then the largest economy secured an exemption, which is exactly what you would predict of an organisation with no enforcement. Use one example twice rather than two examples once.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Explain the problem the global minimum corporate tax was designed to solve, and evaluate how effectively it has been implemented. (4 marks)

Hint 1Start with why a single government acting alone cannot fix profit shifting.

Hint 2The design removes the incentive rather than policing the behaviour. Say how.

Hint 3Evaluate means using both the adoption figures and the January 2026 concession.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Writing that the OECD imposed a 15 per cent tax rate on multinational companies.

    Why it happens: The agreement is reported as though the organisation legislated it.

    The OECD hosted the negotiation. Each jurisdiction legislates for itself, which is why the number that have done so, and the one that secured an exemption, are the facts that decide the evaluation.

  • Confusing the minimum tax with a tariff, or assuming it applies only to the 38 OECD members.

    Why it happens: The OECD has 38 members, so its agreements look confined to them.

    The Inclusive Framework takes in more than 140 economies, well beyond the membership. That reach is the reason the agreement worked at all.

Written for this site.

Inclusive growth, and what the OECD changed its mind about

For most of the post-war period the standard position was a trade-off: policies that reduce inequality blunt the incentives that produce growth, so a society chooses how much of one to give up for the other.

The OECD has spent the last decade arguing the opposite in a specific case. Its inclusive growth work holds that beyond some point inequality reduces growth, through channels that can be named: households at the bottom under-invest in education and skills because they cannot borrow against future earnings, so human capital is lost from the economy; and demand is weaker where income sits with households that save most of it.

Whether or not you accept the argument, it is worth knowing as evidence for what this organisation does. It has no money and no power, so the only thing it can change is what governments believe is true, and this is the clearest instance of it trying.

Common mistake

The OECD sets economic policy for its members.

Why it happens: Its surveys read like instructions and its recommendations are often adopted.

What it did, crisis by crisis

A short timeline is worth carrying, because it lets you show the pattern instead of asserting it.

WhenWhat the OECD did
2008–09Supported monetary and fiscal stimulus by member governments to stop the financial crisis from destroying employment and living standards
2012Pressed crisis-affected euro area economies to repair public finances, strengthen banks and invest in skills
2020Provided a forum for members to share research and coordinate responses to the pandemic
2021Backed the recovery: vaccine production and distribution, income support for workers, and continued stimulus. Brokered the minimum tax agreement
2022Condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine
2023Committed to a country programme for Ukraine's recovery and reconstruction, and supported monetary tightening to bring inflation down

The pattern: in every case it was arguing, publishing and convening. The one line to draw from the table is that the organisation supported expansion in 2008 and contraction in 2023, which is what an institution built on analysis rather than ideology should look like.

The membership problem

Thirty-eight mostly advanced economies is both the source of the OECD's usefulness and its central limitation.

It is useful because comparison requires similarity. A survey that compares Australian and Norwegian labour market policy is informative in a way that comparing Australia with an economy at a fifth of the income per person is not, and peer review only functions between peers.

It is limiting because the questions that matter most to most of the world's population are not on the agenda. Competition policy, ageing populations, innovation and tax avoidance are advanced-economy problems. Sanitation, agricultural productivity and primary education are not on the list, and the economies facing them have no vote.

The Inclusive Framework is the partial answer, and it is why the tax work is the right example to use: by opening the negotiation to more than 140 economies, the OECD did the work outside its own membership. That is the model for how a rich-country club can act globally, and it is currently the only case of it succeeding at scale.

Where this fits in the topic

Set the five organisations against each other one last time. The WTO makes rules and has no money. The World Bank has money and makes no rules. The IMF has a little of each, and only in a crisis. The UN has the widest mandate and the least capacity to act on it. The OECD has neither money nor rules and changed how multinational profit is taxed.

If you can hold that comparison in one paragraph, you can answer any question on this dot point, including the ones that ask you to rank them.