HSC Study

Policy Responses: Full Employment

The policy toolkit for full employment (macroeconomic policy for cyclical unemployment; microeconomic, labour market, welfare, migration and participation policy for structural unemployment), how it has been used from the 1990s to JobKeeper and the post-2022 slowdown, the 2026 labour market, and how to evaluate its effectiveness against clear criteria.

35 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management

Assumes you have read Economic Objective: Full Employment and Policy Responses: Economic Growth and Quality of Life.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Match the policy to the cause. As your textbook explains, governments choose policies according to what they see as the main cause of unemployment:
    • macroeconomic policy reduces cyclical unemployment, because employment is a derived demand from output;
    • microeconomic and labour market policy reduce structural and frictional unemployment, lowering the NAIRU.
  • Record:
    • unemployment peaked at 10.7 per cent in 1992 and took most of a decade to fall;
    • it rose only to 5.9 per cent in the GFC;
    • JobKeeper limited the COVID-19 peak to 7.4 per cent (June 2020); Treasury estimated unemployment would otherwise have exceeded 12 per cent;
    • unemployment fell to 3.4 per cent in October 2022, the lowest in almost 50 years.
  • Since 2022: policy deliberately let unemployment rise to 4.6 per cent (August 2026) to reduce inflation. Participation stayed near a record 67.1 per cent, and underemployment is 6.2 per cent.
  • Assessment: highly effective against cyclical unemployment. Structural problems remain for the long-term unemployed, young people and disadvantaged groups.

The policy toolkit for full employment

AnswersWhich policies reduce unemployment, and which type of unemployment does each target?

PolicyType of unemployment targetedHow it worksRecent examples, 2024 to 2026
Fiscal policyCyclicalSpending and tax cuts raise AD; the multiplier raises output and employment. Wage subsidies keep workers attached to firmsJobKeeper (2020-21); infrastructure spending; permanent $20,000 instant asset write-off in the 2026-27 Budget
Monetary policyCyclicalLower rates raise consumption and investmentCuts to 3.60 per cent in 2025; rises to 4.35 per cent in 2026 traded some employment for lower inflation
Microeconomic reformStructural (long term)Higher productivity and competitiveness raise sustainable growth and job creationEconomic Reform Roundtable (August 2025); regulatory reform; merger control
Education and trainingStructuralNew skills match workers to available jobsFee-free TAFE, made permanent from 2027; Jobs and Skills Australia
Employment servicesFrictional, long-termBetter matching of jobseekers to vacanciesWorkforce Australia (2022); Points Based Activation System
Participation policyHidden unemploymentLower effective marginal tax rates; childcare and paid parental leave let parents workThree-day childcare guarantee from January 2026; paid parental leave of 26 weeks from July 2026
Migration policySkill shortagesSkilled migrants fill vacancies that would otherwise constrain outputSkills in Demand visa (December 2024); recognition of migrants' qualifications expanded in the 2026-27 Budget
Wage determinationStructural, classicalFlexible bargaining lets firms adjust hours and pay rather than cut jobsEnterprise bargaining; Secure Jobs, Better Pay reforms

Chain of reasoning

  1. Expansionary fiscal and monetary policy rises

    Rate cuts, tax cuts, spending
  2. Aggregate demand and output rises

    Multiplier effect
  3. Derived demand for labour rises

    Firms hire to produce more
  4. Cyclical unemployment falls

    But not below the NAIRU without raising inflation

What lifts this to a Band 6

Name the type of unemployment every time. "Fee-free TAFE reduces unemployment" earns little. "Fee-free TAFE reduces structural unemployment by training workers for occupations in shortage, such as aged care and construction, which lowers the NAIRU so that unemployment can stay low without accelerating inflation" earns the marks.

Policy responses from the 1990s to COVID-19

AnswersHow have governments used policy to reduce unemployment?

PeriodPolicy responseOutcome
1990sExpansionary macro policy after the 1990-91 recession. As your notes explain, unemployment fell only to 7.4 per cent by 1998, so the focus shifted to labour market reform: enterprise bargaining (Workplace Relations Act 1996), the Job Network, Work for the Dole and trainingLower NAIRU over time: unemployment reached about 4 per cent by 2008
GFC, 2008-09Rate cuts, cash payments and infrastructure spending. As your notes explain, labour market flexibility let firms cut hours rather than jobsUnemployment peaked at about 5.9 per cent, far below the rises in the US and Europe, but underemployment rose
Rebalancing, 2014 to 2019Cash rate cut to 0.75 per centUnemployment drifted down from about 6 to 5 per cent, but underemployment stayed near 8.5 per cent
COVID-19, 2020-21JobKeeper wage subsidy (about $89 billion, supporting about 3.5 million workers); doubled JobSeeker payments; JobMaker Hiring Credit; cash rate 0.10 per centPeak of 7.4 per cent in June 2020, then a rapid recovery

Chain of reasoning

  1. JobKeeper wage subsidy rises

    $1,500 a fortnight per employee
  2. Job losses falls

    Workers stayed attached to their employers
  3. Long-term unemployment and scarring falls

    Skills and job matches preserved
  4. Speed of recovery rises

    Unemployment 3.4 per cent by October 2022

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

How did JobKeeper help the labour market recover quickly after the COVID-19 lockdowns?

Select one answer

Hint 1Attachment.

Hint 2Scarring.

Hint 3Reopening.

The labour market since 2022

AnswersHow has policy affected the labour market since 2022?

The labour market (per cent)

MonthUnemploymentUnderemploymentParticipation
August 20195.38.566.0
June 20207.411.663.7
August 20223.56.066.5
August 20244.16.567.1
August 20264.66.267.1

Source: ABS, Labour Force, Australia, August 2026. The underutilisation rate was 10.8 per cent in August 2026.

A deliberate trade-off. With unemployment well below the NAIRU in 2022, wages and prices rose quickly. The Reserve Bank's narrow path aimed to reduce inflation while keeping as many employment gains as possible. Unemployment has risen by only about one percentage point, much less than in past periods of disinflation.

2026: slowing again. The 2026 rate rises and the oil shock slowed demand. In August 2026 employment rose by 39,500, but full-time jobs fell by 6,000 and unemployment rose to 4.6 per cent. The Reserve Bank noted the labour market had eased "a little more than expected", which is one reason it held rates in July and August.

Supply-side policy. The Working Future White Paper (2023) set the goal of sustained full employment, and policy since has aimed to lower structural unemployment and raise participation: fee-free TAFE, the Skills in Demand visa, the three-day childcare guarantee and longer paid parental leave.

Remaining gaps.

  • Long-term unemployment: about 21 per cent of the unemployed have been looking for a year or more.
  • Youth unemployment is more than double the overall rate.
  • Disadvantaged groups: First Nations people and people with disability have much lower participation and higher unemployment. The 2026-27 NDIS changes, which move about 160,000 people to other supports by 2030, will test whether mainstream services help them into work.
  • As your textbook notes, Australia spends less than half the OECD average on employment services.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Unemployment rose from 3.5 per cent in August 2022 to 4.6 per cent in August 2026, while participation stayed near 67 per cent. Explain the role of economic policy in these outcomes. (4 marks)

Hint 1NAIRU.

Hint 2Narrow path.

Hint 3Participation policies.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Calling the rise a policy failure.

    Why it happens: Unemployment rose.

    It was an intended trade-off.

Written for this site.

How effective have policy responses been?

AnswersHow successful has policy been in achieving full employment?

Your textbook points out that governments have set targets for growth and inflation, but not a numerical target for unemployment, which makes this objective harder to judge. Use the NAIRU, estimated at around 4.25 to 4.5 per cent, as the benchmark.

CriterionEvidence for full employment
ObjectiveUnemployment at the NAIRU, with low underemployment and high participation; the Working Future goal of sustained full employment
ImplementationJobKeeper was delivered within weeks in 2020; structural programs such as TAFE reform and employment services take years
OutcomesBelow 5 per cent since 2021; underemployment 6.2 per cent against 8.5 per cent before COVID; participation near record highs
Time lagsMacro policy works in 1 to 2 years; training and participation policies take several years
Other factorsClosed borders in 2020 to 2022 created labour shortages that lowered unemployment; strong population growth since 2023 added to labour supply
Side effectsUnemployment below the NAIRU in 2022 fed inflation; JobKeeper cost about $89 billion and some payments went to firms whose revenue recovered

Successes.

  • Unemployment has stayed below 5 per cent since 2021, the longest period of low unemployment since the early 1970s.
  • Australia avoided the large rises in unemployment seen in the G7 during the GFC.
  • JobKeeper prevented the long-term scarring seen after the 1990s recession.
  • Participation has risen, helped by childcare and parental leave policy.

Weaknesses.

  • Macroeconomic policy pushed unemployment below the NAIRU in 2022, contributing to high inflation.
  • Structural problems remain for the long-term unemployed, young people and disadvantaged groups.
  • Low unemployment has partly reflected weak productivity: jobs grew strongly, but output per worker did not.
  • Full-time jobs are now falling, and unemployment is drifting above the NAIRU.

Judgement. Policy has been highly effective at keeping unemployment low, especially through the COVID-19 response. The test now is whether the rise to 4.6 per cent stops close to the NAIRU, and whether microeconomic policy can lower the NAIRU so that low unemployment is consistent with low inflation.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 11 min

6 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of government policies in achieving full employment in Australia in recent years. (6 marks)

Hint 1COVID-19.

Hint 2Since 2022.

Hint 3Structural gaps.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Only using the headline unemployment rate.

    Why it happens: It is the main indicator.

    Use underemployment and participation too.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

Rising unemployment since 2022 shows that policy has failed to achieve full employment.

Why it happens: Unemployment has risen from 3.4 to 4.6 per cent.

The rise was a deliberate result of policy to reduce inflation, because unemployment was below the NAIRU. Unemployment of 4.6 per cent is still close to the Reserve Bank's estimates of full employment, and the rise has been small by historical standards.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'Unemployment rising from 3.4 to 4.6 per cent since 2022 proves policy has failed to achieve full employment.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1NAIRU.

Hint 2Inflation.

Hint 3Size of the rise.

Essay plan: policy responses to unemployment

AnswersHow do I evaluate policy responses to full employment in an extended response?

Essay planpriority 1 of 16 · 20 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of economic policies in achieving full employment in Australia.

Evaluate
Judge worth against criteria, weighing strengths against weaknesses, and conclude.
Thesis
Macroeconomic policy has been highly effective in limiting cyclical unemployment, most clearly through JobKeeper in 2020, while microeconomic and labour market policies have lowered the NAIRU over time. Policy has been less effective for structural and long-term unemployment, and since 2022 has deliberately traded some employment for lower inflation.
  1. Expansionary macroeconomic policy has been effective against cyclical unemployment in downturns.

    Lead with JobKeeper.

    Theory
    Employment is a derived demand; the multiplier; wage subsidies preserve job matches and prevent hysteresis.
    Diagram
    AD-AS diagram with AD shifting right, raising real output.
    Evidence
    Unemployment peaked at 5.9 per cent in the GFC and 7.4 per cent in June 2020 against a Treasury estimate of over 12 per cent without support; JobKeeper about \$89 billion; 3.4 per cent by October 2022.
    Against
    The stimulus was larger and lasted longer than needed, pushing unemployment below the NAIRU and adding to inflation.
  2. Since 2022, contractionary policy has deliberately raised unemployment towards the NAIRU.

    Show that this is a success judged against the NAIRU.

    Theory
    Short-run Phillips curve trade-off; the narrow path.
    Diagram
    Phillips curve with movement down and to the right.
    Evidence
    Cash rate 4.35 per cent in 2023 and again from May 2026; unemployment 4.6 per cent in August 2026, with full-time jobs down 6,000 in the month; participation 67.1 per cent.
    Against
    A small rise compared with past disinflations, suggesting the trade-off was well managed.
  3. Supply-side policies have lowered the NAIRU and raised participation, but slowly.

    Finish on the structural weakness to support the qualified judgement.

    Theory
    Structural and hidden unemployment; effective marginal tax rates; skills matching.
    Diagram
    LRAS shifting right.
    Evidence
    Underemployment fell from 8.5 to 6.2 per cent; fee-free TAFE; three-day childcare guarantee from January 2026; paid parental leave of 26 weeks; Skills in Demand visa.
    Against
    Long-term unemployment is about a fifth of the total, youth unemployment is double the average, and spending on employment services is below half the OECD average.

Judgement

Evaluate each policy against the type of unemployment it targets, using the NAIRU as the benchmark. Conclude that the objective is largely achieved in aggregate, but not for disadvantaged groups.

The full response also needs: The full employment objective and NAIRU lessons, the education, training and employment programs lesson, and the policy responses to price stability lesson for the trade-off.

Why JobKeeper was different

Most recessions cause lasting damage to the labour market. After the early 1990s recession, unemployment took almost a decade to fall below 7 per cent, because many workers who lost jobs became long-term unemployed, lost skills and confidence, and struggled to return. Economists call this hysteresis: a temporary rise in unemployment raises the NAIRU itself.

JobKeeper was designed to prevent hysteresis. By paying employers to keep workers on their books, it preserved the match between workers and firms, so that when restrictions eased, businesses could reopen without hiring and training new staff. Critics pointed to its cost and poor targeting, as some firms whose revenue recovered kept payments they did not need. But the speed of the labour market recovery, with unemployment falling to a 50-year low within two years, is strong evidence that the design worked.