HSC Study

Policy Responses: External Stability

Why external stability is now pursued through long-term settings rather than short-term policy, the toolkit (fiscal consolidation, superannuation, microeconomic reform, the floating dollar, and why monetary policy is no longer used), what happened to the current account and foreign liabilities from the surpluses of 2019-22 to the 2026 deficit, and how to evaluate policy against clear criteria.

35 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management

Assumes you have read Economic Objective: External Stability and Policy Responses: Price Stability.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • A long-term objective. As your textbook explains, external stability is no longer a short-term target of macroeconomic policy. Policymakers accept the consenting adults view: a deficit driven by private saving and investment decisions does not need a policy response. External stability is pursued through long-term settings that keep international investors confident.
  • The toolkit:
    • monetary policy is not used for the current account any more: its effect is temporary, it slows the whole economy, and higher rates can attract capital inflows that raise income payments abroad;
    • fiscal consolidation raises national saving;
    • compulsory superannuation (12 per cent of wages from July 2025) raises saving and builds foreign assets;
    • microeconomic reform raises international competitiveness;
    • the floating dollar absorbs external shocks.
  • Record: the CAD averaged about 4 per cent of GDP from 1980 to 2010 and 2.3 per cent in the 2010s; surpluses from 2019-20 to 2021-22, mainly from record commodity prices; back to a deficit of 3.2 per cent of GDP in 2025-26.
  • Net foreign liabilities fell from about 55 per cent of GDP in 2019 to 22 per cent in 2026, a record low, mainly because superannuation funds invested abroad.
  • Assessment: external stability has improved, but mostly from the terms of trade and superannuation, not short-term policy.

The policy toolkit for external stability

AnswersHow do different policies influence the current account and foreign liabilities?

PolicyTime frameHow it affects external stabilityRecent settings, 2024 to 2026
Monetary policyShort term, no longer used for this goalHigher rates once restrained import demand, as in 2004 to 2008. Now seen as ineffective: the effect is temporary, it slows the whole economy, and higher rates attract capital inflows, raising future net primary income paymentsRates set for inflation only; the 2026 rises were not aimed at the external accounts
Fiscal policyMedium termFiscal consolidation raises national saving, reducing the call on foreign borrowing and future income payments abroadSurpluses in 2022-23 and 2023-24; deficits since, about 1 per cent of GDP in 2026-27; gross debt 34 per cent of GDP
SuperannuationLong termCompulsory saving raises national saving; funds invest overseas, building foreign assets that earn incomeGuarantee rose to 12 per cent in July 2025
Microeconomic reformLong termHigher productivity, better infrastructure and fewer skills shortages improve competitiveness, supporting exportsProductivity agenda; Critical Minerals Strategic Reserve
Floating exchange rateContinuousDepreciation in a downturn makes exports cheaper and imports dearer, cushioning the economyFell to about US 60 cents in April 2025, then rose to about US 71 cents by September 2026
Credible policy frameworkContinuousInflation targeting, fiscal discipline and financial regulation sustain investor confidence and the AAA ratingAAA credit rating kept

Why policy has a limited role. The current account is driven heavily by the terms of trade and by private saving and investment. Most foreign debt is owed by banks and firms, not the government, and much of it is in Australian dollars or hedged. Your textbook adds one caution: in the GFC the government guaranteed banks' borrowing, showing that in a crisis, private foreign debt can become the government's problem.

What lifts this to a Band 6

Use the saving-investment identity. The current account balance equals national saving minus investment, so any policy that raises national saving (fiscal consolidation, superannuation) or raises export competitiveness improves it. A strong answer then adds that a CAD funding productive investment is not a problem in itself, which is the consenting adults view.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

How does fiscal consolidation help achieve external stability in the medium term?

Select one answer

Hint 1Saving.

Hint 2Public borrowing.

Hint 3Income payments.

The external accounts since 2019

AnswersHow has Australia's external position changed, and what role has policy played?

Australia's external accounts (per cent of GDP)

YearCurrent accountNet foreign liabilitiesTerms of trade (index)
2008−6.755.4n/a
2019−1.355.085.9
20212.244.995.2
20230.032.6106.7
2026−3.222.195.4

Source: ABS, Balance of Payments and International Investment Position, June quarter 2026. Financial years; liabilities at 30 June; terms of trade 2023-24 = 100. Net foreign liabilities were $638.9 billion at 30 June 2026.

Surpluses, 2019-20 to 2021-22. As your notes explain, these reflected strong commodity export prices, lower imports and travel during COVID-19, low global interest rates that reduced income payments, and the surge in energy prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. These were largely cyclical, not the result of policy.

Back to deficit. As the terms of trade fell from their 2022 peak and import demand stayed strong, the balance moved to a deficit of 3.2 per cent of GDP in 2025-26. The deficit widened again to $27.2 billion in the June quarter 2026. Budget deficits since 2024-25 have lowered public saving.

Falling net liabilities. Net foreign liabilities have fallen to their lowest level since the series began. Superannuation funds have invested heavily in overseas shares, so Australia is now a large net owner of foreign equity, while net foreign debt remains about half of GDP.

The floating dollar. As your notes explain, Australia's net foreign currency asset position means a depreciation actually reduces its net liabilities in Australian dollar terms, so the April 2025 fall to about US 60 cents amid US tariff announcements did not raise external risk.

Chain of reasoning

  1. Compulsory superannuation rises

    12 per cent of wages from July 2025
  2. National saving rises

    Less reliance on foreign borrowing
  3. Foreign equity assets rises

    Funds invest overseas
  4. Net foreign liabilities falls

    22 per cent of GDP, a record low

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Net foreign liabilities fell from 55.0 per cent of GDP in 2019 to 22.1 per cent in 2026, while the current account moved from surplus to a deficit of 3.2 per cent of GDP in 2025-26. Explain these trends. (4 marks)

Hint 1Superannuation.

Hint 2Terms of trade.

Hint 3Imports.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating the current account and liabilities as moving together.

    Why it happens: Both are external measures.

    Stock and flow can diverge.

Written for this site.

How effective have policy responses been?

AnswersHow successful has policy been in achieving external stability?

CriterionEvidence for external stability
ObjectiveNo numerical target; a sustainable CAD (below about 3 per cent of GDP in the long run), manageable foreign liabilities and investor confidence
ImplementationSuperannuation has been implemented steadily since 1992; fiscal consolidation was interrupted by COVID-19 and has not been restored
OutcomesNet foreign liabilities at a record low; the debt servicing ratio has fallen; the CAD back above 3 per cent of GDP
Time lagsSuperannuation and competitiveness take decades; fiscal settings take years
Other factorsCommodity prices, China's growth, global interest rates and the 2026 oil shock explain most short-run movements
Side effectsUsing high interest rates for the current account in the late 1980s contributed to the 1990-91 recession, which is why the approach was dropped

Successes.

  • Net foreign liabilities have more than halved since 2019, and servicing costs have fallen to about 10 per cent of export earnings.
  • Superannuation has built a large stock of foreign assets, reducing vulnerability.
  • The floating dollar has absorbed shocks in the GFC, COVID-19, the 2025 tariff announcements and the 2026 oil shock.
  • Australia has kept its AAA credit rating, a sign of international confidence.

Weaknesses.

  • The improvement owed more to the terms of trade and superannuation than to active policy.
  • The CAD has widened again, and net foreign debt of about half of GDP remains high.
  • Budget deficits projected for the rest of the decade will lower national saving.
  • As your notes explain, Australia remains vulnerable to external shocks because of its reliance on commodity exports and on China.

Judgement. Australia's external position is stronger than at any time in decades, and external stability no longer constrains domestic policy. But this owes much to favourable cyclical factors and to superannuation, a long-term structural change, and the return to deficit shows that the gains depend on commodity prices that policy does not control.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 11 min

6 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of government policy in achieving external stability in Australia. (6 marks)

Hint 1Cyclical versus policy.

Hint 2Superannuation.

Hint 3Vulnerabilities.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Crediting policy for the surpluses.

    Why it happens: The surpluses coincided with policy.

    Commodity prices were the main cause.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

The current account surpluses from 2019-20 to 2021-22 show that government policy fixed Australia's external imbalance.

Why it happens: The current account moved into surplus.

The surpluses came mainly from cyclical factors: record commodity prices, lower imports and travel in COVID-19, and low global interest rates. As those factors reversed, the current account returned to deficit. Policy's contribution came mainly through long-term saving, especially superannuation.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'The current account surpluses from 2019-20 to 2021-22 prove government policy fixed Australia's external imbalance.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1Commodity prices.

Hint 2COVID-19.

Hint 3Return to deficit.

Essay plan: the role of policy in external stability

AnswersHow do I analyse the role of policy in external stability in an extended response?

Essay planpriority 15 of 16 · 20 marks

Analyse the role of government policies in addressing external stability in Australia.

Analyse
Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
Thesis
Government policy now plays a limited, long-term role in external stability. Fiscal consolidation and compulsory superannuation have raised national saving and built foreign assets, and a floating dollar and credible policy framework sustain confidence, but short-term movements in the current account are driven by the terms of trade and private decisions rather than policy.
  1. Monetary policy is no longer used to target the current account.

    Start by explaining the shift to long-term settings.

    Theory
    Rate rises reduce imports only temporarily, slow the whole economy, and attract capital inflows that raise net primary income payments.
    Diagram
    None needed.
    Evidence
    High rates in the late 1980s contributed to the 1990-91 recession; since 1993 the cash rate is set for inflation, as with the rises to 4.35 per cent in 2023 and 2026.
    Against
    Higher rates can still appreciate the dollar, which affects net exports, so monetary policy has side effects on the external accounts.
  2. Superannuation and fiscal policy raise national saving.

    This is the strongest policy contribution.

    Theory
    CAB = S minus I; fiscal consolidation reduces public borrowing; super builds foreign equity assets.
    Diagram
    None needed.
    Evidence
    Guarantee 12 per cent from July 2025; net foreign liabilities fell from 55 per cent of GDP (2019) to 22 per cent (2026); surpluses in 2022-23 and 2023-24.
    Against
    Deficits of about 1 per cent of GDP to the end of the decade lower public saving.
  3. The floating dollar and microeconomic reform manage vulnerability rather than remove it.

    Conclude that cyclical factors dominate.

    Theory
    Exchange rate as shock absorber; valuation effects; competitiveness shifts net exports.
    Diagram
    Demand and supply for AUD with a fall in demand.
    Evidence
    Dollar about US 60 cents in April 2025, about US 71 cents by September 2026; net foreign currency asset position; AAA rating.
    Against
    Commodity dependence and exposure to China remain; the CAD widened to \$27.2 billion in the June quarter 2026.

Judgement

Analyse means show how each policy works and how much it has contributed. Weigh policy against cyclical factors and conclude that long-term settings, especially superannuation, have been the main policy contribution.

The full response also needs: The external stability objective lesson, the structure of the balance of payments and trends in the balance of payments lessons, and the policy responses to price stability lesson for why monetary policy is set for inflation.

Does the current account deficit still matter?

In 1986 the Treasurer warned that Australia risked becoming a "banana republic" because of its large deficit and foreign debt. Policy in the late 1980s used high interest rates and budget surpluses to try to reduce the deficit, contributing to the 1990-91 recession. Since then, the view has changed. A deficit is the counterpart of a capital inflow, which funds investment that raises future output. If that investment is productive and made by private firms that bear the risk, the deficit need not be a problem.

The risk has not disappeared: Australian banks still rely on foreign funding, and a sudden loss of confidence could raise their borrowing costs, as in 2008, when the government had to guarantee their borrowing. But the combination of a floating dollar, foreign debt mostly hedged or in Australian dollars, and large superannuation assets abroad means Australia's external position is now one of its strengths.