HSC Study

International Environmental Agreements

Why global environmental problems need international cooperation, the free-rider problem and the tragedy of the commons, the Montreal Protocol, Kyoto Protocol and Paris Agreement, recent developments from the US withdrawal to COP31 and the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, the High Seas Treaty, and how international agreements shape Australian policy.

30 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management

Assumes you have read Environmental Targets.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Problems such as climate change, ozone depletion and overfishing are global: no single country can solve them, and each country bears only a small part of the cost of its own pollution.
  • As your notes explain, agreements address two problems:
    • reluctance to act alone, because a country that cuts emissions bears the cost while others share the benefit (the free-rider problem);
    • the tragedy of the commons, the overuse of shared resources with no single owner, such as the atmosphere and the high seas.
  • Key agreements:
    • Montreal Protocol (1987): phased out ozone-depleting substances; about 99 per cent eliminated, the most successful agreement;
    • Kyoto Protocol (1997): binding targets for developed countries only;
    • Paris Agreement (2015): nearly all countries, with nationally determined contributions (NDCs), but no enforcement;
    • High Seas Treaty: in force from January 2026, protecting ocean biodiversity beyond national borders.
  • Recent developments: the US withdrawal from Paris took effect in January 2026; COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, in November 2026 has Australia as President of Negotiations; the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism charges importers from 2026.
  • Limitation: most agreements are non-binding or hard to enforce, but they shape domestic targets through political and trade pressure.

Why international cooperation is needed

AnswersWhy do global environmental problems need international agreements?

Tragedy of the commons

The overuse of a shared resource that no one owns, such as the atmosphere, the oceans or migratory fish stocks, because each user gains the full benefit of using it but bears only a small share of the cost of its depletion.

Free-rider problem

The incentive for a country to benefit from other countries' emissions cuts without making costly cuts itself, because the benefits of a stable climate cannot be limited to those who pay for it.

As your notes explain, individual nations are reluctant to impose strict environmental policies on their own economy if other nations will not do the same. A country that acts alone:

  • raises costs for its own firms and households;
  • risks carbon leakage, where emissions-intensive production moves to countries with weaker policies, costing jobs with no fall in global emissions;
  • gains only a small share of the global benefit.

International agreements coordinate action so that each country's effort is matched by others. As your notes explain, most agreements are non-binding with limited enforcement, but political pressure and, increasingly, trade measures can strongly influence domestic policy.

Chain of reasoning

  1. Global emissions rises

    Each country bears little of the cost of its own pollution
  2. Incentive to free ride rises

    Others' cuts benefit everyone
  3. Coordinated commitments rises

    International agreement matches each country's effort
  4. Global emissions falls

    If commitments are kept

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Why are international agreements needed to address climate change?

Select one answer

Hint 1Who bears the cost?

Hint 2Who gets the benefit?

Hint 3Free riding.

Major environmental agreements

AnswersHow successful have the major international environmental agreements been?

AgreementWhat it doesAssessment
Montreal Protocol (1987)Binding phase-out of CFCs and other ozone-depleting substancesThe most successful agreement: about 99 per cent of ozone-depleting substances eliminated, and the ozone layer is recovering. Success came from a small number of producers and available substitutes
UN Fish Stocks Agreement (1995)Conservation of migratory and high seas fish stocksAddresses a classic tragedy of the commons
Kyoto Protocol (1997)Binding targets for developed countries: about 5 per cent below 1990 levels by 2008-12Limited. Australia was allowed an 8 per cent increase. Developing countries had no targets, the US never ratified it, and Canada withdrew in 2012. As your notes explain, most of the fall came from the collapse of Eastern European industry after 1991
Paris Agreement (2015)Limit warming to well below 2°C, aiming for 1.5°C. Every country sets its own NDC, updated every five yearsNear-universal coverage, including China, India and developing countries, with strong transparency rules. But NDCs are voluntary and not enforceable
High Seas Treaty (in force January 2026)Legally binding protection of biodiversity in the oceans beyond national borders, which cover most of the world's oceansNew; its effect depends on marine protected areas being created and enforced

Strengths and weaknesses of Paris. As your notes explain, its main strength is that it bridged the gap between high-income countries, with high emissions per person, and developing countries, whose emissions are rising as they grow. Its main weakness is that countries set their own targets with no penalty for missing them. Current NDCs and policies put the world on track for warming well above 2°C, and each five-year round is meant to ratchet up ambition. Australia's 2030 NDC is 43 per cent, and its 2035 NDC of 62 to 70 per cent was submitted in September 2025.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Compare the effectiveness of the Montreal Protocol and the Paris Agreement in addressing global environmental problems. (5 marks)

Hint 1Outcome of each.

Hint 2Why Montreal worked.

Hint 3Paris strengths and weaknesses.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing without comparing.

    Why it happens: Both agreements are listed.

    Explain why the outcomes differ.

Written for this site.

Recent developments and Australia

AnswersHow do recent international developments affect Australia's environmental policy?

The US withdrawal. The United States announced its second withdrawal from the Paris Agreement in January 2025, taking effect in January 2026. As your notes explain, withdrawals weaken the agreement by making other countries doubt that competitors will face the same costs, increasing the incentive to free ride.

COP31. Australia bid to host the 2026 UN climate conference. Under a compromise, COP31 is being held in Antalya, Türkiye, in November 2026, with Australia as President of Negotiations and a pre-COP meeting in the Pacific. This raises international scrutiny of Australia's own targets and its continued approval of fossil fuel projects.

Trade pressure: the EU CBAM. The EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism charges importers of goods such as steel, aluminium, cement, fertiliser and hydrogen for their embodied emissions, with financial obligations from 1 January 2026. It is designed to stop carbon leakage from the EU's own emissions trading scheme. For Australia, it means exporters with high emissions intensity face a cost in the EU market, strengthening the incentive to decarbonise regardless of domestic policy. Other economies, including the UK, plan similar measures from 2027.

Influence on Australian policy. International agreements have shaped Australia's policies directly:

  • Australia's 43 per cent and 62 to 70 per cent targets are its Paris NDCs;
  • the phase-out of CFCs was implemented under the Montreal Protocol;
  • the 30 per cent protected areas target follows the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (2022);
  • trading partners' commitments to net zero, especially Japan, Korea and China, affect demand for Australian coal and gas and create opportunities in green metals and critical minerals.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Explain how international agreements and developments influence Australia's environmental policy. (4 marks)

Hint 1NDC.

Hint 2CBAM.

Hint 3COP31.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing agreements without the effect on policy.

    Why it happens: Agreements are the topic.

    Show how each changes Australian policy.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

International agreements are ineffective because they cannot be enforced.

Why it happens: Most climate agreements have no penalties.

Enforcement is weak, but agreements still work through transparency, political pressure and trade measures such as the CBAM. The Montreal Protocol shows that agreements can be highly effective when the costs of acting are low and substitutes exist. Paris has shaped targets in nearly every country, including Australia's.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'International environmental agreements have no effect because they cannot be enforced.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1Montreal.

Hint 2Transparency.

Hint 3Trade.

Why Montreal worked and Kyoto did not

The contrast between the Montreal and Kyoto protocols shows what makes international cooperation succeed. Ozone-depleting substances were produced by a handful of chemical firms, substitutes were available at modest cost, and the protocol included trade restrictions on non-members, removing the free-rider incentive. Climate change is harder: emissions come from every sector of every economy, cutting them was, until recently, costly, and the countries whose emissions were growing fastest were excluded from Kyoto's targets.

Two changes have improved the prospects for climate cooperation. The falling cost of solar, wind and batteries means that cutting emissions is increasingly cheap, and in some cases profitable, reducing the cost of acting. And border carbon adjustments such as the CBAM mimic Montreal's trade restrictions, changing the incentives of exporting countries like Australia even without a binding global agreement.