HSC Study

Globalisation and Environmental Sustainability

The second of the three components the syllabus lists under the effects of globalisation: why growth damages the environment, why the damage crosses borders when production does, and why the agreements written to stop it are so hard to enforce.

80 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read The Effects of Globalisation.

The full teaching. Start here.

Ecologically sustainable development

Development that meets the needs of the present without reducing the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. It is the standard definition and it contains the whole problem: the cost of today's output falls on people who are not in the market that produced it.

Negative externality

A cost of production or consumption borne by a third party rather than by the buyer or seller. Pollution is the standard case, and because the cost is not in the price, the market produces more of the polluting good than is socially optimal. This is market failure, and it is the economic reason the environment needs policy rather than patience.

Common access resource

A resource nobody owns and nobody can be excluded from using, such as the atmosphere, the high seas and fish stocks. Each user gains the whole benefit of using more and bears a small share of the cost of depletion, so the resource is overused. This is the tragedy of the commons, and the climate is the largest example there is.

Carbon leakage

The movement of emissions intensive production from an economy with a carbon price or tight regulation to one without, so that the first economy's reported emissions fall while world emissions do not.

The five things worth carrying out of this lesson:

  • The damage is a market failure, not an accident. Environmental costs sit outside the price, and the atmosphere is a common access resource with no owner, so markets alone overuse it. Naming both failures is worth more than a list of harms.
  • Growth changes the damage twice. The scale of output raises it, and rising income eventually buys cleaner technology and stricter regulation that lower it. That is the inverted U, and it holds for local pollutants far better than for carbon dioxide.
  • Globalisation moves the damage as well as the production. More than half of the United Kingdom's carbon footprint in 2021 was emitted outside it. Reported emissions and the emissions an economy is responsible for are different numbers.
  • The transition is an investment problem for developing economies. They cause the smallest share of emissions, face the largest damage and carry debt that limits what they can spend, which is why climate finance is the centre of every negotiation.
  • Agreements are voluntary and self reported. From Kyoto through Paris to Baku and Belem, the trend is towards wider participation and weaker obligation. Judge them on participation, transparency and finance, not on enforcement, because there is none.

Why growth damages the environment, in economic terms

A response that begins with a list of environmental harms has already lost the marks. The examinable material is why an economic system produces those harms while behaving exactly as it is supposed to.

Chain of reasoning

From a private decision to a global cost

  1. A firm chooses the cheapest way to produce, and its costs include wages, capital and inputs.

  2. The emissions, the river it discharges into and the forest it clears are costs to other people, so they are not in its costs and not in its price.

  3. Because the price is below the true social cost, buyers buy more of the good than they would if the cost were included. The market allocates too many resources to it.

  4. The resource being used, the atmosphere or the ocean or the fish stock, has no owner able to charge for it or exclude anyone, so no private party has an incentive to protect it.

  5. Every user is individually better off using more, and collectively worse off as the resource degrades. The outcome is overuse, and it is a stable outcome, which is why it does not correct itself.

Two features of the climate case make it the hardest version of this problem. The damage is global, so an economy that cuts its emissions bears the whole cost and receives a small fraction of the benefit. And the damage is delayed, so the people who bear it are not the people who decide. Both are reasons an agreement is needed and reasons an agreement is hard to reach.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Writing "globalisation causes pollution" as the argument. Production causes pollution, and globalisation changes where it happens, how much of it is priced and who can be held to account for it. A response that can separate those three earns the analysis marks; one that treats globalisation as a synonym for pollution does not.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In economic terms, why does an unregulated market overuse the atmosphere?

Select one answer

Hint 1There are two separate failures here, and the answer needs both.

Hint 2Who pays for the damage, and who owns the resource?

Hint 3Ask what an individual user gains from using one more unit, and what they bear.

What continuing development does to the damage

The economic issue asks about continuing development, so the question is what happens to environmental damage as income rises. The pattern found in the data is an inverted U.

What economic development does to the environmentAt an income of US$22,000 a head the model reports 71 on the damage index while consumption causes 84.16% of the damage happens abroadTurning point010203040506070020406080100Income per person (US$000)Environmental damage per person (index)
  • Damage caused by what the economy consumes
  • Damage caused inside the economy, which is what it reports
The inverted U is the environmental Kuznets curve: damage rises while an economy industrialises and falls once it is rich enough to demand and afford clean air and water. It is a real pattern for local pollutants, and it is weakest for exactly the pollutant that matters most, because carbon dioxide emissions per person have not fallen that way in most economies. Part of the fall on the reported measure is also production moving somewhere else, which is the upper curve.
22 US$000
40 %
35 %
At this income
The economy reports 71 on the index and causes 84, a difference of 13 caused abroad on its behalf
Why the curve turns down
Three things happen as income rises. Output shifts from heavy industry towards services, which cause less damage for each dollar earned. Cleaner technology becomes affordable, and richer populations demand clean air and water and vote for the regulation that delivers it. The turning point moves left as environmental policy strengthens, which is the whole argument for not waiting for income to solve the problem.
Why the fall is smaller than it looks
Some of the fall on the reported measure is heavy production moving to economies with lower costs and lighter regulation. The damage is still caused, and the goods still arrive, so the consumption measure falls by much less. On the territorial measure United Kingdom emissions fell about 53 per cent between 1990 and 2021, and on the consumption measure about 24 per cent.
Where the pattern fails
The inverted U is well supported for local pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and particulates, where the damage is suffered by the people who cause it. It is weak for carbon dioxide, because the damage falls on everyone and mostly on people who did not cause it, so no domestic constituency forces the turning point. That asymmetry is why climate change needs an international agreement and clean rivers do not.
Decoupling
Relative decoupling means damage grows more slowly than output. Absolute decoupling means output grows while damage falls. Several advanced economies have achieved absolute decoupling of territorial emissions from output, and far fewer have achieved it on a consumption basis. The distinction is worth a mark on its own.
Read it as
A model of a relationship, not a measurement of any economy. The index has no units. The shapes, the turning point and the gap between the two measures are the examinable content.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Move the income slider from left to right. Damage rises while an economy industrialises, peaks, and falls as the economy becomes richer. Three mechanisms drive the fall: output shifts from heavy industry towards services, cleaner technology becomes affordable, and a richer population demands clean air and water and votes for the regulation that delivers it. Strengthening environmental policy moves the turning point to the left, which is the whole argument against waiting for income to fix the problem.

Two qualifications decide how much of this is real, and both are examinable.

The first is the pollutant. The relationship is well supported for local pollutants such as particulates and sulphur dioxide, where the people who cause the damage breathe it. It is weak for carbon dioxide, because that damage is spread across everyone and concentrated in the future, so no domestic constituency forces the turn.

The second is where the production went. Move the offshoring slider and watch the reported curve fall while the consumption curve barely moves. That gap is the next section.

What lifts this to a Band 6

Distinguish relative from absolute decoupling. Relative decoupling means damage grows more slowly than output, which most economies have achieved. Absolute decoupling means output grows while damage falls, which far fewer have achieved, and fewer still once imports are counted. Using the terms correctly signals that you know the difference between a slower increase and a decrease.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A response argues that because environmental damage falls once economies become rich, developing economies should grow first and clean up later. What is the strongest objection?

Select one answer

Hint 1Which pollutants does the pattern fit, and why those ones?

Hint 2Who suffers the damage from carbon dioxide, and when?

Hint 3There is an arithmetic constraint on how much more can be emitted at all.

Globalisation moves the damage as well as the production

The link between this dot point and the rest of Topic 1 is the relocation of production. The same mechanism that moved manufacturing into low cost economies moved the emissions from that manufacturing with it.

Where an advanced economy’s emissions are producedCounting 100 per cent of imported emissions gives 705 million tonnes, against a 1990 footprint of 922 million tonnes.Whole footprint1990: 9222021 as counted: 70502004006008001000Greenhouse gases (Mt CO2e)
  • Footprint in 1990
  • Emitted inside the economy in 2021
  • Emitted abroad to make its imports
An economy reports the emissions released inside its borders. More than half of what this economy consumed was produced somewhere else, so the two measures give different answers about how much progress has been made. Both are published, neither is wrong, and a response that quotes one without naming it has not answered the question.
The numbers behind this graph
MeasureMillion tonnes CO2e
Footprint 1990922
Emitted inside the economy 2021324
Emitted abroad for its imports 2021381
Whole footprint 2021705
100 %
On these settings
705 million tonnes, which is 24 per cent below the 1990 footprint of 922 million tonnes
The two published measures
Counting nothing that happens abroad gives 324 million tonnes, which is the territorial measure an economy reports under the climate agreements. Counting all of it gives 705 million tonnes, the consumption measure. 54 per cent of this economy's footprint was emitted outside it.
Why the gap grew
Globalisation moved emissions intensive production to economies with lower costs, and often with cheaper coal fired electricity and lighter regulation. The imports come back, so consumption is unchanged and the emissions appear on someone else’s account. This is carbon leakage, and it is the reason a fall in reported emissions is not by itself evidence of a fall in damage.
What the policy response is
A carbon border adjustment charges imports for the emissions released making them, so that a domestic carbon price cannot be avoided by producing elsewhere. The European Union scheme is the first at scale. Developing economies argue that it shifts the cost of the transition onto their exporters, which is the trade and climate dispute in one sentence.
Read it as
Real data for one economy, chosen because it publishes both measures. The pattern, not the country, is the point: every advanced economy that has cut reported emissions has also moved production abroad, and the split differs.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

An economy reports the emissions released inside its borders, because that is what the climate agreements count and what a government can regulate. The consumption measure counts the emissions released anywhere in the world to meet its demand. In 2021, 381 of the 705 million tonnes in the United Kingdom's footprint were released abroad to make things it imported.

The two measures also tell different stories over time. On the territorial measure, emissions fell about 53 per cent between 1990 and 2021; on the consumption measure, about 24 per cent. The improvement is real either way, and roughly half of the reported version of it is production moving somewhere else.

What it is calledWhat it countsWhat it is used for
Territorial or production basedEmissions released inside the bordersReporting under the climate agreements, and the basis of national targets
Consumption based, or the carbon footprintEmissions released anywhere to meet domestic demandMeasuring responsibility, and identifying carbon leakage

Two consequences follow, and both are current policy.

The first is the race to the bottom argument: firms relocate to economies with lighter environmental regulation, and governments competing for that investment have an incentive not to tighten it. The evidence that this drives location decisions on a large scale is contested, because energy, wages and market access matter more, but the incentive is real and it is strongest in the most emissions intensive industries.

The second is the carbon border adjustment, which charges imports for the emissions released in making them so that a domestic carbon price cannot be escaped by producing elsewhere. The European Union scheme is the first at scale. Developing economies object that it shifts the cost of the transition onto their exporters and functions as protection with an environmental justification, which is the trade and climate dispute in one sentence.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Quoting an advanced economy's falling emissions as proof that growth and sustainability are compatible, without saying which measure it is. On the territorial measure, the claim is supported. On the consumption measure, it is much weaker. Name the measure and the same evidence becomes an argument rather than an assertion.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain carbon leakage and its consequences for measuring an economy's environmental progress.

Hint 1Start with why production moves.

Hint 2Two different emissions measures exist. Name both.

Hint 3What policy has been introduced in response?

Who causes it, who suffers it, who can afford to fix it

The reason this dot point sits inside a development topic rather than an environment one is that the three questions have three different answers.

Africa holds about 17 per cent of the world's population and causes about 4 per cent of emissions, and most of the economies at the top of every climate vulnerability ranking are in it. Damage concentrates where agriculture is a large share of output, where the climate is already hot, and where there is no money for sea walls, irrigation or insurance. Rich economies caused most of the accumulated stock of emissions and are best placed to adapt.

Debt makes the gap self reinforcing. An economy servicing a large external debt has less revenue for schooling and infrastructure to begin with, and borrowing for a transition it did not cause adds to the burden. This is why climate finance, and increasingly its form, is the centre of every negotiation.

What was promised for the transition, and what arrivesWith 100 per cent of the 2035 goal delivered and 65 per cent of it lent, US$105 billion a year arrives as grants and US$195 billion adds to debt.The 2035 goal: US$300bn2020 goalDelivered: US$300bnAll sources0200400600800100012001400Finance for developing economies (US$bn a year)
  • Goal set in 2009 for 2020
  • Delivered as grants
  • Delivered as loans, which add to debt
  • Wider mobilisation goal for 2035
Developing economies cause the smallest share of emissions, are hit hardest by the consequences and can least afford the investment the transition requires. These are the sums promised to close that gap. They are goals rather than deliveries, and the first of them was met two years late and largely in loans.
The numbers behind this graph
GoalUS$ billion a year
Set in 2009, for 2020100
Agreed 2024, for 2035300
Wider mobilisation, for 20351300
100 %
65 %
On these settings
US$300 billion a year arrives, of which US$105 billion is grants and US$195 billion is lent and has to be repaid with interest
Why the form matters as much as the amount
Finance delivered as loans raises the debt a developing economy is already servicing, and debt servicing competes directly with the schooling, health and infrastructure spending that development requires. A large headline number made mostly of loans can leave an economy with more climate projects and less capacity to run them.
What the goals are
The 2009 goal was US$100 billion a year by 2020, reported as met in 2022. The goal agreed at Baku in 2024 is US$300 billion a year by 2035 from developed economies, inside a wider call to mobilise US$1.3 trillion a year from public, private and alternative sources. Belem in 2025 added a call to triple adaptation finance.
Why developing economies press the point
Africa holds about 17 per cent of the world population and causes about 4 per cent of emissions, and most of the economies at the top of every vulnerability ranking are there. The damage falls where the emissions were not caused, which is why the transfer is argued for as compensation rather than aid.
The enforcement problem
No climate goal carries a penalty for missing it. Agreements set targets that each country writes for itself and reports on itself, and the sanction is embarrassment. That is why the examinable judgement on international environmental agreements is about participation and transparency rather than about compliance.
Read it as
The bars are the goals as agreed, which is data. How much is delivered and in what form is the slider, which is not a forecast. Say which is which when you quote it.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Move the loan slider. The same headline figure delivers very different outcomes depending on how much of it has to be repaid with interest, which is the developing economy argument in one movement: a promise met with loans can leave an economy with more projects and less capacity to run them.

What lifts this to a Band 6

Quote climate finance figures as goals, not as deliveries. The 2009 goal of US$100 billion a year by 2020 was reported as met in 2022. The 2024 goal is US$300 billion a year by 2035 inside a wider call to mobilise US$1.3 trillion. Writing "developed economies have provided" when the source says "agreed to mobilise" is the single most common factual error on this dot point.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

World fossil fuel emissions were about 38.1 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide in 2025, and total emissions including land use change were about 42.2 billion tonnes. The remaining cumulative budget consistent with limiting warming to 1.5 degrees is about 170 billion tonnes. At the 2025 total rate, how many years of emissions remain within that budget? Give your answer to one decimal place.

Hint 1The budget is a stock and emissions are a flow.

Hint 2Decide which of the two emissions figures is the whole flow.

Hint 3Divide the stock by the annual flow.

What has been agreed, and why so little of it binds

Because the atmosphere is a common access resource, no economy can solve the problem alone, and an agreement has to hold together without any authority able to enforce it. The sequence of agreements is the record of that difficulty.

AgreementWhat it didWhy it fell short
Kyoto Protocol, 1997, in force 2005First binding emissions targets, on industrialised economies onlyThe United States never ratified it, developing economies including China and India had no targets, and it expired in 2020
Paris Agreement, 2015Near universal participation, a goal of well below 2 degrees, targets each economy sets for itself, with review every five yearsNothing binds a country to its own target, and the targets submitted do not add to the goal
Glasgow Climate Pact, 2021First agreement to name coal, commitments on methane and deforestationLanguage weakened from phase out to phase down at the last session
Loss and damage fund, agreed 2022, operating from 2023Accepted the principle that economies suffering climate damage should be compensatedPledges are small relative to the damage and are voluntary
Baku, 2024New goal of US$300 billion a year by 2035, inside a wider US$1.3 trillion callDeveloping economies argued the figure was a fraction of the need and much of it will be lent
Belem, 2025A call to triple adaptation finance and a just transition mechanism, agreed by 195 partiesNo roadmap for phasing out fossil fuels was agreed inside the package

The pattern across the sequence is a trade between participation and obligation. Kyoto bound a few economies and was abandoned by the largest. Paris includes nearly everyone and binds nobody. That is not a failure of drafting: it is what happens when the only sanction available is embarrassment, so the agreement that everybody signs is the one that asks least.

What the agreements do achieve is worth marks and is routinely omitted. They create a common measurement and reporting standard, which makes it possible to know what each economy is doing. They create the five year review that ratchets targets and exposes the gap. They mobilise finance, imperfectly. And they coordinate expectations for private investors, which is why the cost of solar and battery technology has fallen as fast as it has.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Concluding that international agreements have failed because emissions keep rising. The counterfactual is not zero emissions, it is emissions without the agreements, and the comparison that matters is between projected warming before Paris and projected warming now. The honest judgement is that agreements have narrowed the gap and have not closed it, and the reason is enforcement rather than intent.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Assess the effectiveness of international agreements in addressing environmental sustainability.

Hint 1Start with why an agreement is needed at all, in economic terms.

Hint 2Trace what each agreement gained and what it gave up to get it.

Hint 3Pick the right comparison before judging effectiveness.

What the arithmetic says about continuing development. Fossil fuel emissions reached a record of about 38.1 billion tonnes in 2025, and total emissions including land use were roughly flat at about 42.2 billion tonnes. The remaining budget consistent with 1.5 degrees is about 170 billion tonnes, which is about four years at that rate. This is the quantitative core of the economic issue: the economies that have not yet industrialised are entitled to the growth that the industrialised ones already had, and there is no remaining budget for them to repeat the way it was done.

Which is why the transition is a technology and finance question. The way out of that arithmetic is for developing economies to reach middle incomes on an energy system that did not exist when the advanced economies industrialised. That requires capital at a scale their own saving cannot fund and technology under patents held elsewhere, which is exactly the trade, investment and technology transfer material from the previous lessons applied to one problem.

The resource curse and purposeful unsustainability. Some environmental damage is not a by-product at all. Deforestation for export agriculture, and mining under weak regulation, are chosen because they earn foreign exchange quickly. The economics is the same as the enclave case: an activity that raises measured output while depleting the natural capital the economy will need later, and which shows as growth because national accounts do not subtract the depletion.

Sustainable development as a measured objective. The seventeen Sustainable Development Goals replaced the Millennium Development Goals in 2015 and run to 2030, and they are the reason development and environmental objectives are now reported together rather than traded against each other. Progress on them has slowed since the pandemic, and the finance gap to meet them is measured in trillions a year.

Where this sits. This is the second component of the effects of globalisation. Trade, investment and transnational corporations came before it and the international business cycle follows. The globalisation essay, priority 12, uses all three, and the environmental policy essay, priority 6, takes the market failure material from here and applies it to Australian policy in Topics 3 and 4.

Worked example4 marks

Reading an economy's emissions on two bases

An economy reports emissions of 324 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent. Its consumption based footprint is 705 million tonnes, and its footprint in 1990 was 922 million tonnes. Its territorial emissions have fallen 53 per cent since 1990. Analyse what these figures show about its progress.

Find what the two measures are counting

The gap between them is the whole point, and naming the measures is the first mark.

The territorial figure of 324 million tonnes counts emissions released inside the borders. The footprint of 705 million tonnes counts emissions released anywhere in the world to meet the economy's demand, so 381 million tonnes, or about 54 per cent of the footprint, was released abroad.

Compare the trends rather than the levels

Progress is a rate of change, and the two bases give different rates.

Territorial emissions fell 53 per cent from 1990. The footprint fell from 922 to 705 million tonnes, which is about 24 per cent. The reported improvement is roughly twice the improvement in what the economy is responsible for.

Explain the difference

The mechanism is carbon leakage, and it connects this dot point to the relocation of production.

Emissions intensive production moved to economies with lower costs and lighter regulation, and the goods came back as imports. The emissions still occur and now appear on another economy's account.

Answer

On the territorial basis this economy has cut emissions by 53 per cent since 1990, and on the consumption basis by about 24 per cent, because 381 million tonnes of its 705 million tonne footprint, about 54 per cent, is released abroad making its imports. Both figures are correct and they measure different things: the first measures what the economy emits and can regulate, the second what its demand causes. The gap is carbon leakage, the movement of emissions intensive production to economies with lighter regulation, so a substantial part of the reported improvement reflects the relocation of production rather than a reduction in the damage caused. Real progress has been made, and it is smaller than the headline figure suggests.

Is that answer sensible?

Four marks: the two measures named, both rates of change calculated, the mechanism identified and a judgement that holds both figures at once. A response that quotes only the 53 per cent earns one.

Exam question

Harder · about 11 min

6 marks

Assess the potential impact on the environment of continuing world economic development.

Hint 1Separate the scale of output from the damage caused per unit of output.

Hint 2The answer differs for local pollutants and for carbon dioxide. Say why.

Hint 3Assess requires a judgement with conditions attached, not a prediction.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Answering with a list of environmental harms

    Why it happens: The topic is familiar from outside economics, where the harms are the story.

    The question is economic. Scale, composition, technology, market failure and distribution are the categories that earn marks.

  • Concluding that growth must stop

    Why it happens: The arithmetic looks like it forces that conclusion.

    The economies yet to develop have the strongest claim to growth. The examinable argument is about the energy system and the finance behind it, not about whether development should continue.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

5 marks

Explain the impact of globalisation on environmental sustainability.

The attempt

2 out of 5

Globalisation has had a major negative impact on the environment. Increased trade means more goods are transported around the world which increases carbon emissions from ships and planes. TNCs move their factories to developing countries where environmental laws are weaker so they can pollute more, which is called the race to the bottom. Deforestation in the Amazon has increased because of demand for agricultural exports. Climate change is causing rising sea levels and extreme weather events which will damage economies. International agreements like the Paris Agreement have tried to fix this but emissions are still rising so they have not worked.

What the marker sees

Two marks. The examples are real and the economics behind them is missing. Nothing here explains why an unregulated market produces this outcome, so the externality and the common access resource, which are the two ideas the question is testing, never appear. The race to the bottom is named but not explained, and the relocation of production is treated only as an evasion, with no mention that it also moves the emissions between accounts, which is the measurable version of the claim. The verdict on agreements is asserted from the wrong comparison: rising emissions do not show that agreements failed unless you say what would have happened without them. Explain requires mechanisms, and this is a list of consequences.

The same answer, fixed

5 out of 5

Globalisation affects environmental sustainability by changing the scale of production, its location, and the capacity of governments to price the damage it causes.

The underlying problem is market failure, and globalisation intensifies it rather than creating it. Environmental costs are externalities that sit outside the price, and the atmosphere is a common access resource that nobody owns and nobody can be excluded from using, so each user gains the full benefit of using more while bearing a fraction of the cost. Freer trade and investment raise the scale of output subject to that failure, which is the first and largest effect: world fossil fuel emissions reached a record of about 38 billion tonnes in 2025.

The second effect is on location. Emissions intensive production has moved towards economies with lower costs and lighter regulation, and the output returns as imports. This shows up as a gap between what an economy reports and what it causes: in 2021 about 54 per cent of the United Kingdom's carbon footprint was released outside it, and its territorial emissions had fallen 53 per cent since 1990 against about 24 per cent on the consumption measure. Carbon leakage of this kind means a national target can be met without the damage falling, which is the mechanism behind the race to the bottom claim and the reason carbon border adjustments are being introduced.

The third effect runs the other way. Globalisation lowers the cost of the solution as well as the cost of the damage. Open trade and investment spread solar, wind and battery technology and drove their costs down far faster than any single economy could have, and integration is what makes an agreement between nearly two hundred governments possible at all.

Against that, the same integration weakens the individual government. An economy that prices carbon alone bears the full cost and receives a small share of the benefit, and risks losing the production to a competitor, so unilateral action is limited by the mobility that globalisation created. This is why the response has to be collective, and why the agreements are as weak as they are: with no enforcement available, the agreement everyone will sign is the one that binds least. Paris achieved near universal participation at the cost of binding targets, and the gap between submitted targets and the stated goal is the measure of what that trade cost.

The judgement the evidence supports is that globalisation has enlarged both the damage and the means of addressing it, and that the damage has moved faster, because the market failure is global while the governments able to correct it are not.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 20 min

10 marks

Evaluate the impact of globalisation on environmental sustainability in the global economy.

Hint 1Evaluate needs a criterion. Decide early what counts as a sustainable outcome and judge against it.

Hint 2Globalisation raises the damage and also spreads the solution. Both belong.

Hint 3End on what would have to change, not on a restatement of both sides.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating globalisation as purely destructive of the environment

    Why it happens: The damage is concrete and the benefits are diffuse.

    The same integration that moved the emissions also moved the technology that reduces them. A response that cannot argue both sides cannot evaluate.

  • Using evidence that stops before 2020

    Why it happens: Kyoto and Paris are the material most often taught.

    The Baku finance goal, the Belem package and the 2025 emissions record are the current evidence, and the carbon budget arithmetic is what makes the argument urgent.

  • Ending with a summary rather than a judgement

    Why it happens: Evaluate is read as an instruction to weigh both sides.

    Weighing is the middle of the response. The end states which way the balance falls and what would change it.

Written for this site.