Methods of Financing Deficits
How the Commonwealth finances a budget deficit by borrowing from the private sector, from the Reserve Bank, from overseas or by selling assets, the advantages and costs of each including crowding out, inflation and foreign debt, and how the 2020 to 2022 bond purchases blurred the line between debt and monetary financing.
30 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management
Assumes you have read Effects of Budgetary Changes.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
When spending exceeds revenue, the gap must be financed. Your notes identify four methods.
| Method | How | Main advantage | Main cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Borrowing from the private sector (debt financing) | Sell Commonwealth government securities (bonds) by tender in domestic markets | No change in the money supply; not inflationary; reliable | Crowding out: higher interest rates reduce private investment; adds to public debt and interest costs |
| Borrowing from the Reserve Bank (monetary financing) | The Bank buys new bonds and credits the government's account, creating money | No rise in interest rates and no debt to the public | Inflation if the economy is near capacity; loss of confidence |
| Borrowing from overseas | Sell bonds in foreign currency markets | No pressure on domestic interest rates | Adds to foreign debt and future income payments, worsening the current account |
| Selling assets | Privatise government businesses or land | One-off revenue with no new debt | One-off only; loses the asset's future income; still draws on the savings pool |
- In practice, the Commonwealth finances deficits by issuing bonds through the Australian Office of Financial Management (AOFM). Because foreign investors buy a large share of bonds sold in Australia, the line between domestic and overseas borrowing has blurred.
- Gross debt is forecast at about $1.05 trillion (34 per cent of GDP) in 2026-27.
Borrowing from the private sector
AnswersHow does debt financing work, and what are its effects?
As your notes explain, the government sells Commonwealth government securities (bonds) in the domestic market. The AOFM announces the amount on offer, investors bid by offering the interest rate they will accept, and the lowest-yield bids are accepted first until the deficit is fully financed.
Advantages.
- No change in the money supply, because the money borrowed from the private sector is returned to the economy when the government spends it, so it is not inflationary in itself.
- Reliable. Commonwealth bonds are seen as very safe (Australia holds a AAA credit rating), so the deficit is almost certain to be fully financed.
- No direct increase in foreign debt, if domestic investors buy the bonds.
The main cost: crowding out. As your notes explain, crowding out works in three ways.
Chain of reasoning
The crowding out effect
Government demand for borrowed funds rises
bonds compete for the domestic savings poolInterest rates rises
other rates rise to compete with the risk-free bond rate: financial crowding outPrivate investment falls
firms find borrowing too expensive: real crowding outCapital inflow and the Australian dollar rises
higher rates attract foreign funds, reducing competitiveness: international crowding out
Crowding out is weaker in a recession, when private demand for funds is low, and stronger in a boom. In an open economy it is also weaker, because foreign investors add to the supply of funds. Debt financing also builds public debt, which must be serviced: net interest payments are forecast to rise from $13.7 billion in 2024-25 to $31.7 billion in 2029-30.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which statement best describes the crowding out effect of financing a budget deficit by borrowing from the private sector?
Hint 1Competition for savings.
Hint 2Interest rates.
Hint 3Private investment.
Borrowing from the Reserve Bank
AnswersWhat is monetary financing, and why is it rarely used?
As your notes explain, the government can sell new bonds directly to the Reserve Bank, which credits the government's account with newly created money. This is often called printing money.
Advantages. Interest rates do not rise, because the government is not competing for private saving, and no debt is owed to the public.
Disadvantages.
- Inflation. The money supply increases. If the economy is near full employment, the extra spending bids up prices rather than raising output.
- Confidence. Regular monetary financing signals a lack of spending discipline and can undermine confidence in the currency. Extreme cases, such as Zimbabwe in the late 2000s, ended in hyperinflation.
For these reasons advanced economies avoid direct monetary financing, and central banks are independent of government.
2020 to 2022. The Reserve Bank bought about $281 billion of government bonds under its bond purchase program and yield target. It bought them in the secondary market from investors, not directly from the government, so this was a monetary policy decision to lower long-term interest rates rather than formal monetary financing. The effect was similar, though: it lowered the cost of financing the COVID deficits and added to the money base. Your notes explain why the inflation effect was limited at first: much of the new money sat in banks' exchange settlement balances, and the household saving ratio was very high, above 20 per cent in 2020. When inflation rose from 2022, the Bank stopped buying and has since let its bond holdings run down.
Common mistake
The Reserve Bank printed money to pay for JobKeeper.
Why it happens: Bond purchases and the deficit happened at the same time.
The Bank bought bonds from investors in the secondary market as monetary policy, not directly from the government. The deficit was financed by selling bonds to the market through the AOFM. The purchases lowered borrowing costs, which made financing cheaper, but they were not direct monetary financing.
Borrowing from overseas and selling assets
AnswersWhat are the effects of financing a deficit from overseas or by selling assets?
Borrowing from overseas. As your notes explain, the government sells bonds to foreign investors. This avoids pushing up domestic interest rates, but it adds to Australia's foreign liabilities. The interest paid on this debt is a debit on the primary income account, which worsens the current account deficit in future years.
Your notes also explain that, with globalisation, the distinction between domestic and overseas borrowing matters less, because foreign investors buy bonds directly in the Australian market. Non-resident holdings of Commonwealth bonds have been around half of the total in recent years (AOFM), which weakens crowding out but makes financing costs more sensitive to world interest rates and investor sentiment.
Selling assets. A one-off sale of government businesses, land or shares, such as the float of Medibank Private in 2014, raises revenue without new borrowing. But:
- it can be done only once;
- the government loses the asset's future income stream;
- the buyer's money still comes from the savings pool or from overseas, so it still competes for funds.
Exam question
Standard · about 7 min
4 marks
Compare the effects of financing a budget deficit by borrowing from overseas with financing it by borrowing from the Reserve Bank. (4 marks)
Hint 1Foreign liabilities.
Hint 2Money supply.
Hint 3Interest rates in both.
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying overseas borrowing increases the money supply.
Why it happens: Foreign funds enter the economy.
The inflation risk belongs to monetary financing.
Written for this site.
Analysing alternative ways to finance a deficit
AnswersHow should a government choose between methods of financing a deficit?
The right method depends on economic conditions.
| Condition | Best suited | Least suited | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deep recession, rates near zero | Debt financing, possibly with central bank bond purchases | Crowding out is weak; inflation risk is low | |
| Economy near capacity, inflation above target | Debt financing with spending restraint | Monetary financing | Printing money adds to inflation |
| Large current account deficit, high foreign debt | Domestic debt financing | Overseas borrowing | Avoids adding to foreign liabilities |
| One-off shortfall | Asset sales | Temporary revenue without permanent debt |
Worked example6 marks
Choosing how to finance a deficit
A government faces a budget deficit of $40 billion. Inflation is 3.9 per cent, above the 2 to 3 per cent target, unemployment is 4.6 per cent, and the current account deficit is 3.2 per cent of GDP. The yield on 10-year government bonds is 4.5 per cent.
Analyse the alternative ways the government could finance this deficit, and recommend one.
Debt financing from the private sector
Selling $40 billion of bonds domestically does not change the money supply, so it does not add directly to inflation. At a yield of 4.5 per cent it adds about billion dollars a year to interest costs.
The risk is crowding out: the economy is near capacity, so private demand for funds is strong and higher bond issuance may push up interest rates and reduce private investment.
Monetary financing
Borrowing from the Reserve Bank would add $40 billion to the money supply at a time when inflation is already above target and unemployment is low. This would add to inflation and conflict with the Bank's tightening. It is the least suitable method.
Overseas borrowing and asset sales
Borrowing overseas avoids domestic interest rate pressure, but with a current account deficit of 3.2 per cent of GDP it would add to foreign liabilities and future primary income debits.
Asset sales could cover part of the deficit once, but a $40 billion sale is large, forfeits future income, and still draws on savings.
Answer
Domestic debt financing is the most suitable, because it avoids the inflationary risk of monetary financing and the external risk of overseas borrowing. Its cost is about $1.8 billion a year in interest and some crowding out, which is why it should be paired with spending restraint to reduce the deficit while inflation is above target.
Is that answer sensible?
A full answer recognises that the choice is partly theoretical: foreign investors buy a large share of bonds sold in Australia, so "domestic" debt financing still adds to foreign liabilities in practice. The judgement would differ in a recession, when crowding out is weak and inflation risk is low, which is why the combination of bond issuance and Reserve Bank purchases in 2020 was appropriate then but would not be now.
Exam question
Harder · about 11 min
6 marks
In 2020 the Australian economy was in recession, with interest rates near zero and unemployment rising. Analyse the alternative ways the government could have financed the large budget deficits of that period. (6 marks)
Hint 1Weak crowding out in recession.
Hint 2Low inflation risk.
Hint 3What actually happened.
Where students lose marks on this one
Ignoring economic conditions.
Why it happens: The methods are learned as a list.
Crowding out and inflation risk depend on the cycle.
Written for this site.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'Selling government assets is the best way to finance deficits because it creates no debt and has no effect on the savings pool.' Which response is best?
Hint 1One-off.
Hint 2Future income.
Hint 3Where the buyer gets the money.
Is public debt a problem?
Australia's gross debt of about 34 per cent of GDP is low by international standards; the average for advanced economies is well above 100 per cent. But three arguments make debt matter even at low levels.
First, interest rates rose. Debt issued during the pandemic at yields near 1 per cent is being refinanced at more than 4 per cent, so interest is now one of the fastest-growing items in the budget. Second, fiscal space: a lower starting debt gives more room to respond to the next crisis, which is the main argument for the current strategy of reducing debt as a share of GDP. Third, intergenerational equity: debt used for recurrent spending shifts the cost to future taxpayers without leaving them an asset.
Against this, debt used for productive investment, such as infrastructure and education, can raise future output and tax revenue enough to pay for itself, and running surpluses too early in a downturn can deepen it. The debate is therefore less about the level of debt than about what it finances and when it is repaid.