Exchange Rate Systems
How the value of a currency is set under floating, fixed and managed exchange rates, drawn with demand and supply diagrams, with the advantages and disadvantages of each and the history of Australia's regime to the float in 1983.
40 min · HSC Topic Two - Australia's Place in the Global Economy
Assumes you have read Appreciation and Depreciation.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- Floating (flexible): the rate is set by demand and supply alone. A shock moves the price. Australia has floated since 12 December 1983.
- Fixed: the central bank sets the rate, usually against the US dollar, and buys or sells its currency to fill any gap between demand and supply at that rate. A shock moves its foreign currency reserves instead of the price. Hong Kong has kept its dollar between HK$7.75 and HK$7.85 per US dollar.
- Managed: the rate may move within a band or be guided daily, and the central bank intervenes at the edges. China manages the renminbi against a basket of currencies.
- The float's advantages: independent monetary policy, a price set by the market, a shock absorber against external shocks (the dollar fell 29 per cent in three months in the GFC), and no need for large reserves.
- Its disadvantages: volatility and overshooting, which firms manage by hedging.
Floating exchange rates
AnswersHow is the exchange rate determined under a floating system?
- Floating exchange rate
An exchange rate set purely by the market forces of demand for and supply of the currency, without a target set by the government or central bank.
The demand for a currency is a derived demand: foreigners want Australian dollars because they want Australian goods, services and assets. Supply is derived from Australians' demand for foreign goods, services and assets.
- Demand slopes down: as the dollar falls, Australian products become cheaper to foreigners, so more A$ are demanded.
- Supply slopes up: as the dollar rises, foreign products become cheaper to Australians, so more A$ are supplied to buy them.
The rate settles where the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied. A shift in either curve moves the price: a rise to a higher equilibrium is an appreciation, a fall a depreciation.
- Demand for A$
- Supply of A$
- Demand after the shock
- System
- Floating
- Exchange rate
- US$0.67, an appreciation of 11.1 per cent
- Rate the market alone would set
- US$0.67
- Central bank
- No intervention: the price moves until the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied.
- What shifts demand
- More exports sold, higher export prices, foreign investment into Australia, higher Australian interest rates, expectations of appreciation.
- What shifts supply
- More imports bought, Australians investing abroad, income paid to foreign owners and lenders, expectations of depreciation.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Set the system to 1 and shift demand left. The price falls to a new equilibrium; nobody intervenes. Then try 2 (fixed) and 3 (managed) with the same shift, and compare who absorbs the shock.
How to draw it. Vertical axis: price of A$1 (US$ or TWI). Horizontal axis: quantity of A$. Downward sloping D, upward sloping S, equilibrium at quantity . Show the shift, the new equilibrium and label the change as an appreciation or depreciation.
Fixed exchange rates
AnswersHow is the exchange rate determined under a fixed system?
- Fixed exchange rate
An exchange rate set by the central bank against another currency (usually the US dollar) or a basket, and held there by the central bank buying or selling its own currency in exchange for foreign currency reserves.
The fixed rate is almost never exactly the market equilibrium, so the central bank must fill the gap every day.
- Peg above equilibrium (excess supply). At the peg more A$ are offered than wanted. The central bank buys the excess A$, paying with foreign currency reserves. Its reserves fall, and it can only keep this up while they last.
- Peg below equilibrium (excess demand). At the peg more A$ are wanted than offered. The central bank sells A$ and buys foreign currency. Its reserves rise, and the extra A$ add to the money supply, which is inflationary unless it sterilises them by selling bonds.
How to draw it. Draw D and S, a horizontal line at the peg, and the gap between the curves at that price, labelled as the central bank's purchase or sale of A$.
Hong Kong is the classic fixed case: since 1983 its currency board has held the Hong Kong dollar to the US dollar, since 2005 within HK$7.75 to HK$7.85. On 22 September 2025 and 2026 the implied rate was HK$7.77 and HK$7.84 per US dollar, inside the band, while the Australian dollar moved 8 per cent against the US dollar over the same year.
Advantages of a fixed rate
- Certainty about the value of the currency, which helps exporters and importers plan.
- It imports the monetary policy credibility of the anchor currency.
Disadvantages of a fixed rate
- Speculative attack. If the market thinks the peg is too high, speculators sell the currency, and the central bank must buy it back with reserves. If reserves run low it is forced to devalue, as in the 1997 Asian financial crisis.
- No independent monetary policy. Interest rates must follow the anchor country to stop capital flowing in or out.
- Balance of payments outcomes change the money supply. Surpluses add to it and can cause inflation; deficits drain it, slowing growth and raising unemployment.
- No automatic adjustment. The price cannot fall to restore competitiveness after a shock, so structural problems and deficits can become entrenched, ending in costly devaluations.
Common mistake
Under a fixed exchange rate, demand and supply for the currency no longer matter.
Why it happens: The price does not move, so the market seems switched off.
Demand and supply still shift. The difference is who absorbs the shift: under a float the price does; under a fixed rate the central bank's reserves do. A big enough fall in demand exhausts the reserves and forces a devaluation.
Exam question
Standard · about 2 min
1 mark
A central bank fixes its currency above the market equilibrium rate. What must it do to maintain the peg?
Hint 1Above equilibrium, is there excess demand or excess supply of the currency?
Hint 2Someone must take up the excess.
Hint 3What does the central bank pay with?
Where students lose marks on this one
Choosing to sell its currency.
Why it happens: Selling seems to support a currency.
Selling adds to supply and pushes the price down further.
Written for this site.
Managed exchange rates
AnswersHow is the exchange rate determined under a managed system?
- Managed exchange rate
An exchange rate that the market sets within limits chosen by the central bank, such as a band around a central rate or a daily reference rate, with the central bank intervening to keep it within those limits.
Your notes use a band example: if the Reserve Bank wanted to keep the dollar between US$0.65 and US$0.75, it would let the market set the rate inside the band. If demand fell so that the rate would drop below 65 cents, it would buy A$ to hold it at 65. If demand rose so that the rate would go above 75 cents, it would sell A$ to hold it at 75.
How to draw it. Draw D and S with two horizontal lines for the top and bottom of the band. If the new equilibrium lies inside the band, no intervention is needed. If it lies outside, the price stops at the edge and the gap at that price is the central bank's intervention.
China manages the renminbi. The People's Bank of China sets a daily reference rate against the US dollar, taking account of a basket of currencies, and allows trading within 2 per cent either side. Unlike the Hong Kong dollar it does move: it rose about 6 per cent against the US dollar in the year to 22 September 2026, from about 7.11 to 6.70 yuan per US dollar.
The three systems in one shock
AnswersHow does the same shock affect a currency under each system?
Worked example6 marks
A fall in demand under each system
Demand for a currency is and supply is , with in US cents and quantities in billions. It starts at . A fall in commodity prices cuts demand by 30 billion (). Find the outcome under (a) a float, (b) a peg at 60 cents and (c) a band from 55 to 65 cents.
Floating
Set , so and . The currency depreciates from 60 to 50 cents, a fall of 16.7 per cent. No reserves are used.
Fixed at 60 cents
At : and . Supply exceeds demand by 30 billion, so the central bank buys 30 billion of its currency with foreign reserves. The price stays at 60.
Managed, 55 to 65 cents
The market would go to 50, below the band, so the price stops at 55. There: and . The central bank buys 15 billion. The currency falls 8.3 per cent.
Answer
| System | Exchange rate | Central bank |
|---|---|---|
| Floating | 50 cents, down 16.7% | Nothing |
| Fixed | 60 cents, unchanged | Buys 30 billion |
| Managed | 55 cents, down 8.3% | Buys 15 billion |
The shock is absorbed by the price under a float, by reserves under a peg, and partly by each under a managed rate.
Is that answer sensible?
The managed intervention should lie between zero (float) and the full peg intervention (30 billion). It does: 15 billion.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Demand for a currency is Q = 150 − 1.5P + d and supply is Q = 1.5P − 30, with P in US cents and Q in billions. The central bank keeps the rate between 55 and 65 cents. Demand rises by 45 billion (d = +45).
How many billion units of its own currency must the central bank sell to keep the rate within the band?
Hint 1First find where the market alone would go: 150 − 1.5P + 45 = 1.5P − 30.
Hint 2If that is above 65, the price stops at 65.
Hint 3At P = 65, find demand minus supply.
Exam question
Harder · about 7 min
4 marks
Using demand and supply diagrams, explain how an increase in demand for a currency is handled under a floating and under a fixed exchange rate system. (4 marks)
Hint 1Under a float, what moves?
Hint 2Under a fixed rate, what fills the gap at the peg?
Hint 3What happens to reserves and the money supply?
Where students lose marks on this one
Showing the fixed rate moving.
Why it happens: The float diagram is drawn first.
Under a peg the price line stays put; mark the gap instead.
Written for this site.
Australia's path to the float
AnswersWhy did Australia float the dollar in 1983 and how has it worked?
| Period | Regime |
|---|---|
| Until December 1971 | Fixed to the British pound (the Australian dollar replaced the pound in 1966) |
| December 1971 to September 1974 | Fixed to the US dollar |
| September 1974 to November 1976 | Fixed to a trade weighted basket of currencies, the origin of the TWI |
| November 1976 to December 1983 | Crawling peg: the basket peg adjusted in small, frequent steps |
| From 12 December 1983 | Floating |
The Hawke government gave three main reasons for floating:
- It is the most efficient way to set the currency's value, reflecting the fundamentals of the economy.
- It exposes the economy to international competitive pressures.
- It allows an independent monetary policy. With financial flows growing fast, defending a peg meant balance of payments flows kept changing the money supply, undermining the fight against inflation. Speculation against the crawling peg in 1983 made this acute.
Advantages of the float, as your notes give them
- Independent monetary policy. Balance of payments surpluses and deficits no longer change the money supply, so the Reserve Bank can set interest rates for Australian conditions.
- A shock absorber. A downturn abroad cuts demand for A$, the dollar depreciates, and exports become more competitive. In the global financial crisis the dollar fell from US$0.9434 at the end of July 2008 to US$0.6680 at the end of October, 29 per cent in three months, cushioning exporters. The same happened in 2020 and 2025.
- No need for large reserves or the inflationary money creation that defending a low currency can bring.
- Less destabilising speculation against a fixed target: there is no peg for speculators to bet against.
- Confidence and capital market integration. A market determined currency supports investor confidence and lets Australia finance current account deficits smoothly.
Disadvantages
- Volatility. Changes in expectations and sentiment move the dollar sharply, creating uncertainty for trade, saving and investment. Firms manage the risk with hedging: forward contracts that lock in an exchange rate for a future transaction.
- Overshooting. Herd behaviour can push the dollar far from its fundamental value: to about US$0.48 in 2001, and above US$1.10 in 2011.
Common mistake
Australia's dollar is a clean float: the Reserve Bank never influences it.
Why it happens: The float means the market sets the rate.
The Reserve Bank keeps the power to intervene when the market becomes disorderly, and its interest rate decisions move the dollar. Australia is often described as a dirty or managed float at the margin. That is the next lesson.
Exam question
Harder · about 7 min
4 marks
Evaluate the floating exchange rate as a system for Australia. (4 marks)
Hint 1Give at least two advantages with evidence.
Hint 2Give at least one disadvantage and how it is managed.
Hint 3Finish with a judgement.
Where students lose marks on this one
Listing points without a judgement.
Why it happens: Evaluate sounds like describe.
Evaluate means make a judgement based on criteria.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Straightforward · about 1 min
1 mark
When was the Australian dollar floated?
Hint 1It was under the Hawke government.
Hint 2It followed a crawling peg.
Hint 3Late in the government's first year.
Where students lose marks on this one
Choosing 1976.
Why it happens: The crawling peg began then.
1976 was the start of the crawling peg, not the float.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Harder · about 2 min
1 mark
A student writes: 'A fixed exchange rate removes all risk, because the currency cannot change in value.' What is wrong with this?
Hint 1What does the central bank need to hold the peg?
Hint 2What happens if speculators think the peg is too high?
Hint 3Think of 1997 in Asia.
Where students lose marks on this one
Treating the peg as permanent.
Why it happens: It is announced as fixed.
A peg lasts only as long as the reserves and the political will.
Written for this site.
The trilemma
An economy cannot have all three of a fixed exchange rate, free movement of capital and an independent monetary policy. It must give one up. Hong Kong keeps the peg and open capital flows, so its interest rates follow the United States. China manages its currency and sets its own interest rates, so it limits capital flows. Australia keeps open capital flows and independent monetary policy, so it lets the dollar float. This is the modern form of the notes' third reason for floating: once Australia's financial markets were opened in the early 1980s, the peg had to go.