HSC Study

Evaluating Development Strategies

The last Topic 1 dot point: judging a development strategy rather than describing it, applying the same criteria to real programmes and to a hypothetical government with a fixed budget and a choice to make.

80 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read Reasons for Differences Between Nations and Case Study: Globalisation and Development in Vietnam.

The full teaching. Start here.

Evaluatetypically 6 to 8 marks

Demands
Judge worth against criteria, weighing strengths against weaknesses, and conclude.
Shape
A position stated early, defended with evidence, with the counter-case acknowledged and answered.
Loses marks
Listing advantages and disadvantages with no weighting, so nothing is actually evaluated.
Development strategy

A deliberate government or donor programme intended to raise living standards, not merely output. Trade and investment policy, aid, debt relief, cash transfers, microfinance, schooling, health and infrastructure programmes and institutional reform are all development strategies.

Conditional cash transfer

A payment made to poor households on condition that children attend school or attend health checks. It delivers income now and buys human capital later, which is why it is evaluated on both.

Opportunity cost of a strategy

The best alternative use of the same money. It is the criterion most often missing from an evaluation, and the one that turns "this programme helped people" into a judgement.

Six criteria that work on any strategy

Learn these rather than a ranking of strategies, because the ranking changes with the economy.

CriterionThe questionWhy responses lose marks on it
ObjectiveWhat was this meant to achieve, and by when?A strategy aimed at poverty now is judged against growth in twenty years
MechanismHow does the money become development?The effect is asserted; no chain is drawn
EvidenceWhat changed that can be measured?Intentions are quoted instead of outcomes
Cost and opportunity costWhat was given up to do this?Every programme looks good when the alternative is nothing
CounterfactualWhat would have happened anyway?Improvement in a growing economy is credited to the programme
TransferabilityWould it work elsewhere, and why?East Asian policies are recommended to economies with none of the conditions that made them work

The two doing most of the work are the fourth and the sixth. A development budget is always fixed, so any strategy is being chosen over another one, and the interesting question is never whether a programme helped somebody but whether it helped more than the alternative. Transferability then decides whether the case study you have learnt is evidence for the situation in front of you.

Common mistake

Evaluating a strategy by listing its advantages and disadvantages

Why it happens:

Two balanced lists and a sentence saying "overall it has been partly effective" is the most common answer to this dot point and rarely passes the middle band. Name the objective, apply evidence to it, say what the money would otherwise have done, and commit to a position. A judgement that could be wrong is worth more than a balance that cannot be.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A government reports that after five years of its rural road programme, incomes in the districts that received roads were 12 per cent higher than before the programme began. Which step is missing before this can be used as evidence that the programme was effective?

Select one answer

Hint 1Ask what else was happening in those five years.

Hint 2If the whole economy grew over the period, how much of the 12 per cent belongs to the roads?

Hint 3The missing step is the one that asks what would have happened anyway.

The strategies, with the evidence each is evaluated on

StrategyMechanismThe evidence forThe evidence against
Export oriented industrialisationForeign investment and world markets supply capital, technology and demand that a poor economy lacksThe fastest recorded escapes from low income, in East Asia and then in VietnamRetained value can be low, the tax base is competed away, and the exposure to a foreign cycle is imported with the growth
Import substitutionProtection builds domestic industry behind a tariff wall so that manufacturing capability is developed at homeSome infant industries did mature; it reduces dependence on a single foreign marketIndustries that never became competitive, small domestic markets limiting scale, and the fiscal cost of sustaining them
Development aidA transfer that funds investment without needing to be servicedDirected programmes in health and schooling have measurable outcomes; multilateral aid is better targeted at the poorest economiesThe committee average is around half the 0.7 per cent of national income promised since 1970, and part of what is counted never leaves the donor economy
Debt reliefRemoving debt servicing frees revenue for health, education and infrastructureThe initiatives of the early 2000s measurably raised social spending in the economies that completed themThe framework agreed by the G20 has moved slowly, because the creditor group is no longer the small club it was designed around
Conditional cash transfersIncome now, conditional on schooling and health checks, so human capital is bought at the same timeAmong the best evidenced programmes in development, with consistent effects on enrolment and nutritionThey raise capability without creating the jobs that capability needs, so they cannot substitute for growth
MicrofinanceSmall loans let poor households invest in tiny enterprisesExpands access to credit where no formal banking exists, particularly for womenThe average effect on income and poverty is far smaller than the early claims, and high interest rates can leave borrowers worse off
Human capital and infrastructureSchooling, clinics, roads and electricity raise the return on every other investmentVietnam's electrification and universal basic schooling; the complementarity with foreign investmentSlow, expensive, and dependent on institutional capacity to build and maintain
Institutional reformSecure property rights and a functioning state raise the return on investment and make it safe to makeThe variable that best separates economies with similar resources and historiesHard to do from outside, slow, and difficult to measure, so programmes claiming it often cannot show it
Development aid against the promiseAustralia gives 0.19 per cent of its national income as aid, against a target of 0.70 per cent, and 5 of the 12 donors shown reach it.Norway1.09Luxembourg0.99Sweden0.91Germany0.79Denmark0.74United Kingdom0.58France0.50Japan0.44Canada0.38Committee total0.37Italy0.27United States0.24Australia0.19Target 0.70%00.250.50.751Aid given as a share of the donor's national income (%)
The target has been 0.7 per cent of national income since 1970 and the committee as a whole has never reached half of it. The useful exam point is not that aid is small but that its size is a choice: the bars show that donors of similar wealth give three and four times as much as each other, so the shortfall is a policy decision rather than a constraint.
The numbers behind this graph
DonorAid, % of national incomeNational income, US$ billion
Norway1.09545
Luxembourg0.9960
Sweden0.91620
Germany0.794100
Denmark0.74410
United Kingdom0.583300
France0.503000
Japan0.444400
Canada0.382100
Committee total0.3755000
Italy0.272200
United States0.2427000
Australia0.191700
13
0.70 %
Australia
0.19 per cent of national income, which is 0.27 times the target of 0.70 per cent
Donors at or above the target
5 of 12 shown
Aid actually given by these donors
About 183 billion United States dollars in the reference year
What the target would add
About 170 billion dollars more a year if every donor shown reached 0.70 per cent
Committee average
0.37 per cent, roughly half the promise made in 1970
What counts as aid here
The published figures include the cost of housing refugees inside the donor economy, which rose sharply after 2022. That money is counted as aid and never leaves the donor, so the share reaching developing economies is smaller than the bars suggest.
Why the amount is not the whole argument
Tied aid, which must be spent on the donor’s own goods, and the share paid to consultants in donor countries both cut what reaches the recipient. Aid directed by strategic interest also goes to the economies a donor cares about rather than the ones in most need.
Source
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Development Assistance Committee, official development assistance statistics, 2023 preliminary data

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Two conclusions are worth stating because they are supported across the table.

No strategy works alone. Foreign investment without schooling, roads and power attracts little; schooling without jobs produces educated emigration; cash transfers without growth raise capability that the economy cannot employ. The complementarity is the reason the East Asian cases combined all of them.

The binding constraint decides the ranking. In an economy where capital is the constraint, foreign investment is the highest return strategy. Where the constraint is that nothing can safely be built, institutional reform comes first and the investment incentives are wasted. Identifying the constraint before recommending a strategy is the analytical move that most improves a response.

What lifts this to a Band 6

Use the strategies that failed. Import substitution is the clearest natural experiment in development economics, because a group of Latin American economies pursued it while a group of East Asian economies pursued export orientation from similar starting points, and the divergence is large. A response that can explain that comparison has an evaluative argument rather than a preference.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Compare the effectiveness of export oriented industrialisation with that of conditional cash transfers as development strategies.

Hint 1The two strategies are aimed at different objectives, so say what each is trying to do before judging it.

Hint 2One has the stronger evidence base; the other has the larger effect where it works. Say which is which and why.

Hint 3Finish with the condition that decides which is the better choice in a given economy.

The mix: relief now against capacity later

Most examination scenarios come down to one choice: money spent on people now, or on the capacity that raises what they can earn later. Both are development spending, and the trade off is about timing and about who waits.

How to spend a development budgetWith a budget of 4.0 per cent of GDP and an institutional index of 50, the share that does most for income after 20 years is about 86 per cent to long run capacity.Best for the later outcome: 86 per cent to capacity0204060801000102030405060Share of the budget spent on long run capacity (per cent)Outcome (per cent)
  • Share of the poor lifted above the line now, per cent
  • Income per person after 20 years, per cent above baseline
A hypothetical, and the syllabus asks for hypothetical situations by name. The point is not the numbers, which are constructed, but the shape: the best mix moves with institutional quality, so the same strategy evaluated in two economies earns two different verdicts.
4.0 % of GDP
50 index
20 years
On these settings
Spending everything on transfers lifts about 45 per cent of the poor above the line now and leaves income about 27 per cent higher after 20 years. Spending everything on capacity lifts nobody now and leaves income about 41 per cent higher. The mix that does most for the later outcome puts about 86 per cent into capacity.
What the trade off actually is
Not growth against development, which is the usual mistake, but relief now against capacity later. A transfer reaches a household this year and is spent; a road, a clinic or a school year changes what that household can earn for decades. Both are development spending and the evaluation is about timing and about who bears the wait.
Why institutional quality moves the answer
Investment only pays its return if the project is built, maintained and used. Where institutions are weak the return falls and the absorptive limit binds sooner, so the best share for capacity moves towards transfers, which are harder to waste because they are simply handed over. On these settings the institutional index is 50, which is why the peak sits at 86 per cent. Move it to either extreme and watch the peak move: that movement is the evaluative point, because it means the same strategy is right in one economy and wrong in another.
Why transfers still raise the later outcome
The lower curve does not start at zero when nothing is invested, because transfers themselves build capacity. A child who is fed and stays in school becomes a more productive adult, which is why conditional cash transfer programmes are evaluated on schooling and health outcomes rather than on consumption alone.
What the figure leaves out
Where the budget comes from. A government financing this by borrowing in a foreign currency has added an exposure that the figure does not show, and one financing it from a single commodity export has tied its development programme to a price it does not control. It also leaves out politics: transfers are visible within an electoral cycle and infrastructure is not.
Read it as
A constructed example, not data. The curves are chosen to have the right shape, so use the figure to argue about which considerations decide the mix, and use real programmes for evidence.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

The figure is a constructed example, and the shape is the teaching. Move the institutional quality slider and the best mix moves with it: where institutions are strong, investment pays enough to justify the wait; where they are weak, the return falls and the absorptive limit binds, so transfers do more because they are harder to waste. That is why the same strategy earns different verdicts in two economies, which is precisely what the dot point means by a range of situations.

Three things the figure deliberately leaves out belong in any full evaluation:

  • Where the money came from. A programme financed by borrowing in a foreign currency has added an external exposure. One financed from a single commodity export has tied the development programme to a price the government does not control.
  • Who waits. Investment asks this generation to accept less so the next has more. That is a legitimate choice and it is not a technical one, which is why development strategy is contested politically rather than settled by calculation.
  • Politics and time. Transfers are visible inside an electoral cycle and infrastructure is not, so the strategy chosen is not always the strategy that scores best.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'Spending a development budget on cash transfers helps people now, but spending it on infrastructure and schooling is what actually promotes development, so a government serious about development should spend as much as possible on the second.' What is wrong with this reasoning?

Select one answer

Hint 1Ask what has to be true for a road to deliver its return.

Hint 2Where does an investment programme run into limits that a transfer does not?

Hint 3The answer that says 'it depends on something' is usually the one that names the condition.

Answering a hypothetical

A hypothetical question gives you an economy in a few lines. Everything in those lines is a constraint placed there deliberately, so read them as the marking criteria.

  1. Identify the binding constraint from what the scenario tells you: no capital, no skills, no institutions, no market access, too much debt, or an exposure to one price.
  2. Name two candidate strategies, one that addresses the constraint directly and one that is the obvious but wrong answer, so the comparison is available.
  3. Apply the criteria: objective, mechanism, evidence from a real case, cost and opportunity cost.
  4. Choose, and say under what conditions you would choose differently.
  5. Name the risk you have accepted by choosing.

Worked example6 marks

A government with one budget and two options

A low income economy has a coastline, a young and largely literate population, unreliable electricity supply and a government with limited administrative capacity. Its government has US$40 million to commit.

Option A is an export processing zone: US$40 million of site works, power connection and road access, expected to attract foreign manufacturers employing 8,000 workers whose annual income rises by US$900 each compared with what they earn now.

Option B is a conditional cash transfer programme: US$40 million distributed to poor households, delivering US$40 million of household income in the year it is paid, conditional on school attendance.

Evaluate the two options.

Put both options on the same measure

Option A delivers an ongoing gain: 8,000 workers times US$900 is US$7.2 million of additional income a year, continuing as long as the zone operates.

Option B delivers US$40 million once, in the year it is paid.

The payback period for Option A is US$40 million divided by US$7.2 million a year, which is about 5.6 years. After that, every year is additional.

Say what each option does that the measure does not capture

Option A also builds power and road infrastructure that is available to other users, and it puts workers into manufacturing jobs where they acquire skills. Against that, the jobs depend on foreign firms that can leave, the retained value may be low if the inputs are imported, and the zone does nothing for households whose members cannot take a factory job.

Option B raises school attendance, which raises the earnings of the next generation, and it reaches the poorest directly rather than through the labour market. Against that, it creates no jobs for the children it educates, and it ends when the money ends.

Apply the constraints the scenario gave you

Three constraints are stated and each one matters. The electricity supply is unreliable, which is the constraint most likely to stop Option A from attracting any investor at all, so part of the budget has to fix it before the zone can work. Administrative capacity is limited, which raises the risk of Option A being built badly and lowers the cost of Option B, since transfers are simpler to administer than construction. The population is young and literate, which means the labour that Option A needs exists and the schooling condition in Option B is buying a smaller increment than it would where enrolment is low.

Choose, and say what would change the choice

On these facts, Option A is the better commitment, because its gain is permanent and its payback is under six years, because the workforce it requires already exists, and because the infrastructure is useful beyond the zone. The judgement depends on fixing the power supply from within the same budget, which reduces the size of the zone and lengthens the payback.

The choice would reverse if the population were not already literate, if there were no realistic prospect of attracting manufacturers, or if administrative capacity were so weak that the construction would not be completed, which is the usual reason zones fail.

Answer

Option A, conditional on funding the electricity connection first and accepting a smaller zone, because it produces a permanent income gain with a payback under six years in an economy that already has the workforce it needs. Option B does more for the poorest immediately and does not address the constraint that keeps them poor.

Is that answer sensible?

The risk accepted is concentration: the gain depends on foreign firms that can relocate, and on world demand for whatever the zone produces. A complete answer names that risk and the mitigation, which is to use the revenue from the zone to fund the transfers later, rather than treating the two options as permanently exclusive.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A government has US$60 million to commit. An industrial park costing the full US$60 million is expected to attract manufacturers employing 9,000 workers, each gaining US$800 a year in income compared with their current earnings, for as long as the park operates. The alternative is a cash transfer programme that distributes the whole US$60 million to poor households once, delivering US$60 million of household income in that year and nothing afterwards. Calculate, in years to one decimal place, how long the park takes before the income it has delivered equals the income the transfer delivered.

Hint 1Work out the income the park delivers in a single year.

Hint 2The transfer delivers its whole amount at once; the park delivers the same annual amount every year.

Hint 3Divide the transfer's total by the park's annual gain.

Why the strategies that worked may not transfer

Every successful case in the textbook industrialised by exporting labour intensive manufactures. Four things have changed since.

The incumbent is larger. China occupies much of the low cost manufacturing space that Korea, Taiwan and later Vietnam moved into, so a new entrant competes against an established producer with better infrastructure rather than against a vacancy.

Automation has weakened the advantage. The competitive edge of a low income economy is cheap labour, and as more of assembly is automated the value of that edge falls, which is sometimes called premature deindustrialisation: economies begin to lose manufacturing employment at much lower income levels than the earlier developers did.

The rules are tighter. Much of what the East Asian economies did, including directed credit, local content requirements and export subsidies, would now breach obligations they accepted on joining the WTO. The policy space that produced the successes is narrower for anyone following.

The climate constraint is new. The earlier developers industrialised on coal without a carbon constraint. The economies developing now face both the physical exposure and the expectation that they will build a lower emissions path, financed largely by loans rather than grants, which is the argument the environmental sustainability lesson sets out.

None of this means industrialisation is closed off. It means an evaluation that recommends the East Asian strategy without naming these four changes has not evaluated anything, and that services exports, regional markets and agricultural processing deserve more weight than the standard answer gives them.

The evidence problem

Development strategies are unusually hard to evaluate, because the counterfactual is unobservable and the successes are self selected. Economies that adopt reform programmes differ from those that do not, so comparing them measures the difference between the economies as much as the effect of the programme. This is why the strategies with the strongest evidence, conditional cash transfers and specific health interventions, are the ones that were trialled deliberately, and why claims about aid in aggregate remain contested after fifty years.

Say this in a response and it reads as sophistication rather than evasion, provided you still commit to a judgement afterwards.

Where this sits

This lesson completes Topic 1. It uses the reasons for differences lesson for the constraints, the case study for the positive example, the aid material from the global distribution lesson for the evidence on transfers, and the assessing organisations lesson for the institutions that fund and restrict these strategies. Its material supports priority 10 on differences in development and priority 8 on the case study, both planned elsewhere.

Putting it together

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 11 min

6 marks

A landlocked low income economy earns 70 per cent of its export revenue from one mineral, has a young population with low school completion, weak administrative capacity and debt servicing absorbing a quarter of government revenue. Evaluate the development strategies available to its government.

Hint 1Every clause in the scenario is a constraint placed there deliberately. Work out which one binds first.

Hint 2Being landlocked rules out one of the standard strategies almost entirely. Say why.

Hint 3Finish with a choice, the sequence, and the risk you have accepted.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Recommending an export processing zone because that is what worked in the case study

    Why it happens: The studied case is the available evidence, so it is applied without checking transferability.

    Check the conditions that made the case work. Coastal access is one of them, and the scenario has removed it.

  • Listing every strategy in the syllabus with a sentence each

    Why it happens: Coverage feels safer than selection when the scenario is unfamiliar.

    The constraints in the scenario select the strategies. Discuss the two or three they point to and say why the others are ruled out.

  • Ignoring the debt figure because it is not a development strategy

    Why it happens: Debt is filed under stability rather than development.

    Debt servicing competes directly with development spending, so it constrains every option and belongs in the evaluation.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

6 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of development aid as a strategy for promoting economic development.

The attempt

2 out of 6

Development aid is money given by developed countries to developing countries to help them develop. It can be bilateral, from one country to another, or multilateral, through organisations like the World Bank. Aid has many advantages: it funds infrastructure, education and health care, and it does not have to be repaid like a loan. However, aid has been criticised because the amount given is well below the 0.7 per cent target that was set, and some aid is tied to buying goods from the donor country. Corruption in recipient countries can also mean the money does not reach the poor. Overall, aid has been somewhat effective but more is needed.

What the marker sees

Two marks. The definitions are correct, the distinction between bilateral and multilateral is made, and three genuine criticisms appear, so the material is there. The response does not evaluate. No objective is stated, so "effective" has nothing to be effective against; no figure is attached to the shortfall, which is the easiest quantification available; no outcome evidence appears at all, either for or against; and there is no opportunity cost or comparison with another strategy, so the conclusion that "more is needed" does not follow from anything. The closing sentence is a hedge, not a judgement.

The same answer, fixed

6 out of 6

Aid should be evaluated against what it is capable of doing, which is funding investment that a poor economy cannot finance from its own saving and does not have to service afterwards. On that criterion its effectiveness is mixed and predictable: strong where it is directed at specific outcomes, weak as a general transfer.

The quantity is the first problem and it is measurable. The target of 0.7 per cent of national income was set in 1970 and is met by a handful of donors; the committee average has been around half of it, with a high point near 0.36 per cent. Part of what is counted never reaches the recipient economy: money spent housing refugees inside the donor country is counted as aid, and it rose sharply after 2022; aid tied to purchases from the donor raises the cost of what is bought; and around one dollar in six is technical cooperation paid to consultants in donor economies. The published figure therefore overstates delivery, which is why quoting both the shortfall and the composition is stronger than quoting either.

The quality evidence runs the other way, and this is where the evaluation has to be two sided. Aid directed at measurable outcomes works: immunisation, malaria prevention and schooling programmes have produced outcomes that can be dated and counted, and multilateral aid is better targeted at the poorest economies than bilateral aid, which follows donor interests. Conditional cash transfer programmes, often donor supported, are among the best evidenced development interventions, with consistent effects on enrolment and nutrition.

Its limits are structural rather than accidental. Aid is small beside the sums involved: it is dwarfed by remittances, which now exceed both aid and foreign direct investment for many low income economies, and it cannot substitute for the growth that creates jobs for the people it educates. Against the alternative uses of the same effort, improving trade access for the goods developing economies actually export, or restructuring debt so that servicing does not compete with health spending, aid is not obviously the highest return option, which is the opportunity cost that most evaluations omit.

The judgement is therefore specific rather than balanced. Aid is effective as a targeted instrument for health and education outcomes, where the evidence is good and the mechanism is short, and it is ineffective as a general strategy for development, because it is too small, partly consumed before it arrives, and aimed at symptoms rather than at the constraints that produce them.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 20 min

10 marks

Evaluate the effectiveness of strategies used to promote economic development, with reference to contemporary examples.

Hint 1Set criteria in the first paragraph and apply the same ones to each strategy, so the response is an evaluation and not a survey.

Hint 2Use at least one strategy that worked and one that did not, and explain the difference rather than reporting it.

Hint 3Address transferability: the conditions that made the successes work have changed since.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing each strategy in turn and adding a judgement only in the conclusion

    Why it happens: The material is stored as a list of strategies, so it is reproduced as one.

    Apply the criteria inside each paragraph so the judgement is built through the response rather than appended.

  • Using only successful examples

    Why it happens: Failures are less revised and feel risky to raise.

    A failure with an explained mechanism, such as import substitution or microfinance, demonstrates the criteria better than another success.

  • Recommending the East Asian model as a general prescription

    Why it happens: It is the best documented success, so it becomes the default recommendation.

    Name the conditions that made it work and what has changed since, then say for which economies it still applies.

Written for this site.