HSC Study

Causes of Balance of Payments Trends

The four causes the syllabus names, international competitiveness, the terms of trade, international borrowing and foreign investment, and how each moves the balance on goods and services or net primary income.

45 min · HSC Topic Two - Australia's Place in the Global Economy

Assumes you have read Trends in the Balance of Payments.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

CauseMain channelRecent direction
International competitiveness: relative prices, set by costs and the exchange rateExport and import volumes, so the balance on goods and servicesThe dollar is well below its 2011 peak, which helps; slow productivity growth hurts
Terms of trade: export prices ÷ import prices × 100Export and import values, so the balance on goods and services; also mining profits paid abroadPeaked at 115.8 in the June quarter 2022, down to 94.8 by the June quarter 2026
International borrowing: net foreign debtInterest debits on net primary incomeNet foreign debt 51.4 per cent of GDP in 2026; interest cost up sharply since 2022
Foreign investment: foreign ownership of Australian assetsDividend and profit debits on net primary income, plus inflows on the KAFAReturns paid to foreign owners of mines rose with the 2022 price boom and have since fallen

International competitiveness

AnswersHow does international competitiveness affect the balance of payments?

International competitiveness

The ability of an economy's producers to sell goods and services abroad and against imports at home. It depends mostly on relative prices, and also on quality, reliability and innovation.

Competitiveness sets the volume of exports Australia sells and the volume of imports it buys, and so the balance on goods and services. Your notes give two measures.

  • Real unit labour costs: how fast wages rise compared with productivity and prices. If Australian costs rise faster than competitors', Australian goods become dearer and competitiveness falls.
  • The real trade weighted index: the value of the dollar against trading partners, adjusted for relative inflation. An appreciation makes Australian exports dearer in foreign currency and imports cheaper in dollars, reducing competitiveness. A depreciation does the reverse.

A rise in either index means a loss of competitiveness; a fall means a gain.

The exchange rate has done most of the work since 2010. The nominal trade weighted index was 78.4 in July 2011, at the height of the mining boom, when the dollar bought US$1.10. That strength hurt manufacturing, tourism and education exports, the Dutch disease effect in your notes: the mining boom's high dollar squeezed other trade exposed industries. The index fell to 54.7 by March 2020 and was 66.2 in August 2026, giving non-mining exporters more room.

The Australian dollar since 1970At the end of August 2026 one Australian dollar bought 71.66 United States cents and the TWI stood at 66.2.Fixed and managedFloating197019801990200020102020406080100120140160YearUS cents per A$1, and TWI
  • Trade weighted index, May 1970 = 100
  • US cents per A$1
Before the float the line moves in steps, because each change was a decision. After it the line moves every day, and its largest movements follow the terms of trade: down in the mid 1980s and late 1990s, up through the mining boom to above parity in 2011, down again to 2015. The TWI moves less than the rate against the United States dollar, because a change in the United States dollar itself moves only one of the currencies in the basket.
2026.63
End of August 2026
US$0.7166, TWI 66.2
Exchange rate system
Floating: set by supply and demand in the foreign exchange market since 12 December 1983.
What was happening
The Reserve Bank raises the cash rate in February, March and May 2026 to fight inflation, and the dollar rises above US$0.72.
Month end range since the float
US$0.4890 in March 2001 to US$1.0954 in July 2011
Latest daily
Daily values from F11.1: the low of the 2025 tariff turmoil was US$0.5975 on 9 April 2025; the 2026 high was US$0.7258 on 14 May 2026; on 22 September 2026 the rate was US$0.7123 and the TWI 65.9. Annual averages: 0.6603 in 2024, 0.6449 in 2025 and 0.7039 in 2026 to date.
Source
Reserve Bank of Australia, Statistical table F11, Exchange rates, historical monthly data (1969 to 2009 and 2010 to current) and daily data F11.1

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Common mistake

A depreciation always improves the balance on goods and services straight away.

Why it happens: A lower dollar makes exports cheaper, so the balance should improve.

In the short run, volumes take time to adjust while import prices in dollars rise immediately, so the import bill can rise before export volumes respond. The improvement usually comes over one to two years. This is the J-curve, covered in the exchange rate effects lesson.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which change would most improve the international competitiveness of Australia's non-mining exporters?

Select one answer

Hint 1Competitiveness depends on relative prices.

Hint 2What makes Australian goods cheaper in foreign currency?

Hint 3Rising costs or a rising dollar reduce competitiveness.

The terms of trade

AnswersHow do the terms of trade affect Australia's balance of payments?

Terms of trade

The ratio of an index of export prices to an index of import prices, multiplied by 100. It measures how many imports a given volume of exports can buy.

An improvement means export prices rise faster than import prices, or fall more slowly: the same volume of exports now finances more imports. A deterioration means the reverse.

Because Australia's exports are concentrated in commodities whose prices move sharply, the terms of trade have been the largest single cause of swings in the balance on goods and services.

PeriodTerms of trade (2023-24 = 100)What happened
2003about 54Before the resources boom
September quarter 2011105.1Boom peak: China's demand for iron ore and coal
March quarter 201667.8Down about 35 per cent as Chinese growth slowed and new mine supply came on
June quarter 2022115.8Record: coal and gas prices surged after Russia invaded Ukraine
June quarter 202694.8Down about 18 per cent from the peak as energy and iron ore prices eased

Source: ABS, Australian National Accounts, June quarter 2026: export price deflator over import price deflator, seasonally adjusted.

Australia’s terms of tradeIn the June quarter 2026 the terms of trade index was 94.8, against a peak of 115.8.Mining boom1960197019801990200020102020406080100120YearIndex, 2023-24 = 100
  • Terms of trade
For forty years the terms of trade drifted around a flat or falling trend, as the long run theory of commodity prices predicted. The mining boom broke the pattern: the index roughly doubled between 2003 and 2011, fell by about 40 per cent to 2016, and set a new record in 2022 when energy prices spiked. Every large movement has been in export prices, because what Australia sells is concentrated in a few commodities while what it buys is a broad basket whose price moves slowly.
The numbers behind this graph
Financial yearTerms of trade, average
1959-6057.9
1960-6155.6
1961-6256.0
1962-6357.1
1963-6463.0
1964-6560.1
1965-6660.0
1966-6759.7
1967-6857.2
1968-6958.9
1969-7059.8
1970-7156.1
1971-7252.5
1972-7362.3
1973-7467.6
1974-7561.0
1975-7658.3
1976-7756.7
1977-7851.6
1978-7951.7
1979-8053.8
1980-8153.1
1981-8252.2
1982-8351.7
1983-8452.6
1984-8552.1
1985-8647.0
1986-8744.6
1987-8848.4
1988-8955.4
1989-9055.8
1990-9152.9
1991-9251.1
1992-9349.1
1993-9447.7
1994-9549.4
1995-9650.9
1996-9752.4
1997-9852.0
1998-9949.5
1999-0051.4
2000-0152.4
2001-0253.1
2002-0353.9
2003-0457.8
2004-0563.4
2005-0670.1
2006-0775.2
2007-0879.4
2008-0985.1
2009-1081.9
2010-1198.9
2011-1299.1
2012-1389.9
2013-1486.7
2014-1577.5
2015-1669.8
2016-1779.7
2017-1881.2
2018-1985.9
2019-2086.5
2020-2195.2
2021-22106.9
2022-23106.7
2023-24100.0
2024-2595.9
2025-2695.4
2026.4
June quarter 2026
94.8
Change on a year earlier
-0.5 per cent
Peak
115.8 in the June quarter 2022
What was happening
Fuel, fertiliser and plastics import prices rise during the Middle East conflict and the index falls 1.6 per cent in the June quarter.
How it is measured
Ratio of the implicit price deflator for exports to that for imports, seasonally adjusted, quarterly.
Source
Australian Bureau of Statistics, Australian National Accounts: National Income, Expenditure and Product, Table 1, Key national accounts aggregates, June quarter 2026

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

A change in the terms of trade reaches the current account through three channels.

Chain of reasoning

A rise in the terms of trade

  1. Export income rises

    Higher commodity prices raise the value of exports: the balance on goods and services improves
  2. Foreign owned mining profits rises

    Much of the mining industry is foreign owned, so dividends and reinvested earnings paid abroad rise: net primary income worsens
  3. Australian dollar rises

    Demand for Australian dollars rises and the dollar appreciates, reducing the competitiveness of other exports

Where it breaks: The net effect on the current account is usually an improvement, but smaller than the rise in export income, because channels 2 and 3 offset part of it.

All three showed in 2022-23. The goods surplus was a record A$151.9 billion, but equity income paid to foreign owners was also near record levels, and the primary income deficit reached A$112.2 billion.

Exam question

Standard · about 3 min

2 marks

In a base year an economy's export price index and import price index are both 100. The next year the export price index is 88 and the import price index is 104.

Calculate the terms of trade index for the second year, to one decimal place.

Hint 1Terms of trade = export price index ÷ import price index × 100.

Hint 288 ÷ 104.

Hint 3Multiply by 100.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Giving 118.2.

    Why it happens: The ratio is inverted.

    Export prices go on top.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 6 min

4 marks

Explain how the rise in Australia's terms of trade to a record 115.8 in the June quarter 2022 affected the current account. (4 marks)

Hint 1Start with export income and the balance on goods and services.

Hint 2Who owns much of Australia's mining industry, and where do their profits go?

Hint 3What happens to the dollar, and to other exporters?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Stopping at the trade balance.

    Why it happens: The export effect is the obvious one.

    Follow the profits: in a foreign owned industry they come back as primary income debits.

Written for this site.

International borrowing

AnswersHow does international borrowing affect Australia's balance of payments?

A current account deficit must be financed by a surplus on the capital and financial account, through debt or equity. Since net foreign equity became an asset in 2013, all of Australia's net foreign liabilities are debt. At 30 June 2026 net foreign debt was A$1,486.0 billion, 51.4 per cent of GDP, down from a peak of 64.6 per cent in 2016.

Foreign debt affects the balance of payments in three ways.

  1. Interest payments are primary income debits. They are the structural base of the primary income deficit and so of the current account deficit.
  2. The debt servicing ratio, interest paid as a share of export income, measures the burden. It depends on both the numerator, the stock of debt times the interest rate, and the denominator, export income.
  3. Repayments of principal are recorded in the financial account, not the current account.
Debt servicing ratio

Net interest paid on foreign debt as a percentage of export income. It shows how much of each dollar earned from exports is needed to pay interest on foreign debt.

YearDebt servicing ratio (per cent of exports)Why
1988-8917.6High world and Australian interest rates, rapid debt growth in the 1980s
2007-0812.0Debt growth and rising world rates before the global financial crisis
2021-223.5Near zero world interest rates, record export income
2025-267.2World interest rates up from 2022, export income down with commodity prices
Net foreign liabilities: debt, equity and the cost of servicing themAt 30 June 2026 net foreign liabilities were 22.1 per cent of GDP, made up of net foreign debt of 51.4 per cent and net foreign equity of -29.3 per cent.Equity turns to a net asset19901995200020052010201520202025-30-15015304560At 30 JuneShare of GDP (%)
  • Net foreign debt
  • Net foreign equity
  • Net foreign liabilities
Net foreign debt has stayed near half of GDP for three decades while net foreign equity went from a liability to a large asset, mostly because superannuation funds have bought shares abroad. So Australia’s net liability to the world has fallen from about 60 per cent of GDP in 2016 to 22 per cent in 2026, and all of what remains is debt. The servicing cost follows world interest rates and export income, not only the size of the debt.
The numbers behind this graph
30 JuneNet liabilities, % of GDPNet equity, % of GDPNet debt, % of GDP
198940.99.831.1
199042.910.732.3
199146.612.234.3
199249.311.238.1
199350.310.839.5
199451.315.036.3
199552.114.237.9
199652.416.535.9
199752.615.936.6
199850.613.137.4
199951.916.235.7
200050.010.239.8
200152.110.841.3
200248.77.441.3
200351.99.142.7
200452.39.043.2
200554.19.244.9
200653.14.848.3
200756.27.648.6
200855.45.050.4
200954.45.548.8
201057.86.051.8
201153.97.146.9
201254.14.349.8
201352.6-0.352.9
201454.0-1.555.6
201554.4-5.960.2
201662.6-2.064.6
201756.6-2.258.8
201856.7-4.461.1
201955.0-7.462.4
202053.2-6.559.6
202144.9-14.159.0
202238.5-11.750.2
202332.6-12.745.3
202425.5-20.345.8
202524.5-25.550.0
202622.1-29.351.4
1
2026
Net foreign liabilities, June 2026
22.1 per cent of GDP
Net foreign debt
51.4 per cent of GDP
Net foreign equity
-29.3 per cent of GDP, a net asset
Reading it
Above zero is a liability, what Australia owes the rest of the world net of what it owns there. Net foreign equity below zero means Australians own more shares and businesses abroad than foreigners own in Australia.
June quarter 2026
The net liability fell by A$122.8 billion in the June quarter 2026: price changes reduced it by A$151.0 billion, mostly falls in the value of Australian equity liabilities relative to assets, while transactions added A$7.6 billion and exchange rate changes A$23.0 billion.
Source
Australian Bureau of Statistics, Balance of Payments and International Investment Position, Australia, Table 29 and 23, International investment position, historical summary, and selected international accounts ratios, June quarter 2026 release

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Your notes list the risks of a large net foreign debt:

  • a rise in world interest rates raises the servicing cost, as happened from 2022;
  • a fall in export income raises the servicing ratio, as also happened from 2023;
  • a large stock of debt may threaten Australia's credit rating and raise the cost of future borrowing;
  • a high debt to GDP ratio can create a sustainability problem.

One feature limits the risk. Australia has a net foreign currency asset position: its foreign currency assets, mostly super funds' foreign shares, exceed its foreign currency liabilities, and much of its foreign debt is in Australian dollars or hedged. So a depreciation of the dollar reduces net foreign liabilities measured in dollars, because foreign assets rise in dollar value by more than foreign currency debts.

Common mistake

A depreciation increases Australia's foreign debt burden.

Why it happens: That is true for economies whose debt is in foreign currency, and it is the standard textbook case.

Australia is the exception. Most of its foreign debt is in Australian dollars or hedged, and its foreign currency assets exceed its foreign currency liabilities, so a depreciation lowers net foreign liabilities in dollar terms.

Exam question

Standard · about 3 min

2 marks

An economy has net foreign debt of 1,200 billion dollars on which it pays an average interest rate of 5 per cent. Its export income is 750 billion dollars.

Calculate the debt servicing ratio, in per cent.

Hint 1First find the interest paid.

Hint 2Interest = 5% of 1,200.

Hint 3Divide interest by export income and multiply by 100.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Dividing by GDP instead of exports.

    Why it happens: Most ratios in the topic are shares of GDP.

    The debt servicing ratio uses export income.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 5 min

3 marks

Australia's debt servicing ratio rose from 3.5 per cent in 2021-22 to 7.2 per cent in 2025-26. Explain the causes of this rise and its effect on the current account. (3 marks)

Hint 1The ratio has a numerator and a denominator.

Hint 2What happened to world interest rates from 2022?

Hint 3What happened to export income as commodity prices fell?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Explaining the rise only by more borrowing.

    Why it happens: Borrowing seems the obvious cause.

    Net foreign debt fell as a share of GDP; rates and export income moved the ratio.

Written for this site.

Foreign investment

AnswersHow does foreign investment affect Australia's balance of payments?

Governments have encouraged foreign investment because it fills the gap between domestic saving and investment. Its growth reflects the relaxation of investment controls, cheaper communication and transport, and the spread of global supply chains run by transnational corporations.

It affects both accounts.

  • Capital and financial account. Inflows of direct and portfolio investment are credits. In 2025-26 net direct investment into Australia was A$63.1 billion, the largest single part of the KAFA surplus.
  • Net primary income. Foreign owners earn dividends, profits and rent, all primary income debits. Reinvested earnings count too, even though the money stays in Australia. Equity income debits were A$100.9 billion in 2025-26.
  • Balance on goods and services, over time. Foreign investment in mines and gas fields built the export capacity that produces today's goods surplus. The investment first adds to imports, of equipment and services, and later adds to exports.

At the end of 2025 foreign investment in Australia totalled A$5,116.3 billion. The largest investors were the United States (26.6 per cent) and the United Kingdom (16.4 per cent). Direct investment made up 25.5 per cent of the total.

The cost your notes emphasise is the repatriation of income: profits, dividends, rent and interest flowing out as primary income debits. Others are loss of control over resources and decisions, which the Foreign Investment Review Board manages; exposure to sudden outflows of portfolio investment; and tax avoidance by transnational corporations.

Exam question

Harder · about 2 min

1 mark

A student writes: 'Foreign investment in Australian mines only affects the capital and financial account, because it is an inflow of capital.' What is wrong with this?

Select one answer

Hint 1What do foreign owners of a mine receive each year?

Hint 2Where are those payments recorded?

Hint 3What does the mine produce?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating a capital inflow as a one-off.

    Why it happens: The inflow is recorded once.

    Its returns are paid every year for as long as it is owned.

Written for this site.

Which cause matters most, and when

Over a few years, the terms of trade dominate: they explain almost all of the swing from surplus to deficit since 2021-22. Over decades, international borrowing and foreign investment dominate: they explain why the primary income deficit, and so the current account deficit, is the normal state. Competitiveness is slower and smaller, but it decides whether Australia can broaden its export base beyond commodities, which is what would make the terms of trade matter less.

A strong answer ranks the causes like this and links them. A terms of trade boom raises the dollar, which reduces competitiveness, and raises foreign owned mining profits, which widens the primary income deficit. A single shock moves three of the four causes.