Causes and Effects of External Instability
The structural and cyclical causes of Australia's current account deficits and foreign liabilities, the factors that improve or worsen external stability, and a discussion of the positive and negative effects of a continued current account deficit on the economy.
45 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues
Assumes you have read Trends in External Stability and Effects of Balance of Payments Trends.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- The root cause is that Australia invests more than it saves. The current account deficit (CAD) equals investment minus national saving, and the gap is filled with foreign capital.
- Structural causes keep the deficit persistent: the savings and investment gap, the primary income deficit on past borrowing, a narrow commodity export base and a high propensity to import.
- Cyclical causes make it swing: the terms of trade, domestic and world growth, the exchange rate and world interest rates.
- Positive causes of a stronger external position: higher export prices, new export capacity, fiscal surpluses, compulsory superannuation and productivity growth.
- Negative effects of a continued CAD: rising foreign liabilities and servicing costs, a risk premium on interest rates, exchange rate volatility, a balance of payments constraint on growth and vulnerability to a sudden loss of investor confidence.
- Positive effects: foreign savings fund investment, growth, jobs and export capacity above what domestic saving allows.
- Judgement: a continued deficit is sustainable if it funds productive investment, is privately financed, and export income grows faster than the servicing cost. Australia meets these tests, but rising debt and interest costs are the risk to watch.
The root cause: saving less than we invest
AnswersWhy does Australia run current account deficits?
National accounts give an identity that links the current account to domestic decisions:
When Australians (households, businesses and government together) want to invest more than they save, the difference must be borrowed from, or sold to, the rest of the world. That inflow is a surplus on the capital and financial account, and its mirror is a current account deficit. In 2025-26 the CAD of 3.2 per cent of GDP meant that investment exceeded national saving by roughly 3 per cent of GDP.
Australia has a large, resource-rich economy with a growing population and many profitable investment opportunities in mining, housing and infrastructure. Its domestic saving has rarely been enough to fund them all. That is why the deficit is structural: it has persisted for most of the last 60 years.
Twin deficits. Your notes explain the link with the budget. A budget deficit is dissaving by the government, which lowers national saving. In an open economy the crowding out effect is weaker than in a closed one, because private borrowers can turn to foreign funds instead. So the gap is filled from overseas: foreign debt rises, net primary income debits rise and the CAD widens. This is why fiscal consolidation is part of the policy mix for external stability.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which statement best explains why Australia has run current account deficits in most years since 1960?
Hint 1Use the identity linking the current account to saving and investment.
Hint 2Where does the gap come from?
Hint 3Think structural, not cyclical.
Structural and cyclical causes
AnswersWhat causes changes in Australia's external stability?
| Cause | How it works | Recent evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Primary income deficit (structural) | Past deficits built up foreign liabilities; interest, dividends and profits paid on them are debits every year | 3.0 per cent of GDP in 2025-26, almost the whole CAD |
| Narrow export base (structural) | Exports are dominated by iron ore, coal and gas, whose prices swing with world demand, especially China's | The goods surplus fell from $151.9 billion in 2022-23 to $27.4 billion in 2025-26 as commodity prices eased |
| High propensity to import (structural) | Much consumption and business equipment is imported, so faster growth raises imports quickly | Imports and overseas travel recovered strongly after the pandemic |
| Terms of trade (cyclical) | Higher export prices raise export income and narrow the CAD | Record terms of trade in 2021-22 helped produce a surplus |
| Domestic and world growth (cyclical) | Faster domestic growth raises imports; faster world growth raises exports | The 2020 recession cut imports faster than exports |
| Exchange rate and competitiveness (cyclical) | An appreciation, or inflation above trading partners', makes exports dearer and imports cheaper | Real TWI up about 13 per cent in the year to June 2026 |
| World interest rates (cyclical) | Higher rates raise interest paid on foreign debt | Debt servicing ratio up from 3.3 per cent (2020-21) to 7.2 per cent (2025-26) |
Your notes stress the link between economic growth and external stability. In the short run, higher growth raises import spending, because much of Australia's consumption and business inputs are imported, so the trade balance worsens. It also raises business profits, and because much Australian equity (especially in mining) is foreign owned, more dividends flow overseas, widening the primary income deficit. The reverse happened in 2020: the fall in growth cut imports faster than exports and helped turn the current account to surplus.
Chain of reasoning
Why growth can widen the deficit
Domestic demand rises
Households and firms spend more as incomes riseImports rises
A large share of consumer goods and capital equipment is importedProfits paid overseas rises
Foreign-owned firms earn more and pay more dividends abroadCurrent account deficit rises
The trade and primary income balances both worsen
Where it breaks: The effect is weaker if the growth comes from exports, or if new investment adds export capacity.
Positive causes. Several developments have strengthened Australia's external position:
- Higher export capacity. The mining and LNG investment of the 2010s raised export volumes for decades.
- Compulsory superannuation. It raised national saving and built large equity holdings abroad, turning net foreign equity into a net asset of 29.3 per cent of GDP.
- Fiscal consolidation. Budget surpluses in 2022-23 and 2023-24 reduced government borrowing.
- Productivity growth and microeconomic reform lower costs and improve competitiveness.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Distinguish between structural and cyclical causes of Australia's current account deficit, using one example of each with recent data. (4 marks)
Hint 1Structural causes persist over decades.
Hint 2Cyclical causes swing with the economy and world prices.
Hint 3Primary income; terms of trade.
Exam question
Standard · about 5 min
3 marks
Explain how a rise in world interest rates can reduce Australia's external stability. (3 marks)
Hint 1Net foreign debt.
Hint 2Primary income and the CAD.
Hint 3The debt servicing ratio.
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying higher rates improve the CAD by attracting capital.
Why it happens: Higher rates attract inflows.
Inflows finance the CAD; they do not reduce it, and servicing costs rise.
Written for this site.
Negative effects of a continued deficit
AnswersWhat are the negative effects of a continued current account deficit?
Your notes list the risks of a sustained high CAD. Each works through the stock of liabilities that the deficit builds up.
- Rising foreign liabilities. Each deficit is financed by borrowing or selling assets, so liabilities grow. Lenders may become reluctant to keep lending.
- Rising servicing costs. More liabilities mean more interest and dividends paid abroad, which widens the primary income deficit and next year's CAD. This is the debt trap: deficits create liabilities, which create future deficits.
- A risk premium on interest rates. Lenders may demand a higher rate from a heavily indebted economy, raising borrowing costs for Australian households and firms.
- Exchange rate volatility. A large deficit relies on a steady inflow of funds. If investors doubt it can be serviced, demand for the dollar falls and it can depreciate sharply.
- A balance of payments constraint on growth. If growth pushes the CAD to an unsustainable level, the economy cannot keep growing that fast. Governments may tighten macroeconomic policy, as in 1988-89 when high interest rates were used partly to rein in import spending, contributing to the 1990-91 recession.
- A sudden loss of investor confidence. Economies with large deficits and foreign currency debt are exposed to a sudden stop in capital inflows. Sri Lanka defaulted on its foreign debt in 2022 after its foreign exchange reserves ran out.
Your notes add the risks of a large net foreign debt: a rise in world interest rates or a fall in export income raises the debt servicing ratio, and a very large debt could threaten Australia's AAA credit rating and raise its borrowing costs.
How real are these risks for Australia now? Net foreign liabilities are the lowest since at least 1989 and most debt is in Australian dollars or hedged, so risks 1, 4 and 6 are low. The risk that has grown is the servicing cost: with net debt at 51.4 per cent of GDP and higher world interest rates, the debt servicing ratio has more than doubled since 2020-21 to 7.2 per cent of exports.
Common mistake
A current account deficit means Australia is losing money, so it is always bad for the economy.
Why it happens: Deficit sounds like a loss.
A CAD means Australia is using foreign savings to fund investment and spending. Whether that is good or bad depends on what the funds are used for and whether the returns cover the cost of servicing them. Borrowing to build an LNG plant that exports for 30 years is very different from borrowing to fund consumption.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Analyse TWO negative effects of a continued current account deficit on an economy. (4 marks)
Hint 1Liabilities and servicing costs.
Hint 2The balance of payments constraint.
Hint 3Investor confidence and the exchange rate.
Positive effects of a continued deficit
AnswersHow can a continued current account deficit benefit an economy?
A continued CAD is the other side of a continued inflow of foreign capital. Your notes list the benefits of foreign investment:
- Higher investment and growth. Foreign savings let Australia invest more than it saves, supporting higher growth, employment and living standards than domestic saving alone would allow.
- Export capacity. Much foreign investment has gone into mining and gas projects that now earn export income, which helps service the liabilities.
- Technology and competitiveness. Foreign direct investment brings technology, management expertise and access to global supply chains, raising productivity.
- Consumption smoothing. Borrowing lets the economy maintain spending through a temporary shock, such as a fall in the terms of trade, rather than cutting it sharply.
The consenting adults view. If the deficit reflects the saving and investment decisions of private households and firms, without government distortions, the borrowers and lenders have weighed the risks themselves, so the deficit is not a problem for policy. Most of Australia's foreign debt is owed by the private sector, mainly banks. The weakness of this view is its assumption that private borrowers and lenders judge risk correctly. The global financial crisis of 2008 showed they can misjudge it badly.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain how a continued current account deficit can benefit an economy such as Australia's. (3 marks)
Hint 1Saving and investment.
Hint 2Export capacity.
Hint 3Technology and productivity.
Discussing the effect of a continued deficit
AnswersIs a continued current account deficit a problem?
A strong discussion does not just list both sides. It identifies the conditions that decide which side wins.
| Condition | Deficit is less of a concern if… | Australia, 2025-26 |
|---|---|---|
| Size | It is below about 4 to 5 per cent of GDP | 3.2 per cent |
| Use of the funds | It finances productive investment rather than consumption | Mostly private investment, channelled through banks and firms |
| Who borrows | The private sector, not the government | Mostly private, especially banks |
| Currency of the debt | It is in the domestic currency or hedged | Mostly Australian dollars or hedged |
| Growth versus interest | Export income and GDP grow faster than the interest on the debt | Debt servicing ratio rising, 7.2 per cent |
| Stock of liabilities | Liabilities are stable or falling as a share of GDP | 22.1 per cent, lowest since at least 1989 |
A continued deficit keeps foreign liabilities stable as a share of GDP if the deficit is no larger than growth in nominal GDP times the liabilities ratio. With nominal growth of about 5 per cent, a deficit of 3 per cent of GDP would eventually take liabilities to about 60 per cent of GDP (see the worked example in the Topic 2 lesson on the effects of balance of payments trends). That is high, but similar to where Australia was in the 2000s and 2010s without a crisis.
A judgement. For Australia, a continued deficit of around 3 per cent of GDP is sustainable: it is privately financed, largely funds investment, carries little currency risk and starts from a low stock of liabilities. It is not costless. The deficit is now driven almost entirely by income paid abroad, net debt and its servicing cost are rising, and the trade surplus that offsets them depends on commodity prices set by demand from China. The main risk is not a crisis but a slow drain on national income and a reduced buffer if commodity prices fall further.
Exam question
Harder · about 14 min
8 marks
Discuss the effects of a continued current account deficit on the Australian economy. (8 marks)
Hint 1Negative effects through liabilities.
Hint 2Positive effects through investment.
Hint 3Conditions and a judgement.
Where students lose marks on this one
Listing effects without a judgement.
Why it happens: Discuss sounds like describe.
Weigh the effects and state which dominates, and why.
Written for this site.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'A depreciation of the Australian dollar would push Australia into a debt crisis because its foreign debt would become much larger.' Which response is best?
Hint 1What currency is most of the debt in?
Hint 2Hedging.
Hint 3What happens to foreign assets?
Why Australia is not Sri Lanka
Many countries have run deficits for decades without a crisis, and others have had crises with smaller deficits. The difference is what the debt is in and who holds it. Crises happen when a country has large debts in a foreign currency, low reserves and a fixed or managed exchange rate: a depreciation then raises the debt burden, and lenders stop rolling it over. Australia borrows mostly in its own currency or hedges it, has a floating exchange rate that absorbs shocks, and holds more foreign currency assets than liabilities. So a depreciation reduces Australia's net foreign liabilities, because the Australian dollar value of its assets abroad rises. In 2024-25, when the TWI fell from 63.3 to 60.1, exchange rate changes cut net foreign liabilities by $48.8 billion. In 2025-26, when it rose to 64.6, they added $105.0 billion.
The deficit has changed character
In the 1980s and 2000s the deficit reflected a large savings and investment gap: Australia was borrowing to build things. Today, with the goods and services balance close to balance, the deficit is almost all primary income: the return paid on past borrowing and on foreign ownership of Australian firms. That is less a sign of new borrowing than of the cost of the old, and it will fall only if export income grows or foreign ownership declines.