HSC Study

Assessing International Organisations and Trade Agreements

The skill the syllabus asks for by name: judging what the WTO, the IMF, the World Bank and a trading bloc agreement have actually done to the global economy, using a counterfactual instead of a list of functions.

70 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read Economic Forums: the G7 and the G20 and Multilateral and Bilateral Agreements.

The full teaching. Start here.

Assesstypically 5 to 8 marks

Demands
Make a judgement of value, size or significance, and support it.
Shape
Criteria, evidence against them, then a stated judgement. The judgement must be visible.
Loses marks
Presenting balanced evidence and never committing to a verdict.
Counterfactual

What would have happened without the thing being assessed. It cannot be observed, which is why an assessment argues for one rather than assuming it, usually by pointing to a comparable case, a period before the body existed, or an episode where it failed to act.

Trade creation

Trade that exists because an agreement removed a barrier: a higher cost domestic producer is replaced by a lower cost partner producer. It raises welfare, because the same goods are produced using fewer resources.

Trade diversion

Trade that shifts from the lowest cost world supplier to a higher cost partner, only because the partner's goods now enter duty free. It can lower welfare, because the resource cost rises and the government loses the tariff revenue.

A method that works for any organisation or agreement

Every assessment question on this material can be answered with the same five steps. Learn the steps rather than a verdict, because the verdict changes with the body being assessed and with the year the question is set.

StepThe question it answersWhat goes wrong without it
PurposeWhat was this body set up to do?The response judges the WTO for failing at something it was never given the power to do
MechanismHow does it act on the global economy?The impact is asserted rather than traced
EvidenceWhat has changed that can be measured or dated?The response is a definition with an adjective
CounterfactualWhat would have happened without it?Everything that happened after 1995 is credited to the WTO
JudgementHow large is the effect, and in which direction?A list ends with "therefore it is very important"

The step most often missing is the fourth, and it is the one that separates bands. World trade grew enormously after 1995; so did container shipping, the internet and China's industrial capacity. The honest assessment is that the organisations lowered the cost and the risk of trading rather than causing the trade, and the way to argue it is to point at cases where the rules were the binding constraint: a small economy winning a dispute against a large one, tariff bindings that stopped a trade war during the financial crisis, or the absence of any forum since the Appellate Body stopped functioning.

Common mistake

Assessing an organisation by listing its functions and adding an evaluative adjective

Why it happens:

"The WTO promotes free trade, settles disputes and provides a forum for negotiation, so it has been very effective" contains three correct facts and no assessment. "The WTO's dispute system was effective while it functioned, and since the Appellate Body lost its quorum in December 2019 there has been no binding forum for appeals, so a small economy now has no enforceable remedy against a large one" contains one fact, one date and a judgement about size and direction.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A response claims that the WTO caused the growth in world trade since 1995, citing the rise in trade volumes over that period. What is the weakness in the argument?

Select one answer

Hint 1What else changed in the world economy over the same thirty years?

Hint 2An assessment compares what happened with what would have happened otherwise.

Hint 3What is the strongest evidence that the rules mattered, if not the trade volume itself?

Assessing the organisations, function by function

An organisation is rarely effective or ineffective as a whole. Split it into what it does, because the assessment usually differs by function and that difference is the argument.

The WTO has three functions and they have diverged sharply. Its rules and tariff bindings still hold, and they are the reason the 2008 crisis and the tariff conflicts since 2018 did not produce a general collapse of trade barriers in the way the 1930s did. Its dispute settlement worked well for two decades and then stopped: the Appellate Body has been unable to hear appeals since December 2019 because new members were not appointed, so a losing party can appeal into a void, and the workaround arrangement covers only the members who joined it. Its negotiating function has produced almost nothing since the Doha Round opened in 2001, with the narrow agreement on fisheries subsidies in 2022 as the notable exception. Assessed as a whole the WTO looks contradictory; assessed function by function it is a rule keeper whose enforcement and rule making have both stalled.

The IMF is assessed on whether its programmes restore stability and at what cost.

An IMF programme: closing an external gapAn outflow worth 7.0 per cent of GDP, met with a loan and an adjustment programme. Output falls 8.0 per cent at its worst, and has regained half of it 9.9 quarters in, while the external balance is closed after about 9.4 quarters.Trough 8.0%External balance closed1.7% never recovered0481216-14-12-10-8-6-4-202Quarters since the crisisPer cent (%)
  • Output, against where it started
  • External balance
This is the argument about conditionality in one picture. Adjustment restores the external balance faster and more cheaply for the lender, and it does it by deepening the recession. Larger official support does the same job with less contraction, which is the shift the IMF made between the Asian crisis programmes and its lending after 2008.
7.0 % of GDP
6.0
4.0
Gap left for domestic demand to close
1.6% of GDP
Deepest fall in output
8.0%
Quarters until half the lost output is back
9.9
Quarters until the external balance closes
9.4
Output not recovered at all
1.7%
What the model leaves out
The distribution. The contraction is borne by the people who lose work and the services that are cut, while the external balance is restored for the economy as a whole. That gap between the aggregate figure and who pays for it is the standing criticism of conditionality, and the model cannot show it.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

The recent evidence runs both ways. The allocation of special drawing rights worth about US$650 billion in 2021 delivered reserves to every member without conditions, which is the largest liquidity operation in its history and reached economies that could not borrow. Against that, the conditions attached to ordinary programmes still require fiscal contraction during a downturn, the surcharges paid by the largest and longest borrowers fall on the economies least able to pay, and the record of the programmes in the Asian crisis of 1997 remains the standard criticism. An assessment that names the 2021 allocation and the conditionality together is doing what the command word asks.

The World Bank lends for development rather than for stabilisation, and its concessional arm is the largest single source of finance for the poorest economies, which is the strongest evidence in its favour. The assessment against it is scale: total development lending is small beside the investment those economies need, and the conditions and procurement rules slow disbursement.

The OECD has no enforcement power and produced the most significant piece of recent coordination anyway. The global minimum corporate tax rate of 15 per cent, applying from 2024, limits the tax competition that let multinationals move profit to the lowest rate available. It is the clearest counterexample to the claim that international organisations can no longer agree on anything.

The G20 is a forum, not an institution, so it is assessed by whether coordination happened when it mattered. In 2009 it did, and the coordinated stimulus is the usual evidence. In 2020 the fiscal response was large but national rather than coordinated, and the Common Framework for restructuring the debt of low income economies has moved slowly because the creditor group is no longer the small club it was designed around.

What lifts this to a Band 6

Use the failures as evidence, not as a complaint. The Appellate Body paralysis is the strongest available demonstration that binding dispute settlement mattered, because it shows what the system looks like without it. An assessment built from what stopped working is usually more convincing than one built from what was promised.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Assess the impact of ONE international organisation on the global economy. Refer to contemporary evidence.

Hint 1Split the organisation into its functions; the assessment usually differs between them.

Hint 2Every claim about impact needs a date or a magnitude attached to it.

Hint 3Say how large the effect is, not only whether it is positive.

Assessing an agreement: creation against diversion

A trading bloc agreement is assessed with a piece of theory rather than a list of members, and the theory is trade creation against trade diversion.

Trade creation and trade diversion in a preferential agreementThe tariff put the price at $10.00. The agreement drops it to $8.00 and switches imports to a partner whose real cost is $8.00 against the cheapest world supplier at $6.00, so the agreement still raises welfare on net.Cheapest world supplierPrice with the tariff on everyonePrice under the agreement01020304050607005101520QuantityPrice ($)
  • Domestic demand
  • Domestic supply
  • Created by cheaper production
  • Created by higher consumption
  • Diverted from the cheapest supplier
This is why a bilateral agreement is not a smaller version of a multilateral one. Removing a tariff against everyone can only create trade. Removing it against one partner also moves purchases away from the cheapest supplier, and when the partner is far from being the cheapest, the diversion is larger than the creation and the agreement lowers welfare.
4.0 $
8.0 $
6.0 $
Domestic price before the agreement
$10.00
Domestic price after it
$8.00
Where imports come from
The partner, at its higher cost
Trade created
16.0
Trade diverted
16.0
Net effect on welfare
Gain of 0.0
What decides the sign
How close the partner is to being the cheapest supplier, and how high the tariff was. A large partner with costs near the world level creates more than it diverts. A small partner with high costs, chosen for political reasons, does the reverse, and the revenue the government loses becomes the partner’s income rather than the consumer’s saving.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

The result that earns marks is that a preferential agreement is not a step towards free trade in the way a multilateral tariff cut is. Removing a tariff for every supplier can only move production towards lower cost producers. Removing it for one supplier can move production away from the cheapest producer in the world towards a partner, and if that happens the importing economy pays more in resources and loses the tariff revenue at the same time.

Worked example4 marks

Assessing an agreement with the numbers

An economy imports 200,000 units of a good each year. Before an agreement it buys from the lowest cost world supplier at US$44 a unit and charges a tariff of US$12 a unit, so the landed price is US$56. A partner economy can supply the same good at US$46 a unit.

The economy then signs an agreement removing the tariff on the partner's goods only. Assume the quantity imported does not change.

Assess the effect of the agreement on this economy.

Work out where the imports come from after the agreement

Before the agreement: the world supplier costs US$44 plus US$12 of tariff, or US$56, and the partner costs US$46 plus US$12, or US$58. Imports come from the world supplier.

After the agreement: the world supplier still costs US$56 and the partner now costs US$46 with no tariff. Imports switch to the partner.

Value the gain to consumers

The landed price falls from US$56 to US$46, a saving of US$10 a unit.

Across 200,000 units that is US$2.0 million.

Value the loss to the government

The tariff was US$12 a unit on 200,000 units, or US$2.4 million of revenue. After the agreement the imports arrive duty free, so all of that revenue is gone.

Net the two, and say what the difference is

The economy gains US$2.0 million and loses US$2.4 million, a net loss of US$0.4 million.

The same answer comes from the resource cost directly: production has moved from a supplier using US$44 of resources a unit to one using US$46, which is US$2 a unit worse across 200,000 units.

Answer

The agreement leaves this economy worse off by about US$0.4 million a year. It is pure trade diversion: no new trade was created, and the cheapest producer was displaced by tariff preference rather than by cost.

Is that answer sensible?

The assessment does not end at the number. Three qualifications belong in a full response. The quantity was assumed fixed, and in reality a lower price raises the quantity bought, which creates some trade and offsets part of the loss. The partner's gain is not counted here, so the effect on the global economy differs from the effect on this economy. And an agreement is signed for reasons beyond this calculation, including secure access, investment rules and political alignment, none of which appear in it.

Two further tests apply to any agreement:

  • Rules of origin. A good only enters duty free if enough of it was made inside the bloc. The paperwork is a cost, and where the threshold is high it pushes firms to source from partners rather than from the cheapest supplier, which is trade diversion written into the text of the agreement.
  • Coverage. Agreements that exclude agriculture, or that phase tariffs out over twenty years, deliver much less than their headlines. Check what the agreement actually liberalised before quoting its size.

The recent agreements worth naming are the RCEP from 2022, the largest by share of world output, the CPTPP with the United Kingdom's accession completing in 2024, which makes it the first to reach beyond the Pacific, and the African Continental Free Trade Area, which is large in ambition and slow in implementation.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An economy imports 150,000 units of a good a year from the lowest cost world supplier at US$60 a unit, with a tariff of US$15 a unit. A partner economy can supply the same good at US$68 a unit. The economy signs an agreement removing the tariff on the partner's goods only, and the quantity imported does not change. Calculate the net welfare effect for this economy in United States dollars, using a negative number for a loss.

Hint 1Work out the landed price from each source before and after the agreement, to see who supplies the market.

Hint 2Consumers gain the fall in the landed price; the government loses the tariff revenue.

Hint 3Check your answer against the change in resource cost per unit, times the quantity.

Saying how large the effect is

Assessment requires size, and size is where most responses become vague. Three habits fix it.

Quantify where a figure exists. Tariff bindings covering most of world trade, the 2021 allocation of about US$650 billion in special drawing rights, a minimum corporate tax rate of 15 per cent from 2024, an appeal system out of action since December 2019: each of these is a fact with a magnitude or a date attached, and each supports a claim about size.

Rank the channels. Not every function matters equally. For the WTO the rules matter more than the negotiations, because the rules hold even when nothing new is agreed. Saying which channel dominates is itself an assessment.

Use the right counterfactual. The comparison for a trade agreement is not "no trade", it is trade under the previous tariff, and the comparison for the IMF is not "no crisis", it is a crisis without a lender of last resort. Choosing the comparison honestly is the difference between an argument and a slogan.

Common mistake

Concluding that international organisations have caused globalisation

Why it happens:

The timing does not support the strong claim. Tariffs were falling before the WTO existed, and the largest single change in world trade in this period was China's entry into world manufacturing, which was driven by domestic reform as much as by accession in 2001. The defensible claim is that the rules made the trade safe to rely on, which is why their erosion since 2019 matters more than the absence of new agreements.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'Free trade agreements always improve welfare, because removing a tariff always moves production to a lower cost producer.' What is wrong with this?

Select one answer

Hint 1Is the statement true of a tariff cut applied to every supplier equally?

Hint 2What happens to the ranking of landed prices when only one supplier is exempted?

Hint 3Where does the tariff revenue go after the agreement?

Whether the system is fragmenting

Since 2018 the direction has changed. Tariffs between the largest economies have risen, industrial policy has returned in the form of large domestic subsidy programmes in the United States and the European Union, and the rules that were supposed to discipline subsidies cannot be enforced while appeals cannot be heard. Trade has not collapsed; it has been rerouted, often through third economies, which is why the rules on where a good was really made are being tested rather than the rules on tariffs.

The assessment to make is that the organisations are being bypassed rather than abolished. Economies still sign agreements, but regionally and preferentially instead of multilaterally, and the coordination that does succeed happens in narrower forums, of which the minimum corporate tax rate is the clearest case. For an examination this is the contemporary evidence the dot point asks for, and it supports a judgement of declining effectiveness in enforcement alongside continued effectiveness in rule keeping.

Where this sits

This lesson is the skills half of the international organisations and trading blocs lessons. Its material is the evidence base for the essay planned in the trading blocs lesson, priority 14 on the contribution of organisations and agreements, and it supplies the institutional paragraph of the globalisation essay, priority 12. The evaluation skill that follows it, applied to development strategies, is the last dot point in Topic 1.

Putting it together

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 12 min

6 marks

Assess the impact of contemporary trading bloc agreements on the global economy.

Hint 1The theory is trade creation against trade diversion; use it rather than listing agreements.

Hint 2Name recent agreements with dates, and say what each actually liberalised.

Hint 3The global economy is not the same as one member economy, so separate the two.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing the members and the tariff reductions of several agreements

    Why it happens: Membership lists are concrete and easy to revise.

    The marks are in the framework. One agreement analysed with creation and diversion beats four described.

  • Assessing the effect on one member economy when the question asks about the global economy

    Why it happens: The classroom examples are usually run from one country's point of view.

    A diversion loss to the importing economy is partly a gain to the partner. The global question is about resource allocation and fragmentation, not about one country's terms.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

5 marks

Assess the impact of the World Trade Organisation on the global economy.

The attempt

2 out of 5

The WTO was established in 1995 and replaced the GATT. It has over 160 members and its role is to promote free trade by reducing protection, to settle trade disputes between member countries, and to act as a forum for trade negotiations. Since the WTO was created world trade has grown enormously and globalisation has accelerated. Many developing countries have joined, such as China in 2001, and have benefited from access to world markets. However, the Doha Round has not been completed. Overall the WTO has had a very significant positive impact on the global economy.

What the marker sees

Two marks. The functions are correct, the date and the accession of China are accurate, and the response notices that Doha failed, which is the beginning of a two sided answer. It does not assess. The growth in world trade is attributed to the WTO with no argument that the WTO caused it, which is the missing counterfactual; the failure of Doha is mentioned and then dropped rather than weighed; and the dispute settlement function, which is where the strongest recent evidence sits, is named but not examined. The final sentence is a verdict without a criterion or a magnitude, which is what "assess" requires.

The same answer, fixed

5 out of 5

The WTO's impact differs sharply by function, and an assessment has to separate them.

Its most durable contribution is rule keeping. Tariff bindings cover most of world trade and commit members to ceilings they cannot exceed without compensation. The evidence that this matters is negative and therefore strong: during the 2008 financial crisis, and through the tariff conflicts since 2018, protection rose but did not produce the general collapse of trade barriers seen in the 1930s, when no such commitments existed.

Its dispute settlement was effective for two decades and is not now. Members brought hundreds of cases, and the system's distinctive feature was that a small economy could win against a large one. Since December 2019 the Appellate Body has been unable to hear appeals because replacement members were not appointed, so a losing party can appeal into a void and the ruling never takes effect. The workaround arrangement binds only the members who joined it. This is the clearest demonstration available that binding enforcement, rather than the existence of rules, was what made the system work.

Its negotiating function has produced very little since the Doha Round opened in 2001, with the narrow fisheries subsidies agreement of 2022 as the exception. Liberalisation has continued instead through preferential agreements such as RCEP and the CPTPP, which is a second best outcome because preferential deals can divert trade towards partners rather than towards the cheapest producer.

On size and direction, the WTO's impact on the global economy has been large but smaller than the growth of trade suggests, because falling transport and communication costs and China's domestic reform did much of the causing. The defensible judgement is that the WTO made trade predictable enough to be relied on, that this effect persists, and that its capacity to enforce and to extend the rules has declined markedly since 2019.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 25 min

10 marks

Assess the impact on the global economy of international organisations and contemporary trading bloc agreements.

Hint 1Two things are named, so the response needs both and a relationship between them.

Hint 2Separate rule keeping, enforcement and negotiation, because the assessment differs by function.

Hint 3The strongest structure judges each body as it is introduced and reserves the last paragraph for the relationship.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Answering only the organisations half of the question

    Why it happens: The organisations are taught first and have more memorable detail.

    The dot point and the question name both. An answer without agreements cannot reach the upper bands however good the first half is.

  • Treating the fragmentation of the system as a prediction of collapse

    Why it happens: The evidence of rising tariffs and stalled negotiation points one way.

    Trade has been rerouted rather than reduced. The assessable change is in the rules and the routing, and saying that is more accurate than forecasting the end of globalisation.

Written for this site.