Static and Dynamic Equilibrium
What happens when reactions do not go to completion. Reversible and irreversible reactions from the four practicals, static versus dynamic equilibrium, open and closed systems, why combustion and photosynthesis are non-equilibrium systems, and how collision theory explains a system reaching equilibrium.
55 min · Module 5: Equilibrium and Acid Reactions
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- Reversible reaction: products can react to re-form the reactants. It is shown with .
- Static equilibrium: the forward and reverse rates are both zero. Nothing is reacting.
- Dynamic equilibrium: the forward and reverse rates are equal and not zero. There is no macroscopic change, but particles keep reacting in both directions.
- Requirements for dynamic equilibrium:
- a closed system;
- a reversible reaction;
- equal forward and reverse rates;
- constant (not necessarily equal) concentrations.
- Approaching equilibrium: it can be reached from either direction.
- Non-equilibrium systems: combustion (, ) and photosynthesis (, ). In both, has the same sign at every temperature, so only one direction happens. Both also happen in open systems.
- Collision theory: as reactants are used up, the forward rate falls. As products build up, the reverse rate rises. When the rates are equal, the system is at equilibrium. A catalyst gets there faster but does not change where equilibrium lies.
Reversible and irreversible reactions
A system is the reaction itself: the reactants, the products and their energy. Everything else is the surroundings.
- In an open system, both matter and energy can be exchanged with the surroundings.
- In a closed system, only energy can be exchanged.
- An isolated system exchanges neither.
An aqueous reaction that forms a precipitate but no gas can be treated as a closed system.
All physical changes are reversible, but only some chemical changes are. The four practicals show both kinds.
Worked example4 marks
Classifying the four practicals
For each practical, give the equation and decide whether the reaction is reversible in the school laboratory.
Cobalt(II) chloride
Heating removes water; adding water brings it back.
. The pink hydrate turns blue on heating, and turns pink again when water is added. The original substance is regenerated, so the reaction is reversible.
Iron(III) thiocyanate
Both reactants are still present at the end.
, which is blood red. Adding more of either reactant deepens the colour, so both must have been left over. The reaction does not go to completion, and it is reversible.
Burning magnesium
Very exothermic, very stable product, open system.
happens with a blinding white flame. The white MgO does not turn back into magnesium. The reaction is irreversible.
Burning steel wool
The mass increases as oxygen is added.
. The iron glows and the mass increases. The oxide does not revert, so the reaction is irreversible.
Answer
Cobalt(II) chloride and iron(III) thiocyanate are reversible. The two combustion reactions are irreversible under laboratory conditions.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Steel wool is weighed, burnt in air and weighed again. What happens to its mass, and what does this suggest?
Hint 1Iron combines with something from the air.
Hint 2.
Hint 3Can iron oxide easily turn back into iron?
Exam question
Standard · about 4 min
3 marks
Pink crystals of hydrated cobalt(II) chloride, , are heated gently in a test tube and turn blue. When cooled and a few drops of water are added, they turn pink again. Write an equation for the change, and explain what the observations show about the reaction.
Hint 1Heating removes water of crystallisation.
Hint 2Write the forward and reverse changes as one equation.
Hint 3What does getting the pink colour back tell you?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying heating is the reverse reaction.
Why it happens: Both directions need identifying.
Heating forms the anhydrous salt; water re-forms the hydrate.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Standard · about 4 min
3 marks
Pale yellow iron(III) nitrate and colourless potassium thiocyanate are mixed, giving a blood-red solution containing . The mixture is split into three tubes. Adding more to one tube, or more to another, makes the red colour deeper. Explain how these observations show the reaction is reversible and does not go to completion.
Hint 1.
Hint 2If adding Fe³⁺ makes more product, what must still be present?
Hint 3Could both reactants be left over if it went to completion?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying the extra ions simply react with the red product.
Why it happens: The product is formed, not consumed, when colour deepens.
Ask what was left over to react.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Standard · about 4 min
3 marks
Magnesium ribbon burns in air with a bright white flame, forming a white powder: . Explain why this reaction is not reversible under normal conditions.
Hint 1Consider the energy released.
Hint 2What would the reverse reaction need?
Hint 3Is the system open or closed?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying it is irreversible because a solid forms.
Why it happens: Many reversible reactions involve solids.
Focus on energy, stability and the open system.
Written for this site.
Static and dynamic equilibrium
Equilibrium is a steady state: its properties are constant. There are two very different ways to get one.
Two kinds of steady
AnswersIf nothing visible is changing, how do you know whether anything is happening?
In a static equilibrium, the forward and reverse rates are both zero. No reaction is happening in either direction, so there is no change at either the macroscopic or the microscopic level. Diamond and graphite at room temperature are an example: the activation energy for converting one into the other is so high that neither direction happens.
In a dynamic equilibrium, the forward and reverse rates are equal but not zero. Particles keep reacting in both directions. Every time one molecule splits into two , somewhere else two combine. The concentrations stay constant, so the colour, pressure and mass look fixed: there is no macroscopic change. At the microscopic level, change never stops.
A dynamic equilibrium needs all of these:
- a closed system, so that no reactant or product escapes;
- a reversible reaction, with activation energies low enough in both directions;
- equal forward and reverse rates;
- constant concentrations of reactants and products, which are usually not equal to each other.
Two more properties follow. The same equilibrium can be approached from either direction. And if the equilibrium is disturbed, the system settles into a new equilibrium, different from the original one.
Worked example4 marks
Open and closed systems, and a model of dynamic equilibrium
A student places 50 mL of water in a stoppered flask and 50 mL in an open beaker, both at room temperature. Explain which can reach equilibrium, whether that equilibrium is static or dynamic, and describe a physical model that shows the difference between the two kinds of equilibrium.
The open beaker
Matter can leave an open system.
Water molecules evaporate from the beaker and escape into the room, so few return to the liquid. Evaporation keeps winning and the volume falls until the beaker is dry. No equilibrium is reached, because a product (the vapour) is being removed.
The stoppered flask
In a closed system the vapour is trapped.
At first, evaporation is faster than condensation. As vapour builds up, the condensation rate rises until it equals the evaporation rate:
The volume of liquid and the vapour pressure then stay constant.
Static or dynamic
Ask whether particles are still changing state.
Molecules keep leaving and rejoining the liquid at equal rates, so the equilibrium is dynamic. It would only be static if both processes had stopped, as for diamond and graphite.
A model
A model must show constant amounts while transfer continues.
Two students each have a measuring cylinder, one full and one empty, and a small beaker each. On each turn both transfer one beaker of water into the other cylinder at the same moment. The full cylinder loses more at first, because the empty one has little to send back. The volumes settle at constant values while the transfers carry on: a dynamic equilibrium. If both students simply stopped, the volumes would also be constant, which models a static equilibrium.
Answer
Only the stoppered flask reaches equilibrium, because it is a closed system. That equilibrium is dynamic: evaporation and condensation continue at equal rates. The two-cylinder transfer model shows constant amounts with continuing change; stopping the transfers models a static equilibrium.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which statement correctly distinguishes dynamic equilibrium from static equilibrium?
Hint 1Think about the forward and reverse rates in each.
Hint 2In one of them, nothing is reacting at all.
Hint 3In the other, both reactions continue.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
The reaction reaches equilibrium in a sealed flask. Which statement is true at equilibrium?
Hint 1Equilibrium is about rates, not amounts.
Hint 2Both reactions are still happening.
Hint 3What stays the same, and what does not have to be equal?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student says: "At equilibrium nothing is happening, because the colour of the mixture does not change." Which response is best?
Hint 1Colour is a macroscopic property.
Hint 2What is happening to individual particles?
Hint 3Dynamic equilibrium has microscopic change.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which is the best example of a static equilibrium?
Hint 1Static means no reaction in either direction.
Hint 2Look for a system where both rates are effectively zero.
Hint 3Very high activation energy can stop both directions.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which of these can reach a dynamic equilibrium?
Hint 1Equilibrium needs a closed system.
Hint 2In an open system, a gas can escape.
Hint 3Which one keeps all of its reactants and products?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
For , starting with only A, which describes the concentration–time graph once equilibrium is reached?
Hint 1What does constant concentration look like on a graph?
Hint 2Must the two lines meet?
Hint 3They only need to stop changing.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
One flask starts with mol of . An identical flask at the same temperature starts with mol of . What happens?
Hint 1.
Hint 20.20 mol NO₂ contains the same atoms as 0.10 mol N₂O₄.
Hint 3Equilibrium can be approached from either side.
Exam question
Standard · about 3 min
2 marks
Calcium carbonate decomposes when heated: . Explain why it reaches equilibrium in a sealed container but goes to completion in an open crucible.
Hint 1What happens to the CO₂ in each case?
Hint 2The reverse reaction needs CO₂.
Hint 3Open system: products escape.
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying the reaction is irreversible in the crucible.
Why it happens: The reaction itself is reversible.
It is the open system that prevents equilibrium.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Harder · about 6 min
4 marks
A model of dynamic equilibrium uses two measuring cylinders. Cylinder A starts with 100 mL of water and B is empty. Each round, a student uses a large straw to transfer water from A to B while another uses a small straw to transfer from B to A. After many rounds, the volumes stop changing. Explain how this models dynamic equilibrium, and evaluate one limitation.
Hint 1Volumes stand for concentrations.
Hint 2Why do the volumes stop changing even though transfers continue?
Hint 3What about particles and collisions?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying equilibrium occurs when both cylinders hold 50 mL.
Why it happens: The straws are different sizes.
Equal rates, not equal volumes.
Written for this site.
Common mistake
At equilibrium the concentrations of reactants and products are equal.
Why it happens: Constant and equal sound alike, and textbook graphs sometimes show the lines meeting.
At equilibrium the concentrations are constant. Where they level off depends on the reaction and the conditions. For most reactions, one side is much larger than the other.
The graph below starts with only A in the reaction A ⇌ B. Change the rate constants and watch the forward and reverse rates meet. Once they are equal, both reactions keep going, but the concentrations no longer change.
- forward rate kf[A]
- reverse rate kr[B]
- K = kf/kr = [B]/[A] at equilibrium
- 2.00
- Equilibrium [A]
- 0.333 mol L⁻¹
- Equilibrium [B]
- 0.667 mol L⁻¹
- Rate of each reaction at equilibrium
- 0.0200 mol L⁻¹ s⁻¹
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Non-equilibrium systems
Some reactions only ever go one way. The reason is thermodynamic. The Gibbs free energy change, , decides whether a reaction is spontaneous: it is spontaneous if . A reaction can come to equilibrium only when both directions are accessible. When is large and negative, the equilibrium lies so far towards the products that no reverse reaction is observed.
Non-equilibrium systems include:
- irreversible reactions, which are strongly product-favoured, often because they are strongly exothermic;
- stable reactants, which do not react under normal conditions;
- open systems, where products are lost.
Worked example3 marks
Combustion of methane
For , kJ mol and J K mol. Find at K, and explain why the reaction does not reach equilibrium.
Convert units
ΔH is in kJ, ΔS in J.
kJ K mol.
Substitute
ΔG = ΔH − TΔS.
kJ mol.
Interpret
The size and sign of ΔG decide reversibility.
is large and negative, and it is dominated by , so the reaction is enthalpy-driven. The reverse reaction would have kJ mol, far too large to happen. Burning also happens in an open system: the heat and gases disperse.
Answer
kJ mol. The reaction goes essentially to completion in one direction, so it is a non-equilibrium system.
Most combustions produce more moles of gas than they consume, so as well. The reverse then has and , and it is non-spontaneous at every temperature.
Photosynthesis is the opposite case:
It is endothermic () and builds one ordered molecule from many small ones (), so at every temperature. It happens only because light supplies a continuous input of energy. A leaf is an open system: oxygen escapes and glucose is used or stored. Respiration has the reverse overall equation, but it follows a completely different series of reactions, and each process goes to completion on its own. They are not two directions of one equilibrium.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Combustion reactions usually have and . What does this mean for the reverse reaction?
Hint 1Reverse both signs.
Hint 2.
Hint 3Is there any temperature at which ΔG would be negative?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
For photosynthesis, , which signs are correct?
Hint 1Energy must be absorbed from light.
Hint 2A single large molecule is built from many small ones.
Hint 3Count the moles of gas: 6 on each side, but a liquid is used up.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Respiration has the reverse overall equation of photosynthesis. Why do the two not form an equilibrium system?
Hint 1Compare the pathways.
Hint 2Where and how does each happen?
Hint 3Do they share intermediates?
Exam question
Standard · about 3 min
2 marks
For the combustion , kJ mol and J K mol. Calculate at K, in kJ mol.
Hint 1.
Hint 2Convert ΔS to kJ: +0.100 kJ K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
Hint 3.
Where students lose marks on this one
Using ΔS in J without converting, giving −31 844.
Why it happens: ΔH is in kJ and ΔS in J.
Divide ΔS by 1000 first.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Standard · about 3 min
2 marks
For photosynthesis, kJ mol and J K mol. Calculate at K, in kJ mol.
Hint 1.
Hint 2 kJ K mol.
Hint 3Subtracting a negative adds.
Where students lose marks on this one
Getting 2726 by subtracting 77.
Why it happens: −T × (negative) is positive.
Watch the double negative.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Harder · about 5 min
3 marks
Photosynthesis has ΔG > 0, yet it happens continuously in plants. Explain why it is classed as a non-equilibrium system, and how it proceeds.
Hint 1What supplies energy?
Hint 2Is a leaf an open or closed system?
Hint 3What happens to the products?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying it reaches equilibrium with respiration.
Why it happens: Respiration follows a different pathway.
Explain energy input and the open system.
Written for this site.
Common mistake
Photosynthesis is endothermic, so ΔH is negative.
Why it happens: The word endothermic gets linked to minus, because the surroundings lose heat.
In an endothermic reaction, the system gains energy, so . In an exothermic reaction, it loses energy, so . Photosynthesis has kJ mol.
Collision theory and reaching equilibrium
Collision theory says a reaction happens when particles collide with at least the activation energy and in the correct orientation. So the rate depends on how often successful collisions happen, which depends on concentration, temperature, surface area, pressure (for gases), stirring and catalysts.
Worked example3 marks
Explaining the approach to equilibrium
is sealed in a flask and forms : . Use collision theory to explain how equilibrium is reached.
At the start
Only reactant is present.
Only is present, so only the forward reaction occurs. Its rate is at its highest.
As the reaction proceeds
Concentration controls collision frequency.
falls, so successful collisions leading to the forward reaction become less frequent and the forward rate falls. rises, so collisions between molecules become more frequent and the reverse rate rises.
At equilibrium
Equal rates mean no net change.
The rates become equal. Each molecule of used up is replaced, so the concentrations stay constant.
Answer
The forward rate falls and the reverse rate rises until they are equal, giving a dynamic equilibrium.
For a reaction to be reversible, the activation energies of both the forward and reverse reactions must be low enough, and similar enough, that a meaningful fraction of collisions succeed in each direction. If one side is far more stable, its activation energy is huge, and that direction effectively never happens.
A catalyst lowers both activation energies by the same amount. It increases the forward and reverse rates equally, so equilibrium is reached sooner, but the equilibrium position does not change.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
For , starting with only A, how do the forward and reverse rates change as equilibrium is approached?
Hint 1At the start, how much B is there?
Hint 2As A is used up, what happens to the forward rate?
Hint 3As B builds up, what happens to the reverse rate?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
According to collision theory, which condition makes a reaction readily reversible?
Hint 1Both directions need successful collisions.
Hint 2That needs enough particles with at least Ea.
Hint 3What if one direction has a huge Ea?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A catalyst is added to a reaction mixture before it reaches equilibrium. What is the effect?
Hint 1A catalyst lowers the activation energy.
Hint 2For which direction?
Hint 3Does it change where equilibrium lies?
Exam question
Standard · about 5 min
3 marks
Use collision theory to explain how the system reaches dynamic equilibrium when and are sealed in a flask.
Hint 1Rate depends on how often particles collide successfully.
Hint 2How does the number of reactant particles change over time?
Hint 3What happens to HI collisions?
Where students lose marks on this one
Explaining only in terms of "the reaction slowing down".
Why it happens: Both directions need a collision explanation.
Describe forward and reverse collision frequencies.
Written for this site.
What lifts this to a Band 6
"Explain" questions on equilibrium are marked on rates. Say what happens to the forward rate and the reverse rate, and why, in terms of collisions. Then say the rates become equal. Answers that describe only the concentrations ("the reactants go down and the products go up") usually lose a mark.
Is anything truly irreversible?
In principle, no reaction is perfectly irreversible. Mixing products and reactants always raises entropy a little, so every reaction has some equilibrium position. The standard free energy change sets how far along it lies: .
For burning magnesium, kJ per mole of . That gives , so the amount of reactant left at equilibrium is far too small to measure. "Irreversible" really means that the equilibrium lies so far to one side that the reverse reaction can never be observed.
This link between and the equilibrium constant is why the next lessons can treat the size of as a measure of how far a reaction goes.